Social genetic and social environment effects on parental and helper care in a cooperatively breeding bird

Mark J. Adams, Matthew R. Robinson, Maria‐Elena Mannarelli, Ben J. HatchwellProceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how social interactions influence parental care in cooperatively breeding long-tailed tits. It reveals that while individuals adjust their care based on their social group, these adjustments are primarily driven by current environmental conditions rather than stable genetic or long-term environmental factors. This highlights the dynamic nature of social effects in shaping behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many social species, an individual's behavior isn't solely determined by its own genes and environment, but also by the actions and traits of its social partners. This is particularly relevant in cooperative breeding systems, where multiple individuals contribute to raising offspring. Understanding how these "social effects" arise – whether from genetic influences passed down or from immediate environmental cues – is crucial for explaining the evolution and maintenance of such complex social behaviors. Previous research has often treated social effects as a single entity, making it difficult to disentangle their underlying causes. This paper aims to address this by partitioning social effects into their genetic and environmental components, and further distinguishing between stable (permanent) and fluctuating (current) environmental influences, using a wild cooperatively breeding bird as a model system.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative genetic framework, specifically a mixed-effects animal model, to analyze provisioning rates of long-tailed tits. This approach allowed them to partition the variance in an individual's behavior into several components:

  • Direct effects: An individual's own genetic and environmental influences on its behavior.
  • Social effects: The influence of social partners on an individual's behavior.

Crucially, they extended standard models to:

  • Partition social effects: Distinguish between social effects that are stable over an individual's lifetime (permanent environment) and those that vary year-to-year (current environment).
  • Incorporate social genetic effects (IGEs): Investigate whether the genetic makeup of social partners influences an individual's behavior.
  • Account for individual identity: Recognize that social effects might be specific to individual partners, not just their role (e.g., parent vs. helper).

They analyzed provisioning rates (visits per hour) collected over many years from a wild population of long-tailed tits.

Datasets

The study utilized a long-term dataset of provisioning rates collected from a wild population of long-tailed tits in the Rivelin Valley, Sheffield, UK, spanning from 1994 to 2011. This dataset included observations of approximately 25-72 breeding pairs per year, with individuals being ringed and monitored. Blood samples were collected for genetic analysis and pedigree construction.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Social context matters, but it's dynamic: Individuals in the study did adjust their provisioning effort based on who was in their social group, indicating the presence of social effects. However, these effects were not consistent across years.
  • Current environment dominates social effects: The primary driver of these year-to-year variations in social effects was the current environment, not stable genetic influences or long-term environmental factors. This suggests that birds are highly responsive to immediate social circumstances.
  • Little evidence for social genetic effects: The study found no significant evidence for social genetic effects, meaning the genes of helpers or other group members did not appear to directly influence the provisioning behavior of the focal bird. This suggests that genetic influences on social behavior are primarily direct.
  • Compensatory, not additive, responses: The observed social effects leaned towards a compensatory response, where birds tended to decrease their own effort when social partners were providing more care. This "load-lightening" effect is consistent with previous findings in this species.

Key Results

  • Individuals showed moderate consistency in their feeding rates within a given year, but this was largely explained by differences between nests and current environmental conditions.
  • Direct genetic and permanent environmental effects accounted for less than a third of the within-year variation in provisioning effort.
  • Social effects from helper identity were significant, accounting for a substantial portion of repeatable variance in parental feeding rates.
  • Social current environment effects explained a notable portion of the repeatable variance in provisioning rates, especially when considering both parents and helpers.
  • The contribution of social genetic effects to parental care was minimal, accounting for at most 10% of the between-individual variance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Underpowered for IGEs: The authors acknowledge that their sample sizes might have been underpowered to detect subtle social genetic effects, a common challenge in quantitative genetic studies of wild populations.
  • Repeatability of social effects: The lack of repeatability in social effects across years is attributed to within-individual variation from changes in breeding roles and fluctuating condition. Future work could explore how these role changes and condition variations interact with social environments.
  • Generalizability of the framework: While the framework is presented as general, its application to other species with different social structures and breeding systems would be valuable. The authors suggest that their approach provides a general framework for investigating social interactions in any ecological population.

Summary updated

Abstract

Phenotypes expressed in a social context are not only a function of the individual, but can also be shaped by the phenotypes of social partners. These social effects may play a major role in the evolution of cooperative breeding if social partners differ in the quality of care they provide and if individual carers adjust their effort in relation to that of other carers. When applying social effects models to wild study systems, it is also important to explore sources of individual plasticity that could masquerade as social effects. We studied offspring provisioning rates of parents and helpers in a wild population of long-tailed tits Aegithalos caudatus using a quantitative genetic framework to identify these social effects and partition them into genetic, permanent environment and current environment components. Controlling for other effects, individuals were consistent in their provisioning effort at a given nest, but adjusted their effort based on who was in their social group, indicating the presence of social effects. However, these social effects differed between years and social contexts, indicating a current environment effect, rather than indicating a genetic or permanent environment effect. While this study reveals the importance of examining environmental and genetic sources of social effects, the framework we present is entirely general, enabling a greater understanding of potentially important social effects within any ecological population.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adams2015social,
  author = {Mark J. Adams and Matthew R. Robinson and Maria‐Elena Mannarelli and Ben J. Hatchwell},
  title = {{Social genetic and social environment effects on parental and helper care in a cooperatively breeding bird}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1098/rspb.2015.0689},
}
Figure