Social Capital, Political Efficacy and Chinese Residents’ Willingness to Participate in Food Safety Governance

Nianyu Du, Chuanmei Zhang, Jing Qin, Liangqiang Jiang, Zongshuo Yin, Mo ChenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the factors influencing Chinese residents' willingness to participate in food safety governance, finding that social capital (reciprocity, trust, engagement) and political efficacy are key drivers. It highlights that political efficacy partially mediates the relationship between social capital and participation, and identifies specific combinations of these factors that lead to high engagement.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Effective food safety governance relies on active participation from various stakeholders, including residents. However, in many countries, including China, resident participation in food safety governance is relatively low. This study aims to understand the underlying reasons for this low participation by examining the roles of social capital and political efficacy, two crucial theoretical frameworks that have not been extensively integrated to explain this specific phenomenon in the Chinese context. The paper seeks to identify actionable strategies to boost resident engagement in ensuring food safety.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged methodological approach:

  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): This statistical technique was used to test the direct and indirect relationships between social capital (reciprocity norm, social engagement, institutional trust, interpersonal trust), political efficacy, and residents' willingness to participate in food safety governance. SEM allows for the simultaneous analysis of complex relationships and the testing of hypothesized causal pathways.
  • Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA): This method was used to explore the various combinations of conditions (antecedents) that lead to a high willingness to participate. Unlike traditional regression, fsQCA identifies "recipes" or configurations of factors that, together, produce a specific outcome, acknowledging that multiple pathways can lead to the same result. This approach is particularly useful for understanding complex causal relationships where multiple factors interact.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a survey of 714 residents in Shandong Province, China, collected between January and March 2022. The survey included measures for willingness to participate in food safety governance, reciprocity norm, social engagement, institutional trust, interpersonal trust, political efficacy, and sociodemographic variables (gender, age, income, education).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Social Capital is Foundational: The study strongly supports the idea that social capital, particularly reciprocity norms and institutional trust, significantly boosts residents' willingness to engage in food safety governance. This suggests that fostering a sense of mutual obligation and trust in governing bodies is crucial.
  • Political Efficacy as a Bridge: Political efficacy acts as a partial mediator, meaning that social capital doesn't just directly influence participation; it also enhances residents' belief in their ability to influence political outcomes, which in turn drives their willingness to participate. This highlights the importance of empowering citizens to feel their voices matter.
  • Multiple Paths to Engagement: fsQCA revealed that there isn't a single "magic bullet" for high participation. Instead, different combinations of factors can lead to strong engagement. This is critical for designing targeted interventions.
  • Core vs. Non-Core Factors: The fsQCA analysis identified reciprocity norm, institutional trust, and political efficacy as "core" conditions for high participation, meaning they are consistently present in successful configurations. Social engagement and sociodemographic variables were found to be "non-core," meaning their presence or absence can be compensated for by other factors in specific combinations.

Key Results

  • Direct Effects: Reciprocity norm (standardized path coefficient = 0.278), social engagement (0.108), institutional trust (0.093), and political efficacy (0.208) all had significant positive effects on residents' willingness to participate. Interpersonal trust had a negative but non-significant effect.
  • Mediating Effects: Reciprocity norm, social engagement, and institutional trust all positively influenced political efficacy, which in turn influenced willingness to participate. The indirect effects were: RN -> PE -> WP (0.019), SE -> PE -> WP (0.032), and InsT -> PE -> WP (0.103).
  • Sociodemographic Influences: Age had a positive significant effect (0.107), gender had a positive significant effect (0.058), and household income had a significant negative effect (-0.096) on willingness to participate. Education had a positive but non-significant effect.
  • fsQCA Configurations: Four configurations were identified for high willingness to participate, with Solution 3 ('SE • InsT • PE • Gender • ~Income') showing the highest explanation strength. Core elements across solutions were reciprocity norm, institutional trust, and political efficacy.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Interpersonal Trust Measurement: The measurement of interpersonal trust did not meet standard effectiveness thresholds, and its hypothesis was not supported. Future research should refine its measurement.
  • Geographic Scope: The study was limited to 16 cities in Shandong Province, China. Broader data collection is needed to verify the generalizability of the findings.
  • Policy Impact Analysis: Future research could explore the specific impacts of current food safety governance policies on potential participants' costs and benefits, which would further address the collective action dilemma.

The study suggests that future work should focus on understanding how social capital influences perceptions of costs and benefits in food safety governance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Residents play an important role as one of the main actors in food safety governance. To build a pattern of food safety risk co-governance, the positive and effective participation of residents is vital. This study first establishes a comprehensive analysis framework combining social capital theory and political efficacy theory. Data from a survey of 714 residents in Shandong Province, China, were analysed through structural equation modelling and fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) to examine the causal relationship between residents' willingness to participate and its driving factors. The results indicated that: (1) reciprocity norm, institutional trust and social engagement have significant positive effects on willingness to participate; (2) political efficacy has a partial mediating effect in the relationship between social capital and willingness to participate; (3) fsQCA findings have four solutions to achieving residents' strong willingness to participate; reciprocity norm, institutional trust and political efficacy are the core elements that affected residents' high willingness to participate, whereas social engagement and sociodemographic variables are the non-core variables. Therefore, we put forward suggestions for improving residents' willingness to participate in food safety governance, including improving the appeal expression and feedback mechanism, cultivating residents' social capital and paying attention to the superposition effect of social capital and political efficacy.
BibTeX
@article{du2022social,
  author = {Nianyu Du and Chuanmei Zhang and Jing Qin and Liangqiang Jiang and Zongshuo Yin and Mo Chen},
  title = {{Social Capital, Political Efficacy and Chinese Residents’ Willingness to Participate in Food Safety Governance}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192013147},
}
Figure