Smartphone and web-based independent consultation and feedback for joint replacement surgeries: a randomized control trial protocol

Guixian Tong, Qingqing Geng, Tong Xu, Debin Wang, Tongzhu LiuBMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

Background: Cost control and usage regulation of medical materials (MMs) are critical issues for healthcare governance. While mobilizing doctors and patients in clinical decisions regarding MMs has potential, few interventions target specific behavioral deficiencies. This study aims to develop and validate an independent consultation and feedback system (ICFS) to optimize clinical decisions for joint replacement surgeries.

Methods: The protocol is based on a trans-theoretical framework incorporating soft systems-thinking, information asymmetry, and planned behavior. The intervention targets both patients (via a smartphone app) and doctors (via a web-based portal) across 30 hospitals in a cluster randomized controlled trial.

Discussion: The study expects to reduce moral hazards and medical costs by standardizing behaviors through economic and sustainable digital tools.

Trial registration: ISRCTN10152297.

Introduction: Addressing Information Asymmetry in Orthopedics

In orthopedic surgery, high-value medical materials (MMs)—such as artificial hips and knees—often constitute over 50% of total hospital costs. However, the selection process is frequently hindered by information asymmetry. Surgeons possess technical expertise but may face "moral hazards," such as over-prescribing expensive materials to mitigate perceived risks or comply with hospital policies. Conversely, patients often lack the medical literacy to evaluate options, leading to a passive role in decision-making.

Existing interventions typically focus solely on physician education. This paper proposes a "dual-sided" approach, engaging both surgeons and patients through an independent third-party platform to curb costs and standardize care.

Methods and Conceptual Framework

The study is a cluster randomized controlled trial (RCT) involving 30 hospitals in Anhui Province, China, with a target enrollment of 1,100 patients. The intervention is centered on the Independent Consultation and Feedback System (ICFS).

The researchers utilized "soft systems-thinking" to map the surgical journey—from admission to follow-up—identifying specific behavioral deficiencies. These deficiencies, such as doctors ignoring guidelines or patients concealing symptoms, were then mapped to specific digital "intervention ingredients."

Conceptual framework for identifying defects and developing countermeasures.

The ICFS Intervention

  1. Patient-Side (Smartphone App): Provides cost-benefit evaluation aids and a "facts review" feature to verify medical history, ensuring patient preferences are accurately captured.
  2. Doctor-Side (Web Portal): Offers evidence-based reminders and summaries of patient needs. It also implements a peer-audit mechanism for anonymous review of clinical decisions.

Data will be collected from electronic medical records (EMR) and telephone interviews at 6, 12, and 18 months post-discharge to assess long-term outcomes.

Key Insights: The Power of Independent Feedback

A central innovation of the ICFS is its maintenance by a provincial Quality Assurance Center rather than individual hospitals. This independence minimizes the influence of hospital-specific financial interests. By providing structured "cost-utility" summaries, the system empowers patients to become active participants, potentially steering choices toward more appropriate, cost-effective materials. This addresses the "dual delegate" problem, where doctors must balance the interests of the patient with those of the payer (insurance or government).

Anticipated Results and Impact

While final results are pending the trial's completion, the researchers have set specific benchmarks for success:

  • Cost Efficiency: A projected 20% reduction in the cost of medical materials.
  • Clinical Quality: Improved patient quality-of-life scores (measured via the EQ-5D-5L scale).
  • Process Standardization: Higher patient awareness of surgical risks and improved peer-expert audit scores for surgeons.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study faces challenges, including the short duration of hospital stays for orthopedic patients, which limits the intervention window. Additionally, the system does not yet account for varying patient personality types or broader systemic hospital management factors. Future work will focus on integrating more personalized behavioral models and deeper synchronization with hospital-wide software systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Cost control and usage regulation of medical materials (MMs) are the practical issues that the government pays close attention to. Although it is well established that there is great potential to mobilize doctors and patients in participating MMs-related clinical decisions, few interventions adopt effective measures against specific behavioral deficiencies. This study aims at developing and validating an independent consultation and feedback system (ICFS) for optimizing clinical decisions on the use of MMs for inpatients needing joint replacement surgeries. Methods Development of the research protocol is based on a problem or deficiency list derived on a trans-theoretical framework which incorporates including mainly soft systems-thinking, information asymmetry, crisis-coping, dual delegation and planned behavior. The intervention consists of two main components targeting at patients and doctors respectively. Each of the intervention ingredients is designed to tackle the doctor and patient-side problems with MMs using in joint replacement surgeries. The intervention arm receives 18 months' ICFS intervention program on the basis of the routine medical services; while the control arm, only the routine medical services. Implementation of the intervention is supported by an online platform established and maintained by the Quality Assurance Center for Medical Care in Anhui Province, a smartphone-based application program (APP) and a web-based clinical support system. Discussion The implementation of this study is expected to significantly reduce the deficiencies and moral hazards in decision-making of MMs using through the output of economic, efficient, sustainable and easy-to-promote cooperative intervention programs, thus greatly reducing medical costs and standardizing medical behaviors. Trial registration number ISRCTN10152297.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tong2021smartphone,
  author = {Guixian Tong and Qingqing Geng and Tong Xu and Debin Wang and Tongzhu Liu},
  title = {{Smartphone and web-based independent consultation and feedback for joint replacement surgeries: a randomized control trial protocol}},
  booktitle = {BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=HlqxJEQ79O},
}
Figure