Social stress drives the multi-wave dynamics of COVID-19 outbreaks

Innokentiy Kastalskiy, Evgeniya V. Pankratova, Evgeny M. Mirkes, Victor Kazantsev, Alexander N. GorbanScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

The dynamics of epidemics depend on how people's behavior changes during an outbreak. At the beginning of the epidemic, people do not know about the virus, then, after the outbreak of epidemics and alarm, they begin to comply with the restrictions and the spreading of epidemics may decline. Over time, some people get tired/frustrated by the restrictions and stop following them (exhaustion), especially if the number of new cases drops down. After resting for a while, they can follow the restrictions again. But during this pause the second wave can come and become even stronger then the first one. Studies based on SIR models do not predict the observed quick exit from the first wave of epidemics. Social dynamics should be considered. The appearance of the second wave also depends on social factors. Many generalizations of the SIR model have been developed that take into account the weakening of immunity over time, the evolution of the virus, vaccination and other medical and biological details. However, these more sophisticated models do not explain the apparent differences in outbreak profiles between countries with different intrinsic socio-cultural features. In our work, a system of models of the COVID-19 pandemic is proposed, combining the dynamics of social stress with classical epidemic models. Social stress is described by the tools of sociophysics. The combination of a dynamic SIR-type model with the classical triad of stages of the general adaptation syndrome, alarm-resistance-exhaustion, makes it possible to describe with high accuracy the available statistical data for 13 countries. The sets of kinetic constants corresponding to optimal fit of model to data were found. These constants characterize the ability of society to mobilize efforts against epidemics and maintain this concentration over time and can further help in the development of management strategies specific to a particular society.

Introduction

Standard epidemiological models, such as the Susceptible-Infected-Removed (SIR) framework, typically predict a single infection peak followed by a gradual decline. However, real-world COVID-19 data frequently displayed a "quick exit" from the first wave followed by subsequent, often more severe, resurgences. This paper introduces the $SIR_{SS}$ model, which posits that these discrepancies arise because standard models ignore the non-static nature of human behavior. By integrating "social stress"—defined through the stages of alarm, resistance, and exhaustion—into classical frameworks, we demonstrate that socio-cultural behavior is a primary driver of multi-wave pandemic dynamics.

The $SIR_{SS}$ Model Framework

The researchers developed the $SIR_{SS}$ model by splitting the "Susceptible" population into three behavioral subgroups based on the General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS):

  1. Ignorant ($S_{ign}$): Individuals unaware of or ignoring the danger.
  2. Resistant ($S_{res}$): Individuals practicing social distancing and hygiene.
  3. Exhausted ($S_{exh}$): Individuals whose psychological resources are depleted, leading them to abandon restrictions.

The model tracks transitions between these states using key parameters: the stress response rate ($q$), the exhaustion rate ($K_2$), and the morbidity rate ($a$). Using global optimization, these parameters were fitted to data from 13 countries, achieving an average $R^2$ of 0.998.

Results and Discussion

Case Study: China's High-Resistance Profile

China serves as a high-resistance outlier in the study. Its resistance index ($q$) was found to be significantly higher than any other country, reflecting extreme social discipline and state control. This allowed the population to transition rapidly from $S_{ign}$ to $S_{res}$, effectively suppressing the first wave and avoiding a second wave during the initial 200-day period.

Figure 4: Model fit and behavioral state transitions for China, showing a single-wave profile due to high resistance (q).

The Role of Social Exhaustion in Multi-Wave Resurgence

In contrast to the single-peak profile seen in China, many countries experienced a resurgence driven by the accumulation of social stress. When the first wave declines, the perceived risk drops, and individuals enter the "exhaustion" phase ($S_{exh}$). As people stop following social distancing rules, they effectively return to a susceptible state that facilitates a second wave.

Figure 6: Dynamics of a multi-wave outbreak where rising social exhaustion (S_exh) triggers a resurgence in infections (I).

In countries like the USA, Colombia, and Iran, high exhaustion rates ($K_2$) led to a rapid accumulation of $S_{exh}$ individuals. This behavioral feedback loop created the conditions for second waves that were often larger than the first. The study suggests that for the first 300 days of the pandemic, these social differences were more influential on the epidemic's shape than biological factors or viral mutations.

Conclusion

The $SIR_{SS}$ model demonstrates that social dynamics are as critical as biological ones in predicting pandemic trajectories. The "resistance index" and "exhaustion rate" provide quantitative measures of a society's ability to mobilize and sustain efforts against an epidemic. These insights can assist in developing management strategies tailored to the specific socio-cultural features of a population, moving beyond one-size-fits-all epidemiological interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The dynamics of epidemics depend on how people's behavior changes during an outbreak. At the beginning of the epidemic, people do not know about the virus, then, after the outbreak of epidemics and alarm, they begin to comply with the restrictions and the spreading of epidemics may decline. Over time, some people get tired/frustrated by the restrictions and stop following them (exhaustion), especially if the number of new cases drops down. After resting for a while, they can follow the restrictions again. But during this pause the second wave can come and become even stronger then the first one. Studies based on SIR models do not predict the observed quick exit from the first wave of epidemics. Social dynamics should be considered. The appearance of the second wave also depends on social factors. Many generalizations of the SIR model have been developed that take into account the weakening of immunity over time, the evolution of the virus, vaccination and other medical and biological details. However, these more sophisticated models do not explain the apparent differences in outbreak profiles between countries with different intrinsic socio-cultural features. In our work, a system of models of the COVID-19 pandemic is proposed, combining the dynamics of social stress with classical epidemic models. Social stress is described by the tools of sociophysics. The combination of a dynamic SIR-type model with the classical triad of stages of the general adaptation syndrome, alarm-resistance-exhaustion, makes it possible to describe with high accuracy the available statistical data for 13 countries. The sets of kinetic constants corresponding to optimal fit of model to data were found. These constants characterize the ability of society to mobilize efforts against epidemics and maintain this concentration over time and can further help in the development of management strategies specific to a particular society.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kastalskiy2021social,
  author = {Innokentiy Kastalskiy and Evgeniya V. Pankratova and Evgeny M. Mirkes and Victor Kazantsev and Alexander N. Gorban},
  title = {{Social stress drives the multi-wave dynamics of COVID-19 outbreaks}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-01317-z},
}
Figure