TL;DR
This study reveals that public attitudes towards "Tongqi" (wives of men who have sex with men) in Hubei, China, are moderately neutral but significantly influenced by socio-demographic factors and deeply ingrained cultural norms. While emotional sympathy exists, a lack of public understanding and structural support hinders meaningful action, highlighting the persistent stigma faced by this marginalized group.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In China, "Tongqi" represent a significant and growing population of heterosexual women married to gay men. This phenomenon is largely driven by traditional cultural pressures for marriage and procreation, coupled with the societal stigma surrounding homosexuality and the lack of legal recognition for same-sex relationships. Despite the increasing visibility of this issue, empirical research on the general public's attitudes towards Tongqi and the factors shaping these attitudes has been scarce. Existing knowledge primarily relies on the self-reported experiences of Tongqi themselves, leaving a gap in understanding broader societal perceptions. This paper aims to address this gap by investigating the general public's social attitudes towards Tongqi and identifying the determinants of these attitudes.
Methods
The study employed a sequential explanatory mixed-methods design, combining quantitative and qualitative approaches.
- Quantitative Phase: A structured online survey was administered to 587 participants in Hubei Province. Data collection occurred from June to August 2024. The survey included a self-designed demographic questionnaire, a 24-item Social Attitudes toward Tongqi Scale (based on the ABC model of attitudes), and validated scales for marriage intention, online social support, attitudes toward homosexuality, attitudes toward same-sex marriage, and empathy. Statistical analyses included descriptive statistics, independent-samples t-tests, one-way ANOVA, and multiple linear regression to identify significant predictors of social attitudes.
- Qualitative Phase: In-depth, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 20 participants from diverse social backgrounds to provide deeper contextual insights. Interviews were conducted between September and December 2024 and analyzed thematically using NVivo 14, following Colaizzi's seven-step phenomenological analysis.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from:
- Quantitative Survey: 587 valid responses from participants in Hubei Province, China, collected via the Wenjuanxing (Questionnaire Star) platform.
- Qualitative Interviews: 20 in-depth interviews with participants from Hubei Province.
No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, validated scales were adapted and used.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Cognitive-Affective-Behavioral Gap: A significant disconnect exists between expressed emotional sympathy towards Tongqi and actual supportive behaviors. While people may feel empathy, this rarely translates into concrete actions or advocacy.
- Cultural Norms as Primary Drivers: Deeply entrenched traditional Chinese cultural values, particularly regarding marriage, lineage continuity, and filial piety, are central to understanding societal attitudes. These norms create pressure for conformity and contribute to the marginalization of Tongqi.
- The "Tongqi" Phenomenon as a Symptom: The existence of Tongqi is viewed not as an anomaly but as a consequence of societal pressures and the lack of acceptance for homosexuality, forcing individuals into heterosexual marriages to conceal their identity.
- Education as a Crucial Lever: Participants consistently highlighted the need for comprehensive public education, including improved sex education, to combat misconceptions, reduce stigma, and foster greater understanding and acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals and Tongqi.
- Structural Support is Lacking: The absence of robust legal protections, accessible legal aid, and dedicated psychological support services exacerbates the vulnerability and marginalization of Tongqi.
Key Results
- Overall Social Attitudes: The mean score for social attitudes toward Tongqi was 89.93 (SD = 16.60), indicating a moderately neutral stance.
- Quantitative Predictors: Social attitude scores were significantly associated with gender (females more positive), education (higher education more positive), marital status (unmarried more positive), occupational status, perceptions of the social environment (gender-equal society more positive), and sexual orientation (heterosexual/bisexual more positive). Marriage intention, attitudes towards homosexuality, and empathy were also positively correlated with more favorable attitudes.
- Qualitative Themes: Three main themes emerged:
- Cognitive Aspect: Awareness shaped by traditional and societal norms, particularly the influence of traditional Chinese cultural values and the perceived absence of social justice.
- Affective Aspect: Public empathy and emotional orientation toward Tongqi, characterized by respect and moral support, and inclusion and emotional understanding.
- Behavioral Aspect: Expressed needs and public expectations for support mechanisms, including the need for public education, broader social acceptance, psychological support, and legal protection.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Sample Homogeneity: The sample was over-represented by highly educated and unmarried individuals, potentially limiting the generalizability of findings to the broader Chinese population.
- Urban-Rural and Regional Differences: The study did not systematically analyze urban-rural differences or regional cultural variations within Hubei Province, which could influence attitudes.
- Gender Stratification in Qualitative Data: The qualitative component lacked gender stratification, potentially limiting comprehensive insights into gender-specific views.
Future research should:
- Expand to diverse populations and sociocultural settings to improve external validity.
- Consider regional and urban-rural variations.
- Conduct gender-stratified qualitative analyses.
- Focus on developing and implementing targeted interventions informed by these findings, including multisectoral engagement to enhance awareness, reduce stigma, and establish comprehensive support systems for Tongqi.
Summary updated