Soil Microbes Mediate Productivity Differences Between Natural and Plantation Forests

Xing Zhang, Mengya Yang, Yangyang Liu, Jinkun Ye, Jiechen Tangyu, Jie Gao, Wei Liu, Yuchuan FanPlants 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while climate sets the baseline for forest productivity, soil microbes play a crucial, yet distinct, role in natural versus plantation forests. Natural forests, with diverse microbial communities, exhibit stable productivity, while plantations, often simplified, show more sensitive and threshold-dependent responses, highlighting the need for tailored management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forest productivity is a critical factor in global carbon cycling and ecosystem health. While climate has long been recognized as a primary driver, its influence alone doesn't fully explain productivity variations across different forest types. Specifically, the role of soil microbial communities—their diversity, composition, and functional contributions—in mediating productivity differences between natural and human-managed plantation forests remains poorly understood, especially at broad scales. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by integrating climate, soil properties, and microbial data to disentangle the complex pathways influencing forest productivity in these two distinct forest types.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Meta-analysis and Synthesis: They compiled data from 237 observations across China, integrating metrics of forest productivity (GPP and NPP) with microbial diversity (Shannon and Chao1 indices), dominant microbial taxa, and soil properties. This synthesis allowed for a broad-scale comparison.
  • Statistical Modeling:
    • Nonlinear Regression: Used to examine the relationship between microbial diversity indices and forest productivity, revealing potential threshold effects.
  • Random Forest Models: Applied to identify the most influential environmental predictors (climate, soil) for microbial diversity in both natural and plantation forests.
  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): Employed to disentangle the direct and indirect causal relationships among climate, soil properties, microbial diversity, and forest productivity, providing a mechanistic understanding of their interactions.

Datasets

The study utilized a synthesized dataset comprising 237 observations from published peer-reviewed studies conducted in China. These studies provided data on:

  • Forest Productivity: Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and Net Primary Productivity (NPP), sourced from NASA's MOD13Q1 product.
  • Microbial Data: Bacterial and fungal diversity indices (Shannon and Chao1), dominant genera, and functional guilds, often extracted from text, tables, and figures of the original studies.
  • Environmental Data:
    • Climatic Variables: Mean Annual Temperature (MAT), Temperature Seasonality (TS), Maximum Temperature of the Warmest Month (MTWM), Annual Precipitation (MAP), Precipitation Seasonality (PS), and Precipitation of the Wettest Quarter (PWQ), obtained from the WorldClim database.
  • Soil Properties: Exchangeable Potassium (AK), Aluminum (AL), Phosphorus (AP), Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC), Organic Matter Content (DC), Soil Moisture (DH), Particle Content (GRAV), Soil pH, Porosity (POR), and Total Nitrogen (TN), sourced from the National Tibetan Plateau Data Center.

This synthesized dataset is novel in its integration of these diverse data types across a large number of comparative natural and plantation forest sites.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Climate as the Foundation, Microbes as the Modulators: Climate is the primary driver setting the baseline for forest productivity, but soil microbes and soil properties act as crucial mediators, fine-tuning efficiency and stability.
  • Functional Simplification in Plantations: Plantation forests, often managed as monocultures, tend to have simplified microbial communities dominated by "r-strategist" taxa (fast-growing, disturbance-tolerant). This contrasts with natural forests, which host more diverse "K-strategist" taxa (slower-growing, resource-efficient) that support long-term nutrient cycling and stability.
  • Asymmetric Productivity-Diversity Relationships: The link between microbial diversity and productivity is not linear. In plantations, productivity increases with diversity up to a point, then declines, suggesting a potential instability or saturation effect. Natural forests, however, show a more consistent positive relationship.
  • Distinct Drivers of Microbial Diversity: Climate and biotic feedbacks are more influential for microbial diversity in natural forests, while soil nutrient status and physical properties (like CEC and TN) are stronger predictors in plantations, reflecting the impact of management practices.

