Social relationships, social isolation, and the human gut microbiota

Kimberly A. Dill‐McFarland, Zheng-Zheng Tang, Julia H. Kemis, Robert L. Kerby, Guanhua Chen, Alberto Palloni, Thomas J. Sorenson, Federico E. Rey, Pamela HerdbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Social relationships are fundamental drivers of human health and mortality, influencing outcomes through behavioral, psychosocial, and physiological pathways. While inflammatory and immune responses are well-documented mediators, recent research in primates suggests the gut microbiome may also link sociality to health. This study integrates microbiota data into the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study (WLS) to examine how social connections influence the human fecal microbiota. Analyzing spouse pairs (N = 94) and sibling pairs (N = 83), we find that spouses possess more similar and diverse microbiota than siblings or unrelated individuals, even after controlling for diet. Notably, this similarity is driven by the quality of the relationship; only couples reporting high levels of closeness exhibited these microbial patterns. These findings suggest that sustained human intimacy is a key architect of the internal microbial ecosystems associated with long-term health.

Introduction

For over sixty years, researchers have recognized that social isolation is a risk factor for mortality comparable to smoking or obesity. However, the biological "black box" connecting social bonds to physical health remains partially opaque. While researchers have explored inflammatory and immune pathways, the gut microbiome has recently emerged as a potential mediator.

Previous studies in primates showed that social grooming and proximity influence microbial sharing, but human studies have been inconsistent. Some suggested cohabitation is the primary driver, while others found no significant microbial similarity between spouses. This paper addresses this gap by asking: Is microbial similarity merely a byproduct of living in the same house, or does the quality and nature of the relationship determine our microbial makeup?

Methods and Data

The researchers leveraged the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study (WLS), a comprehensive project following 1957 high school graduates for six decades. This dataset provides a unique opportunity to correlate current gut health with decades of documented social history.

  • Participants: The study analyzed 408 older adults (ages 58–91), including 94 spouse pairs and 83 sibling pairs.
  • Sequencing: 16S rRNA gene sequencing was used to characterize fecal microbiota.
  • Controls: To isolate the "social" effect, the team controlled for diet (habitual protein, vegetable, and fruit intake), antibiotic use, and chronic conditions like diabetes and heart disease.
  • Metrics: Researchers utilized standard ecological measures, including Shannon’s diversity and Chao’s richness (alpha-diversity), alongside UniFrac distances (beta-diversity) to compare microbial communities between pairs.

Key Insights

Adult Environment vs. Genetics

One of the most striking findings is that spouses have more similar microbiotas than siblings. This challenges the assumption that microbial communities established in early life—influenced by genetics and the birth environment—remain the dominant signature throughout adulthood. The shared environment and intimacy of marriage appear to override the genetic and early-life similarities shared by siblings.

The "Closeness" Threshold

Microbial similarity is not a guaranteed outcome of cohabitation. The study found that the microbial "marriage effect" was driven entirely by couples who reported being "very close." Couples who described their relationship as only "somewhat close" were no more similar to each other than total strangers. This suggests that the frequency and intensity of interaction are critical for microbial exchange.

Diversity as a Social Benefit

In the microbial world, diversity is generally synonymous with resilience and health; lower diversity is linked to conditions such as IBS, Crohn’s disease, and metabolic disorders. This study found that married individuals had significantly higher microbial diversity and richness than those living alone. Furthermore, for those not living with a partner, the frequency of getting together with friends and relatives was a strong predictor of microbial diversity ($P = 0.003$).

Direct Sharing Mechanisms

The shared taxa between spouses were often strictly anaerobic bacteria. Because these microbes cannot survive long in oxygen-rich environments (such as household surfaces), their presence in both spouses suggests transmission via direct physical contact or very close proximity rather than shared air or surfaces.

Results

  • Microbial Similarity: Spouses were significantly more similar than unrelated subjects (unweighted UniFrac $P = 3.2 \times 10^{-5}$) and sibling pairs ($P = 0.033$).
  • Shared Taxa: Spouses shared an average of 30.4% of their microbial species (OTUs), compared to 26.4% for siblings.
  • The Marriage Bonus: Married individuals showed higher Shannon diversity ($P = 0.005$) and Chao richness ($P = 0.011$) than those living alone, with the highest diversity observed in "very close" marriages.

Discussion and Limitations

While these results are robust, the study's demographic focus—predominantly white individuals from Wisconsin—may limit the generalizability of specific bacterial taxa identified. Additionally, as a cross-sectional analysis, the study shows correlation rather than absolute causation. It remains possible that individuals with certain microbial profiles are more predisposed to socialness, a potential "gut-brain axis" effect in reverse.

Future research should investigate younger cohorts to determine how quickly these microbial signatures emerge after the onset of a relationship and whether these signatures can predict long-term health outcomes as couples age. Ultimately, this study reinforces the idea that our social lives are not just psychological experiences but biological ones that fundamentally reshape our internal ecosystems.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Social relationships shape human health and mortality via behavioral, psychosocial, and physiological mechanisms, including inflammatory and immune responses. Though not tested in human studies, recent primate studies indicate that the gut microbiome may also be a biological mechanism linking relationships to health. Integrating microbiota data into the 60-year-old Wisconsin Longitudinal Study, we found that socialness with family and friends is associated with differences in the human fecal microbiota. Analysis of spouse (N = 94) and sibling pairs (N = 83) further revealed that spouses have more similar microbiota and more bacterial taxa in common than siblings, with no observed differences between sibling and unrelated pairs. These differences held even after accounting for dietary factors. The differences between unrelated individuals and married couples was driven entirely by couples who reported close relationships; there were no differences in similarity between couples reporting somewhat close relationships and unrelated individuals. Moreover, the microbiota of married individuals, compared to those living alone, has greater diversity and richness, with the greatest diversity among couples reporting close relationships, which is notable given decades of research documenting the health benefits of marriage. These results suggest that human interactions, especially sustained, close marital relationships, influence the gut microbiota.
BibTeX
@misc{dillmcfarland2018social,
  author = {Kimberly A. Dill‐McFarland and Zheng-Zheng Tang and Julia H. Kemis and Robert L. Kerby and Guanhua Chen and Alberto Palloni and Thomas J. Sorenson and Federico E. Rey and Pamela Herd},
  title = {{Social relationships, social isolation, and the human gut microbiota}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/428938},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure