Socially-Assistive Robots to Support Learning in Students on the Autism Spectrum: Investigating Educator Perspectives and a Pilot Trial of a Mobile Platform to Remove Barriers to Implementation

David Silvera‐Tawil, Susan Bruck, Yi Xiao, DanaKai BradfordSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the integration of socially-assistive robots into classrooms for students with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). It identifies key barriers and concerns from educators and autistic adults, then introduces a novel mobile platform (MAX) designed to simplify robot use, followed by a pilot trial demonstrating its potential to facilitate implementation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Students with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) often benefit from structured, predictable learning environments that cater to their specific interests and learning styles. Socially-assistive robots (SARs) show promise in providing such support, offering consistent interactions and engaging learning opportunities. However, despite promising research, the adoption of SARs in educational settings for students with ASD has been slow. This paper addresses the critical gap between the potential of SARs and their actual implementation in schools by investigating the perspectives of those who would use them: teachers, therapists, and autistic adults themselves. It aims to understand their expectations, concerns, and perceived barriers to adoption, and then to develop and test a solution to overcome these challenges.

Methods

The research employed a mixed-methods approach, divided into three parts:

  1. Exploratory Study (Focus Groups): Three focus groups were conducted with adults on the autism spectrum and teachers/therapists from autism-specific schools. These sessions aimed to gather insights into their expectations, perceived benefits, concerns, and potential barriers regarding the use of robots for learning and teaching.
  2. Software Platform Development: Based on the findings from the exploratory study, a software platform named MAX was developed. MAX is designed to simplify the use of robots in the classroom by providing teachers with an easy-to-use interface and pre-programmed modules.
  3. Pilot Trial (Focus Groups): A pilot trial of the MAX platform was conducted with seven teachers and therapists in two schools. Focus groups were used again to gather feedback on the usability, features, and overall utility of the MAX app in supporting robot-assisted learning.

The data analysis involved thematic analysis of transcribed focus group discussions, with an inductive approach to identify emerging themes and codes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on qualitative data collected through focus groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cautious Optimism: Educators and autistic adults expressed a general optimism about the potential of socially-assistive robots to support learning for students with ASD, particularly due to their predictable nature and engaging qualities.
  • The "Usability Barrier": A significant concern identified was the complexity of current robot programming and control. Teachers felt they lacked the technical skills and time to develop custom lessons, highlighting the need for user-friendly tools.
  • MAX as a Solution: The development of the MAX mobile application directly addresses the usability barrier by providing an intuitive interface and pre-programmed modules, making robot integration more accessible for educators.
  • Beyond "Toy" Status: Autistic adults emphasized that robots should be viewed as serious educational tools, not rewards, and stressed the importance of equitable access for all students.
  • Sensory and Security Concerns: Beyond usability, participants raised important points about potential sensory sensitivities to robot appearance and movement, as well as concerns regarding data security and privacy.

Key Results

  • Exploratory Study Findings: Participants identified several anticipated enabling features of robots, including their novelty, predictability, non-judgmental nature, and human-like appearance. Key barriers to implementation included cost, fragility, time constraints for lesson preparation, and the need for teacher training.
  • MAX Trial Feedback: Teachers and therapists found the MAX app's user interface to be easy to use and the icon buttons understandable. They viewed the available modules as a good starting point but desired more specific modules (e.g., for bullying, turn-taking, emotion regulation). They also suggested improvements like simpler robot connection methods and additional features such as voice customization and battery level display.
  • Motivation for Trial: The mobile app's ease of use and ability to support lesson preparation and delivery were identified as key motivators for teachers to trial robots in their classrooms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The exploratory study involved participants from only two schools and one autism-specific organization, limiting the generalizability of findings to mainstream school teachers.
  • None of the participants in the initial study had prior experience with robots, which might have influenced their initial perceptions.
  • The MAX trial was conducted with a small sample size.
  • The study did not include direct input from students with autism.
  • Future Work:
    • Future research should aim to recruit a more representative sample of teachers, including those in mainstream settings.
  • Interviewing students with autism directly would provide valuable insights.
  • Making robots readily available for future explorations is recommended.
  • Further research is needed to evaluate the impact of socially-assistive robots in large-scale, longitudinal studies.
  • Exploring the potential of robots to support alternative communication methods (e.g., sign language) and addressing sensory and security concerns are important future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Technology offers educators tools that can tailor learning to students' learning styles and interests. Research into the use of socially-assistive robots as a learning support for children on the autism spectrum are showing promising results. However, to date, few schools have introduced these robots to support learning in students on the autism spectrum. This paper reports on a research project that investigated the barriers to implementing socially-assistive robot supported learning, and the expectations, perceived benefits and concerns of school teachers and therapists of students on the autism spectrum and adults on the autism spectrum. First, three focus groups were conducted with six adults on the autism spectrum, and 13 teachers and therapists of students from two autism-specific schools. During the focus groups, there was cautious optimism from participants about the value of socially-assistive robots for teaching support. While the data showed that participants were in favour of trialling socially-assistive robots in the classroom, they also raised several concerns and potential barriers to implementation, including the need for teacher training. In response to their concerns, the second part of the project focussed on developing a software platform and mobile application (app) to support the introduction of robots into autism-specific classrooms. The software platform and app were then trialled in two schools (<i>n</i> = 7 teachers and therapists). Results from focus groups indicated that participants believe socially-assistive robots could be useful for learning support, as the mobile app provides an easy to use tool to support preparing and conducting lessons that would motivate them to trial robots in the classroom.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{silveratawil2022socially,
  author = {David Silvera‐Tawil and Susan Bruck and Yi Xiao and DanaKai Bradford},
  title = {{Socially-Assistive Robots to Support Learning in Students on the Autism Spectrum: Investigating Educator Perspectives and a Pilot Trial of a Mobile Platform to Remove Barriers to Implementation}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22166125},
}
Figure