Key Results

  • Productivity Differences: Natural forests generally exhibited higher productivity than plantation forests across the dataset.
  • Microbial Diversity: Natural forests showed significantly higher bacterial and fungal Shannon diversity than plantations. Bacterial Chao1 was also higher in natural forests, while fungal Chao1 was higher in plantations.
  • Taxonomic Differences: Natural forests were characterized by nitrogen-cycling and acid-tolerant bacteria (e.g., Nitrobacter, Bradyrhizobium) and fungi associated with nutrient acquisition and decomposition (e.g., Cortinarius). Plantations were enriched with taxa linked to disturbance tolerance, rhizosphere interactions, and potential pathogens (e.g., Sphingomonas, Fusarium).
  • Predictors of Diversity: In natural forests, MAP, PWQ, and POR were key predictors of Shannon diversity. In plantations, GRAV, longitude, and pH were important for Shannon diversity, while CEC and TN were dominant for Chao1 diversity.
  • SEM Findings: Climate had a strong direct effect on productivity in both forest types. Soil factors positively influenced microbial diversity in natural forests but negatively in plantations. Microbial diversity had a greater positive effect on GPP in natural forests compared to plantations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Climate Space Confounding: A key limitation is that the compiled dataset may not perfectly match the climate spaces of natural and plantation forests, potentially confounding direct comparisons. The authors acknowledge that findings should be interpreted as association patterns within the current data coverage rather than strictly climate-controlled causal contrasts.
  • Management Intensity: The study highlights the need for future research to incorporate explicit management intensity variables to more robustly isolate microbial contributions.
  • Climate-Comparable Designs: Future work should prioritize climate-comparable paired designs for more robust comparisons.
  • Ecosystem Modeling: The findings offer insights for improving ecosystem modeling by incorporating the distinct roles of microbial communities.
  • Restoration Strategies: The study suggests practical steps for restoring microbial diversity in plantations, such as increasing tree species diversity, reducing intensive management, and applying organic amendments or microbial inocula.

Summary updated

Abstract

While climate is known to regulate forest productivity, the mechanistic contribution of soil microbial communities-and whether it differs between natural and plantation forests-remains poorly quantified at broad scales. Here, we provide a synthesis-level, unified analysis that jointly evaluates climate, edaphic conditions, and soil microbes to compare mechanistic pathways underlying productivity divergence between forest types. We synthesized 237 observations across China and integrated productivity metrics-gross primary productivity (GPP) and net primary productivity (NPP)-with microbial diversity, dominant taxa, and soil drivers to compare natural and plantation forests within the current environmental coverage. Plantation productivity showed nonlinear responses to microbial diversity and appeared more sensitive than natural forests. Natural forests exhibited higher bacterial Shannon and Chao1 but lower fungal Chao1 and were characterized by taxa such as <i>Nitrobacter</i>, <i>Bradyrhizobium</i>, and <i>Cortinarius</i>. In contrast, plantations were characterized by taxa often associated with disturbance tolerance and opportunistic life-history strategies (e.g., <i>Sphingomonas</i>, <i>Fusarium</i>, <i>Gemmatimonas</i>), consistent with potential functional simplification. Structural equation models identified climate as the strongest correlate of productivity, while soil properties showed contrasting associations with microbial diversity across forest types. Random forest models further highlighted cation-exchange capacity and total nitrogen as key predictors of microbial diversity in plantations. Overall, our results indicate that soil microbial communities are differentially associated with forest productivity across forest types and environmental contexts and underscore the need for future climate-comparable designs and management-intensity information to more robustly isolate microbial contributions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025soil,
  author = {Xing Zhang and Mengya Yang and Yangyang Liu and Jinkun Ye and Jiechen Tangyu and Jie Gao and Wei Liu and Yuchuan Fan},
  title = {{Soil Microbes Mediate Productivity Differences Between Natural and Plantation Forests}},
  booktitle = {Plants},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/plants15010098},
}
Figure