Soft Rehabilitation Actuator With Integrated Post-stroke Finger Spasticity Evaluation

Ho Lam Heung, Zhi Qiang Tang, Xiangqian Shi, Raymond Kai‐Yu Tong, Zheng LiFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel 3D-printed soft robotic actuator that can objectively measure finger spasticity in stroke patients. By analyzing the pressure-angle relationship of the actuator when worn on a finger, it quantifies finger joint stiffness, offering a more precise and reliable alternative to subjective clinical assessments. This technology promises to enable personalized rehabilitation and track therapeutic progress more effectively.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Stroke survivors often experience significant impairment in hand function due to spasticity in their upper extremities. This spasticity, characterized by increased muscle tone and involuntary contractions, leads to stiff fingers that are difficult to extend, severely limiting daily activities. While evaluating spasticity is crucial for tailoring rehabilitation, current methods like the Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS) are subjective, relying heavily on clinician experience and lacking quantitative data. This subjectivity can lead to inconsistent assessments and hinder the development of truly personalized therapy. Furthermore, existing robotic rehabilitation devices often lack integrated, objective spasticity measurement capabilities, making it difficult to dynamically adjust training based on a patient's real-time condition.

Methods

The core innovation is a Soft-Elastic Composite Actuator (SECA), a 3D-printed soft robotic component designed to facilitate both flexion and extension of fingers. The SECA's unique design incorporates a composite structure with an elastomeric actuator body and a torque-compensating layer, enabling controlled bending.

The key to spasticity evaluation lies in modeling the SECA's behavior. The authors developed a theoretical framework based on the conservation of energy to relate the input air pressure to the actuator's bending angle. This model accounts for the strain energy stored in the elastomer and the torque-compensating layer.

Crucially, they extended this model to constrained bending on model fingers. By considering the finger joint's elastic potential energy, they derived equations to estimate joint stiffness (both PIP and MCP joints) from the SECA's pressure-angle response when worn on a finger. This allows for the quantification of spasticity as finger joint stiffness.

The methodology was validated through:

  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA): To simulate the SECA's behavior and compare it with analytical models.
  • Experiments on mannequin fingers: Using custom-designed mannequin fingers with integrated springs to mimic different levels of finger stiffness (low and high).
  • Experiments on human subjects: Testing the SECA on both stroke patients and healthy individuals.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental data: Collected from the SECA's performance on mannequin fingers and human subjects.
  • FEA simulations: Used for model validation.

The study introduces a novel benchmark for evaluating finger joint stiffness in stroke patients, comparing their quantified stiffness values with MAS scores.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Objective Spasticity Measurement: The SECA provides a quantitative, objective measure of finger joint stiffness, overcoming the subjectivity of traditional clinical scales like MAS.
  • Real-time Assessment Potential: The pressure-angle relationship of the SECA can be measured in real-time, allowing for dynamic assessment of spasticity during rehabilitation or daily activities.
  • Stiffness Variation in Stroke Patients: Even among stroke patients with the same MAS score, there can be significant variations in finger stiffness (a few times), highlighting the need for individualized assessment.
  • Correlation between MAS and Stiffness: The study demonstrates a clear trend of increased finger stiffness in stroke patients compared to healthy individuals, particularly for those with higher MAS scores.
  • Importance of Torque Compensation: The torque-compensating layer in the SECA is crucial for enabling both flexion and extension and for accurate stiffness estimation.

Key Results

  • The analytical and FEA models for SECA bending were validated against experimental results with good agreement.
  • Experiments on model fingers showed that the SECA could accurately predict joint stiffness, with mean errors as low as 0.027 Nm/rad.
  • Clinical evaluation on eight subjects (four stroke, four healthy) revealed significantly higher MCP and PIP joint stiffness in stroke patients compared to healthy controls.
  • Subject S3, with an MAS score of 3, exhibited substantially higher joint stiffness (e.g., MCP stiffness of 0.63123 Nm/rad) compared to subjects with MAS scores of 1+ (e.g., S1 and S2 with MCP stiffness around 0.09 Nm/rad).
  • Healthy subjects showed joint stiffness values comparable to those reported in existing literature (around 0.03 Nm/rad).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Layer Thickness: The paper notes that a torque-compensating layer thickness below 0.1 mm might not provide sufficient differentiation between SECA and traditional Fiber-Reinforced Actuators (FRAs).
  • Limited Subject Pool: The study involved a small number of stroke patients (four) and healthy subjects (four) for preliminary evaluation.
  • Generalizability: While the SECA is designed for finger rehabilitation, further work is needed to generalize its application to a full hand rehabilitation robotic system.

The authors envision future work focusing on:

  • Integrating the SECA into a complete rehabilitation robotic hand that can provide real-time stiffness feedback.
  • Using this stiffness information to plan personalized training tasks tailored to each patient's spasticity level.
  • Monitoring therapeutic progress by observing the decrease in joint stiffness over time, which can serve as a motivational tool for patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Strokes cause severe impairment of hand function because of the spasticity in the affected upper extremities. Proper spasticity evaluation is critical to facilitate neural plasticity for rehabilitation after stroke. However, existing methods for measuring spasticity, e.g. Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS), highly depends on clinicians' experiences, which are subjective and lacks quantitative details. Here, we introduce the first rehabilitation actuator that objectively reflects the condition of post-stroke finger spasticity. The actuator is 3D printed with soft materials. By considering the finger and the actuator together, the spasticity, i.e. stiffness, in finger is obtained from the pressure-angle relationship. The method is validated by simulations using finite element analysis (FEA) and experiments on mannequin fingers. Furthermore, it is examined on four stroke subjects and four healthy subjects. Results show the finger stiffness increases significantly from healthy subjects to stroke subjects, particularly those with high MAS score. For patients with the same MAS score, stiffness variation can be a few times. With this soft actuator, a hand rehabilitation robot that may tell the therapeutic progress during the rehabilitation training is readily available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heung2020soft,
  author = {Ho Lam Heung and Zhi Qiang Tang and Xiangqian Shi and Raymond Kai‐Yu Tong and Zheng Li},
  title = {{Soft Rehabilitation Actuator With Integrated Post-stroke Finger Spasticity Evaluation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2020.00111},
}
Figure