Soft matter roadmap*

Jean‐Louis Barrat, Emanuela Del Gado, Stefan U. Egelhaaf, Xiaoming Mao, Marjolein Dijkstra, David J. Pine, Sanat K. Kumar, Kyle J. M. Bishop, Oleg Gang, Allie C. Obermeyer, Christine M. Papadakis, Constantinos Tsitsilianis, Ivan I. Smalyukh, Aurélie Hourlier‐Fargette, Sébastien Andrieux, Wiebke Drenckhan, Norman J. Wagner, Ryan P. Murphy, Eric R. Weeks, Roberto Cerbino, Yilong Han, Luca Cipelletti, Laurence Ramos, Wilson C. K. Poon, James A. Richards, Itai Cohen, Eric M. Furst, Alshakim Nelson, Stephen L. Craig, Rajesh Ganapathy, A. K. Sood, Francesco Sciortino, Muhittin Mungan, Srikanth Sastry, Colin Scheibner, Michel Fruchart, Vincenzo Vitelli, Sean A. Ridout, Menachem Stern, Indrajit Tah, Ge Zhang, Andrea J. Liu, Chinedum O. Osuji, Yuan Xu, Heather M. Shewan, Jason R. Stokes, Matthias Merkel, Pierre Ronceray, Jean-François Rupprecht, Olga Matsarskaia, Frank Schreiber, Felix Roosen‐Runge, Marie‐Eve Aubin‐Tam, Gijsje H. Koenderink, Rosa M. Espinosa‐Marzal, Joaquín Yus, Jiheon KwonJournal of Physics Materials 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the exciting frontier of "soft metamaterials" – engineered materials that go beyond their constituent properties to exhibit intelligent and adaptive behaviors. The authors highlight how concepts from topology, programmable mechanics, and even biological systems are being integrated to create materials that can compute, learn, and dynamically respond to their environment, opening doors to revolutionary applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional materials have fixed properties. The challenge this paper addresses is how to design and engineer materials that are not static but can dynamically adapt their behavior, perform computations, and even learn from their experiences. This moves beyond simply creating materials with novel mechanical properties (like auxetics) to materials that exhibit a form of "intelligence" and "adaptability" akin to living systems. The authors are interested in bridging the gap between passive, predictable materials and active, responsive systems that can autonomously perform complex tasks.

Methods

The paper discusses several key approaches to achieving adaptive and intelligent soft metamaterials:

  • Topological Protection: Utilizing topological invariants to ensure the existence of robust, localized mechanical modes or deformation mechanisms, making them resilient to defects.
  • Programmable Multistability: Encoding specific responses into the material's structure, allowing it to adopt predefined shapes or patterns when subjected to external stimuli (like compression).
  • Directed Aging/Training: Modifying the material's properties over time through repeated exposure to stress, akin to a learning process where bonds are strengthened or weakened.
  • Active Elements & Energy Sources: Incorporating components with internal energy sources (like motorized hinges) to enable self-sustained motion and complex directional control.
  • Bio-inspiration: Drawing inspiration from biological systems like neural tissues for computation and muscle tissues for large-scale deformation, as well as self-assembly principles seen in colloidal structures.
  • Dynamical Systems Theory: Conceptualizing metamaterials as dynamical systems where functionalities emerge from limit cycles or attractors in their configuration space.
  • Machine Learning Integration: Employing machine learning to accelerate material design, establish relationships between physical parameters and desired dynamic behaviors, and develop effective theories for adaptive dynamics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on conceptual frameworks and experimental examples rather than large-scale data-driven training.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intelligence is not just computation, but physical embodiment: The paper suggests that "intelligence" in materials can arise from physical processes, not just embedded electronics. Materials can "compute" and "learn" through their inherent mechanical dynamics and structural evolution.
  • Topology as a robustness guarantee: Topological principles offer a way to design materials with inherent resilience, ensuring specific functionalities persist even in the presence of defects.
  • Materials as "computers" and "robots": The vision is to create materials that can perform calculations, store information (memories), and execute actions, blurring the lines between matter and computation.
  • Self-assembly as a manufacturing paradigm: At small scales, self-assembly offers a powerful route to create complex, functional metamaterials, mimicking natural processes.
  • Bridging scales: The concepts discussed are applicable across various length scales, from microscopic colloidal structures to macroscopic engineered systems.

