Soft drop

Andrew J. Larkoski, Simone Marzani, Grégory Soyez, Jesse ThalerJournal of High Energy Physics 2014 · DOI

Abstract

We introduce a new jet substructure technique called "soft drop declustering", which recursively removes soft wide-angle radiation from a jet. The soft drop algorithm depends on two parameters—a soft threshold $z_{cut}$ and an angular exponent $\beta$—with the $\beta = 0$ limit corresponding roughly to the (modified) mass drop procedure. To gain an analytic understanding of soft drop and highlight the $\beta$ dependence, we perform resummed calculations for three observables on soft-dropped jets: the energy correlation functions, the groomed jet radius, and the energy loss due to soft drop. The $\beta = 0$ limit of the energy loss is particularly interesting, since it is not only "Sudakov safe" but also largely insensitive to the value of the strong coupling constant. While our calculations are strictly accurate only to modified leading-logarithmic order, we also include a discussion of higher-order effects such as multiple emissions and (the absence of) non-global logarithms. We compare our analytic results to parton shower simulations and find good agreement, and we also estimate the impact of non-perturbative effects such as hadronization and the underlying event. Finally, we demonstrate how soft drop can be used for tagging boosted $W$ bosons, and we speculate on the potential advantages of using soft drop for pileup mitigation.

Introduction

In high-energy particle physics experiments like those at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), jets—sprays of particles resulting from the fragmentation of quarks and gluons—are fundamental objects of study. However, these jets are often contaminated by "noise" from the Underlying Event (UE) and Pileup (multiple simultaneous proton collisions). Extracting the underlying physics, such as the mass of a boosted heavy particle, requires "grooming" techniques to strip away this soft, diffuse radiation.

While several methods existed (like trimming or pruning), they often lacked a clear analytical understanding or suffered from complex mathematical artifacts like non-global logarithms (NGLs). This paper introduces Soft Drop, a generalized jet grooming algorithm that is both experimentally robust and theoretically "clean," providing a bridge between noise reduction and particle tagging.

The Soft Drop Algorithm

Soft Drop works by recursively declustering a jet and pruning branches that fail a specific energy-angle condition. The procedure is as follows:

  1. Reclustering: Jet constituents are organized into a branching tree using the Cambridge-Aachen (C/A) algorithm, which clusters particles based on angular proximity.
  2. Recursive Declustering: Starting from the widest angle (the last clustering step), the jet is broken into two subjets, $j_1$ and $j_2$.
  3. The Soft Drop Condition: The algorithm checks if the subjets satisfy the following criterion: $$\frac{\min(p_{T1}, p_{T2})}{p_{T1} + p_{T2}} > z_{cut} \left( \frac{\Delta R_{12}}{R_0} \right)^\beta$$ where $z_{cut}$ is a threshold, $\Delta R_{12}$ is the distance between subjets, and $\beta$ is a tunable angular exponent.

  4. Iteration: If the condition is met, the jet is considered "groomed." If not, the softer subjet is discarded, and the algorithm repeats on the harder subjet.

Phase space diagram of the Soft Drop algorithm showing the impact of the angular exponent $\beta$ on radiation removal.

The exponent $\beta$ is a critical parameter that determines the algorithm's behavior. As shown in the phase space diagram, $\beta$ defines the boundary of the "Soft Dropped" region in the $(\log R_0/\theta, \log 1/z)$ plane. When $\beta = 0$, the algorithm recovers a version of the Modified Mass Drop Tagger (mMDT). For $\beta > 0$, it acts as a smooth groomer, while $\beta < 0$ turns it into a "tagger" that enforces a hard two-prong structure.

Theoretical Insights and Results

A key advantage of Soft Drop is its mathematical calculability. Using logarithmic resummation (specifically Modified Leading Logarithmic accuracy), the authors predicted observables like jet mass and energy loss from first principles.

Resilience and "Sudakov Safety"

Soft Drop is remarkably well-behaved mathematically. For $\beta = 0$, it completely eliminates Non-Global Logarithms (NGLs), which are notoriously difficult to calculate. Even for $\beta > 0$, NGLs are significantly suppressed. Furthermore, the authors demonstrate that certain observables are "Sudakov safe"—meaning they become well-defined once the effects of multiple particle emissions are accounted for, even if they appear divergent in standard perturbation theory.

Performance and Noise Mitigation

Simulations using Pythia 8.175 at 14 TeV show excellent agreement between analytic predictions and Monte Carlo data. The algorithm effectively reduces the impact of hadronization and the underlying event on jet observables. In $W$-boson tagging trials, Soft Drop (particularly with negative $\beta$) demonstrated superior performance in rejecting background noise while preserving the signal. Additionally, the "groomed jet radius" ($R_g$) emerged as a powerful proxy for a jet's sensitivity to pileup, suggesting significant potential for high-luminosity LHC data cleaning.

One surprising finding is that for $\beta = 0$, the jet energy drop is largely independent of the strong coupling constant ($\alpha_s$), making it a very robust probe of jet dynamics.

Conclusion

Soft Drop provides a flexible and theoretically grounded framework for jet substructure analysis. By tuning $\beta$, researchers can optimize the algorithm for different physics goals, from precision QCD measurements to searching for new heavy particles. While current calculations are at Modified Leading Logarithmic order, future work will involve higher-order (NLL) calculations and more extensive studies of pileup mitigation in realistic detector environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce a new jet substructure technique called "soft drop declustering", which recursively removes soft wide-angle radiation from a jet. The soft drop algorithm depends on two parameters -a soft threshold z cut and an angular exponent -with the = 0 limit corresponding roughly to the (modified) mass drop procedure. To gain an analytic understanding of soft drop and highlight the dependence, we perform resummed calculations for three observables on soft-dropped jets: the energy correlation functions, the groomed jet radius, and the energy loss due to soft drop. The = 0 limit of the energy loss is particularly interesting, since it is not only "Sudakov safe" but also largely insensitive to the value of the strong coupling constant. While our calculations are strictly accurate only to modified leading-logarithmic order, we also include a discussion of higher-order effects such as multiple emissions and (the absence of) non-global logarithms. We compare our analytic results to parton shower simulations and find good agreement, and we also estimate the impact of non-perturbative effects such as hadronization and the underlying event. Finally, we demonstrate how soft drop can be used for tagging boosted W bosons, and we speculate on the potential advantages of using soft drop for pileup mitigation.
BibTeX
@article{larkoski2014soft,
  author = {Andrew J. Larkoski and Simone Marzani and Grégory Soyez and Jesse Thaler},
  title = {{Soft drop}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep05(2014)146},
}
Figure