Skill reconstruction as induction of LQ controllers with subgoals

IJCAI 1997

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to behavioral cloning that reconstructs an operator's control skills by inducing Linear Quadratic (LQ) controllers. By modeling the system dynamics and identifying operator-defined subgoals, this method significantly improves the robustness and yield of induced controllers compared to traditional decision tree methods, offering deeper insights into human control strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reconstructing complex human control skills, such as operating a crane or flying a plane, is a challenging task. Traditional methods like behavioral cloning, which learn directly from operator traces, often result in brittle controllers that lack the nuanced strategies humans employ, like setting subgoals. These induced controllers are also prone to failure when faced with minor changes in the task or system dynamics. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more robust and interpretable method for skill reconstruction that captures the underlying structure of human control, including the concept of subgoals.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its novel approach to behavioral cloning, which leverages Linear Quadratic Regulation (LQR) theory. Instead of directly inducing decision trees, the authors propose:

  1. System Dynamics Induction: Learning a linear model of the controlled system's dynamics using locally weighted regression from operator traces.
  2. LQ Controller Induction: Treating the operator's actions as attempts to optimize an LQ cost function. The problem is framed as an inverse optimal control problem: given operator actions, find the LQ cost matrices (Q and R) that best explain these actions.
  3. Subgoal Identification: Extending the approach to identify implicit subgoals within an execution trace. A subgoal is defined as a point in the state space where the operator's strategy (reflected in the LQ cost matrices) changes. This is achieved by searching for points that minimize a weighted LQ-fit error across the trace, effectively breaking down the task into stages, each with its own LQ controller and associated subgoal.

Datasets

The paper uses experimental data from manually controlling a crane simulator. This data was collected from six students who learned to control the simulator in a previous study. The authors do not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilize existing experimental data to evaluate their approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LQ Controllers for Robustness: Framing skill reconstruction within the LQR framework inherently leads to more robust controllers. LQ controllers are goal-directed and consider system dynamics, making them less susceptible to minor perturbations than reactive decision trees.
  • Subgoals as Strategic Shifts: The identification of subgoals is crucial. The paper demonstrates that operators don't use a single, static strategy but rather adapt their approach based on intermediate objectives. These subgoals are not explicitly programmed but are inferred from changes in the operator's control strategy.
  • Inverse Optimal Control for Interpretation: By solving the inverse problem (finding Q and R from actions), the induced controllers become more interpretable. The learned Q and R matrices provide insights into what aspects of the state and action the operator prioritized at different stages.
  • "Clean-up Effect": In some cases, the induced controllers, especially those with subgoals, outperformed the original human operator in terms of task completion time, suggesting a potential for learning more efficient strategies.

Key Results

  • Improved Robustness: Controllers induced using this method showed significantly higher success rates (over 60%) when tested against modified crane parameters (friction, cargo weight) compared to previous regression tree approaches (less than 10% yield). Nineteen out of twenty controllers successfully completed tasks with varied start states.
  • Higher Yield: The success rate of induced controllers is substantially improved, making the cloning process more effective.
  • Interpretability: The learned Q and R matrices provide a basis for understanding operator strategies, revealing differences in how operators prioritize state and action components. For example, operator S was more conservative, while operator V accelerated faster at the risk of larger swings.
  • Faster Task Completion: In some instances, the induced clones accomplished the task faster than the original operator, demonstrating the "clean-up effect."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear System Assumption: The core LQR theory assumes linear system dynamics. While empirical results show robustness even with non-linear systems, this remains a theoretical limitation.
  • Subgoal Definition: The current definition of a subgoal is based on a change in LQ-fit error. Future work could explore more sophisticated methods for subgoal identification.
  • Diagonal Matrices: For simplification and interpretability, the experiments often restricted Q and R matrices to be diagonal. Exploring non-diagonal matrices could potentially capture more complex relationships.
  • Complexity of Optimization: While improved, the local optimization process for finding Q and R can still be computationally intensive, especially for high-dimensional systems.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the approach to more complex control tasks and further investigating the interpretation of induced subgoals and their relationship to human cognitive processes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997skill,
  title = {{Skill reconstruction as induction of LQ controllers with subgoals}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure