Slipknot or Crystallographic Error: A Computational Analysis of the Plasmodium falciparum DHFR Structural Folds

Rolland Bantar Tata, Ali F. Alsulami, Olivier Sheik Amamuddy, Tom L. Blundell, Özlem Taştan BishopInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates an unusual "slipknot-like" fold in the Plasmodium falciparum DHFR enzyme, a crucial drug target. Through computational analysis, the researchers suggest this fold is likely a crystallographic artifact rather than a true knot, offering insights into potential errors in structural biology and guiding future experimental validation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Protein Data Bank (PDB) is a vital resource for structural biology, but it occasionally contains protein structures with atypical folds. These anomalies can arise from naturally occurring protein knots or, more commonly, from errors during experimental structure determination (like X-ray crystallography). Such errors, if uncorrected, can lead to misinterpretations in downstream research, including drug discovery efforts. This paper focuses on Plasmodium falciparum dihydrofolate reductase (PfDHFR), an important antimalarial drug target, which exhibits an unusual fold involving two specific loops (residues 20-51 and 191-205). The researchers aim to determine whether this atypical fold is a genuine protein knot or a result of crystallographic error, which could mislead drug development.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged computational approach:

  • Multiple Sequence Alignment (MSA): Researchers aligned DHFR protein sequences from various organisms to identify conserved regions and unique inserts. This helped pinpoint a specific insert within PfDHFR's loop 1 that might contribute to the observed atypical fold.
  • Knot Detection: The PfDHFR structure was analyzed using the KnotProt 2.0 database, a specialized resource for identifying knotted protein topologies.
  • Homology Modeling: Using established protein structures as templates (specifically those used in the original PfDHFR structure determination), new models of PfDHFR, E. coli DHFR, and M. tuberculosis DHFR were generated. This allowed for the exploration of alternative loop conformations, particularly "open" conformations where the loops were computationally separated.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: All-atom MD simulations were performed on both the original (closed) and the newly modeled (open) loop conformations for PfDHFR, E. coli DHFR, and M. tuberculosis DHFR. These simulations, run for 200 ns, allowed the researchers to observe the dynamic behavior and stability of these loop structures.
  • Structure Quality Evaluation: Various metrics, including zDOPE scores and MolProbity analysis, were used to assess the quality of both the initial and simulated protein structures.
  • Pocket Analysis: Fpocket software was used to analyze the active site pocket volume and druggability in the representative structures.

Datasets

  • Swiss-Prot Database: Used for retrieving reviewed DHFR and DHFR-TS protein sequences.
  • RCSB PDB: The primary source for deposited protein structures, including the PfDHFR structures and the nine molecular replacement templates used in its determination.
  • KnotProt 2.0 Database: A specialized database for identifying knotted protein topologies.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilizes existing databases and structures for its analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Slipknot" is Likely an Artifact: Despite the visual appearance of a slipknot in PfDHFR's loop 1, computational analysis (including KnotProt 2.0) failed to detect any actual knots. This strongly suggests the observed fold is a crystallographic error.
  • A Specific Insert Exacerbates the "Knot": MSA revealed a unique insert in PfDHFR's loop 1, which appears to contribute to the slipknot-like appearance by interacting with another loop.
  • Lab-Effect Hypothesis: The study proposes that a specific research group (Group A) might be responsible for consistently propagating this loop misplacement in PfDHFR structures deposited in the PDB over several years, suggesting a "lab-effect" in structural determination.
  • Open Conformations are Plausible: MD simulations of homology-modeled structures showed that the loops can adopt more relaxed, "open" conformations, which are structurally plausible and unentangled, further supporting the idea that the observed "knot" is not a native feature.
  • Implications for Drug Discovery: If crystallographic errors are not identified, they can lead to incorrect understanding of enzyme-ligand interactions and potentially hinder the development of effective drugs.

Key Results

  • No Knots Detected: KnotProt 2.0 analysis found no evidence of knots in the PfDHFR structure.
  • Homology Models Show Unentangled Loops: Modeled structures of PfDHFR, E. coli DHFR, and M. tuberculosis DHFR, particularly in their "open" loop conformations, displayed plausible, unentangled loop arrangements.
  • MD Simulations Confirm Stability of Open Conformations: MD simulations demonstrated that the open loop conformations are stable over the simulated time, suggesting they are energetically feasible.
  • PfDHFR Active Site Partitioning: Analysis of the representative structures revealed that the PfDHFR active site can be partitioned into inner and outer pockets, a feature not observed in E. coli or M. tuberculosis DHFR. This partitioning is potentially linked to loop 1's interaction with the TS enzyme in the DHFR-TS complex.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Knot Detection: The paper acknowledges that slipknots can be challenging for computational detection methods, though KnotProt 2.0 is designed to address this.
  • Reliance on Templates: Homology modeling relies on existing structures, and if the templates themselves contain errors, these can be propagated.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that these computational findings should guide future crystallographic experiments to provide definitive insights into the atypical folds. Further experimental validation is crucial to confirm whether the observed fold is indeed a crystallographic artifact. Investigating the functional implications of the observed active site partitioning in PfDHFR is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

The presence of protein structures with atypical folds in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) is rare and may result from naturally occurring knots or crystallographic errors. Proper characterisation of such folds is imperative to understanding the basis of naturally existing knots and correcting crystallographic errors. If left uncorrected, such errors can frustrate downstream experiments that depend on the structures containing them. An atypical fold has been identified in <i>P. falciparum</i> dihydrofolate reductase (<i>Pf</i>DHFR) between residues 20-51 (loop 1) and residues 191-205 (loop 2). This enzyme is key to drug discovery efforts in the parasite, necessitating a thorough characterisation of these folds. Using multiple sequence alignments (MSA), a unique insert was identified in loop 1 that exacerbates the appearance of the atypical fold-giving it a slipknot-like topology. However, <i>Pf</i>DHFR has not been deposited in the knotted proteins database, and processing its structure failed to identify any knots within its folds. The application of protein homology modelling and molecular dynamics simulations on the DHFR domain of <i>P. falciparum</i> and those of two other organisms (<i>E. coli</i> and <i>M. tuberculosis</i>) that were used as molecular replacement templates in solving the <i>Pf</i>DHFR structure revealed plausible unentangled or open conformations of these loops. These results will serve as guides for crystallographic experiments to provide further insights into the atypical folds identified.
BibTeX
@article{tata2022slipknot,
  author = {Rolland Bantar Tata and Ali F. Alsulami and Olivier Sheik Amamuddy and Tom L. Blundell and Özlem Taştan Bishop},
  title = {{Slipknot or Crystallographic Error: A Computational Analysis of the Plasmodium falciparum DHFR Structural Folds}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms23031514},
}
Figure