Abstract
Generalized Planning (GP) aims to synthesize a single program or policy capable of solving an infinite set of related problem instances. This paper introduces a formal framework that combines the Situation Calculus with Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) synthesis. By utilizing "temporally lifted abstractions," the authors bridge the gap between abstract high-level strategies and concrete low-level implementations, providing mathematical guarantees of soundness and completeness for synthesized programs.
Introduction
In traditional automated planning, the goal is to find a sequence of actions that transitions an agent from a specific initial state to a goal state. In contrast, Generalized Planning (GP) seeks a "recipe"—a program that works across an entire class of problems, such as sorting a list of any length or traversing a binary tree of any depth.
The primary challenge in GP is the complexity of concrete problem instances, which often exceed the capabilities of automated synthesis tools. While researchers frequently use abstractions to simplify these problems, existing methods often lack formal guarantees regarding soundness (whether the abstract solution works in reality) and completeness (whether the abstraction captures all necessary details). Furthermore, handling temporal constraints and fairness—such as ensuring an agent eventually reaches a destination—remains a significant hurdle.
Methodology: Temporally Lifted Abstractions
The authors propose a framework built upon the Situation Calculus, a logic-based language for representing dynamic domains. The core innovation is the concept of temporally lifted abstractions. Unlike traditional methods that abstract static states, this approach abstracts "traces" (sequences of actions over time).
Key Components
- Nondeterministic Situation Calculus (DL21): This is used to model the low-level (LL) concrete world, where actions may have varying outcomes depending on the environment.
- Refinement Mapping: This links high-level (HL) propositional fluents and actions to low-level ConGolog programs. For instance, a high-level action like
nextHLis mapped to a sequence of low-level instructions such asstartHLAction; nextLL; endHLAction. - LTL Trace Constraints: LTL is used to define assumptions about the environment. These constraints ensure that abstract "fairness" assumptions—like the guarantee that iterating through a list will eventually terminate—are grounded in concrete reality.
- Simulation-based Proofs: The framework employs a unidirectional $m$-simulation to demonstrate that if a high-level model can simulate all low-level models, any strategy synthesized for the high-level model is guaranteed to function correctly across all concrete instances.
Synthesis and Results
The framework leverages existing LTL synthesis tools, such as the Strix engine, to automatically generate a controller from abstract goals and constraints. This controller takes the form of a finite-state machine (FSM) that dictates actions based on observations.
To validate the framework, the authors applied it to the "Minimum in a List" problem—finding the smallest value in a singly-linked list of unknown length. The synthesis engine produced a provably correct controller that manages the iteration and comparison logic required for the task.
Key Insights
- Trace Constraints as a Bridge: By mapping high-level LTL constraints to low-level behaviors, the authors ensure that abstract solutions do not rely on impossible environmental assumptions.
- Refinement as Programming: High-level actions act as placeholders for small, concrete programs, allowing the planner to focus on strategic logic rather than implementation details.
- Universal Applicability: A single, simple propositional high-level model can represent an infinite variety of low-level models. If the high-level model is a valid abstraction, the synthesized strategy is automatically a solution for the entire GP problem class.
Conclusion and Future Work
The authors formally prove (Theorem 16) that a strategy synthesized at the abstract level can be refined into a strategy that achieves the goal in all concrete instances. While the current framework requires manual creation of the refinement mapping and high-level theory, it sets the stage for future work in automating abstraction discovery. Additionally, the authors propose building modular libraries for common data structures (lists, trees, graphs) to streamline the application of this framework to diverse planning puzzles and data manipulation tasks.
Summary updated