Key Results

The paper presents conceptual examples and illustrative figures rather than quantitative results from a single experiment. Key qualitative findings include:

  • Demonstration of topological metamaterials with robust soft modes.
  • Examples of programmable metamaterials that can form specific patterns (e.g., a smiley face) upon compression.
  • Illustrations of "trained" metamaterials where properties evolve with stress.
  • Concepts of active metamaterials capable of steering projectiles.
  • Examples of deployable metamaterials that undergo controlled shape changes.
  • Visualizations of self-assembled colloidal structures mimicking atomic arrangements.
  • Schematics showing how dynamic states (attractors) can lead to functional behaviors like swimming or flying.
  • Conceptualization of materials that learn through physical stimulation and adapt their behavior.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Fabrication and Miniaturization: A significant challenge is the miniaturization and mass production of complex elements required for these advanced metamaterials.
  • Decentralized Control: Removing the reliance on external computers for control and integrating computation directly into the material's physics is a major hurdle.
  • Describing Intermediate Time Scales: Developing effective theories to describe the complex, adaptive dynamics of these materials, especially at intermediate time scales, is difficult.
  • Conceptual and Practical Challenges: Reaching the full promise of these materials requires tackling fundamental questions about representation and learning in physical systems.

Future Work:

  • Bio-inspired Systems: Further exploration of engineered DNA molecules and micro-robots for implementing algorithms and performing complex tasks.
  • Effective Theories: Developing advanced model reduction techniques (dimensionality reduction, invariant manifold reduction) to describe adaptive dynamics and physical learning.
  • Machine Learning for Design: Utilizing machine learning to automate the inverse design problem, mapping desired functionalities to material structures and parameters.
  • Self-Repair and Replication: Investigating materials that can repair themselves or even replicate, inspired by biological systems.
  • Applications: Exploring applications in diverse fields such as medicine, robotics, and space exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Soft materials are usually defined as materials made of mesoscopic entities, often self-organised, sensitive to thermal fluctuations and to weak perturbations. Archetypal examples are colloids, polymers, amphiphiles, liquid crystals, foams. The importance of soft materials in everyday commodity products, as well as in technological applications, is enormous, and controlling or improving their properties is the focus of many efforts. From a fundamental perspective, the possibility of manipulating soft material properties, by tuning interactions between constituents and by applying external perturbations, gives rise to an almost unlimited variety in physical properties. Together with the relative ease to observe and characterise them, this renders soft matter systems powerful model systems to investigate statistical physics phenomena, many of them relevant as well to hard condensed matter systems. Understanding the emerging properties from mesoscale constituents still poses enormous challenges, which have stimulated a wealth of new experimental approaches, including the synthesis of new systems with, e.g. tailored self-assembling properties, or novel experimental techniques in imaging, scattering or rheology. Theoretical and numerical methods, and coarse-grained models, have become central to predict physical properties of soft materials, while computational approaches that also use machine learning tools are playing a progressively major role in many investigations. This Roadmap intends to give a broad overview of recent and possible future activities in the field of soft materials, with experts covering various developments and challenges in material synthesis and characterisation, instrumental, simulation and theoretical methods as well as general concepts.
BibTeX
@article{barrat2023soft,
  author = {Jean‐Louis Barrat and Emanuela Del Gado and Stefan U. Egelhaaf and Xiaoming Mao and Marjolein Dijkstra and David J. Pine and Sanat K. Kumar and Kyle J. M. Bishop and Oleg Gang and Allie C. Obermeyer and Christine M. Papadakis and Constantinos Tsitsilianis and Ivan I. Smalyukh and Aurélie Hourlier‐Fargette and Sébastien Andrieux and Wiebke Drenckhan and Norman J. Wagner and Ryan P. Murphy and Eric R. Weeks and Roberto Cerbino and Yilong Han and Luca Cipelletti and Laurence Ramos and Wilson C. K. Poon and James A. Richards and Itai Cohen and Eric M. Furst and Alshakim Nelson and Stephen L. Craig and Rajesh Ganapathy and A. K. Sood and Francesco Sciortino and Muhittin Mungan and Srikanth Sastry and Colin Scheibner and Michel Fruchart and Vincenzo Vitelli and Sean A. Ridout and Menachem Stern and Indrajit Tah and Ge Zhang and Andrea J. Liu and Chinedum O. Osuji and Yuan Xu and Heather M. Shewan and Jason R. Stokes and Matthias Merkel and Pierre Ronceray and Jean-François Rupprecht and Olga Matsarskaia and Frank Schreiber and Felix Roosen‐Runge and Marie‐Eve Aubin‐Tam and Gijsje H. Koenderink and Rosa M. Espinosa‐Marzal and Joaquín Yus and Jiheon Kwon},
  title = {{Soft matter roadmap<sup>*</sup>}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics Materials},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/2515-7639/ad06cc},
}
Figure