Situation Calculus for Controller Synthesis in Manufacturing Systems with First-Order State Representation (Extended Abstract)

Giuseppe De Giacomo, Paolo Felli, Brian Logan, Fabio Patrizi, Sebastian SardiñaIJCAI 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of automatically generating control software for manufacturing systems in a "manufacturing-as-a-service" (MaaS) environment. They propose using the Situation Calculus, a powerful AI formalism for reasoning about actions and change, to synthesize these controllers from high-level process recipes and detailed facility descriptions. This work provides a formal, decidable approach for synthesizing controllers even when dealing with complex, relational state representations, a significant step beyond previous propositional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "manufacturing-as-a-service" (MaaS) paradigm envisions a future where manufacturing facilities act like cloud services, offering their capabilities on-demand. In this model, customers provide "process recipes" – abstract, system-independent descriptions of how a product should be manufactured. The challenge for a facility is to automatically translate these abstract recipes into concrete execution plans, delegating tasks to its available resources (e.g., CNC machines, robots). This process planning and controller synthesis is currently a manual, time-consuming activity, which is not scalable for the dynamic, on-the-fly nature of MaaS.

Existing AI approaches for this problem often rely on propositional representations of states, which are too simplistic for manufacturing. Manufacturing processes inherently involve complex relationships between objects (parts, tools, materials) and data, requiring a richer, first-order, relational state representation. This paper addresses the gap of how to perform controller synthesis in such a rich, relational setting, moving beyond propositional limitations.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in leveraging the Situation Calculus, a well-established AI formalism for reasoning about actions and change, to model and synthesize controllers for MaaS. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • First-Order State Representation: They use the Situation Calculus to represent the state of the manufacturing system using first-order logic. This allows for rich, relational descriptions of objects and their properties, which is crucial for modeling manufacturing processes accurately.
  • Action Theories: Manufacturing processes are formalized as action theories within the Situation Calculus. These theories define the preconditions and effects of actions, capturing how the system's state changes over time.
  • ConGolog Programs: High-level process recipes and the capabilities of individual manufacturing resources are modeled as ConGolog programs. ConGolog is a logic programming language that extends the Situation Calculus with constructs for concurrency, nondeterminism, and sequencing, making it suitable for expressing complex process flows.
  • Synchronized Concurrency: A novel extension to ConGolog is introduced: synchronized concurrency (|||). This operator allows multiple processes (representing different manufacturing resources) to execute actions simultaneously in a single transition step, provided their joint execution is explicitly allowed by a global action theory. This is a key feature for modeling how multiple machines can work together.
  • Information Models and Mappings: The framework distinguishes between a "cloud level" (resource-independent) information model and a "facility level" (resource-dependent) information model. Mappings are defined to bridge these two levels, translating abstract recipe actions and states into concrete facility actions and states.
  • Controller Synthesis via Game Theory: The problem of realizability (whether a recipe can be executed by a facility) and controller synthesis is framed as a two-player game between an "ENVIRONMENT" (representing the recipe) and a "CONTROLLER" (the system being synthesized). This game is played on a "game arena" (GA) derived from the Situation Calculus theories. The controller's goal is to find a winning strategy in this game, which directly translates into a computable controller.
  • Decidability Results: The paper identifies two important cases for which controller synthesis is decidable:
  • Finite Domains: When the number of objects in the system is finite.
  • Bounded Action Theories: When the number of objects being processed at any given time is bounded, even if the total number of objects is infinite. This is a practical assumption for most manufacturing facilities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Abstract and Concrete: The core insight is that the Situation Calculus, with its rich first-order capabilities, provides a principled way to formally bridge the gap between abstract, system-independent process recipes and concrete, facility-specific execution plans.
  • Formalizing MaaS: The paper offers a robust, formal foundation for the MaaS paradigm, moving beyond informal descriptions and enabling automated reasoning and synthesis.
  • Synchronized Concurrency is Crucial: The introduction of synchronized concurrency (|||) in ConGolog is a significant contribution, as it accurately models the simultaneous execution of actions by multiple resources, a common scenario in manufacturing.
  • Game Theory for Synthesis: Framing controller synthesis as a game is a powerful technique. It allows for a clear definition of what it means for a controller to "realize" a recipe and provides a mechanism for automatically finding such controllers.
  • Decidability in Relational Settings: Achieving decidability results for controller synthesis in a first-order, relational setting is a major breakthrough. This makes the proposed approach practical for real-world manufacturing systems, which are rarely simple.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a formal framework for representing MaaS scenarios using Situation Calculus and ConGolog.
  • They introduce synchronized concurrency (|||) for modeling simultaneous resource execution.
  • They define a realizability relation between recipes and facilities.
  • They frame controller synthesis as a game-theoretic problem and show how to extract a controller from a winning strategy.
  • Crucially, they establish decidability results for controller synthesis in the presence of relational state representations, specifically for finite domain and bounded action theories. This means that for these practical cases, the synthesis problem can be solved algorithmically.

Limitations and Future Work

  • State-Boundedness Assumption: While practical, the decidability results are contingent on the "state-boundedness" assumption. Systems that truly accumulate an unbounded number of objects might still pose challenges.
  • Complexity of Synthesis: While decidable, the complexity of the synthesis process for complex scenarios is not explicitly detailed, but it's implied to be non-trivial.
  • Scalability: The paper is an extended abstract, and the full details of the algorithms and their scalability for large-scale manufacturing systems would be of interest.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their approach can be applied to other AI frameworks for reasoning about actions and data-aware/artifact-centric systems. Further exploration of these connections and the application to more complex manufacturing scenarios are natural next steps.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{giacomo2022situation,
  author = {Giuseppe De Giacomo and Paolo Felli and Brian Logan and Fabio Patrizi and Sebastian Sardiña},
  title = {{Situation Calculus for Controller Synthesis in Manufacturing Systems with First-Order State Representation (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2022/798},
}
Figure