Sisyphus, a Workflow Manager Designed for Machine Translation and Automatic Speech Recognition

Jan-Thorsten Peter, Eugen Beck, Hermann NeyEMNLP 2018

TL;DR

This paper introduces Sisyphus, a Python-based workflow manager designed to streamline complex machine learning experiments, particularly for tasks like machine translation and automatic speech recognition. It tackles the challenge of managing intricate pipelines of commands, ensuring reproducibility, and efficiently reusing computations, ultimately saving researchers significant time and effort.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building state-of-the-art machine learning systems, especially in areas like machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR), involves a lengthy and complex sequence of operations. This pipeline typically includes data preprocessing, model training with numerous parameter variations, and rigorous evaluation of the outputs. Manually managing these steps is not only tedious but also highly prone to errors, making it difficult to reproduce results accurately. Existing ad-hoc scripting solutions often lack flexibility when workflows change, and parallel execution can lead to overlooked errors. Furthermore, organizing and naming numerous related experiments can become unwieldy. Sisyphus aims to solve these problems by providing a structured, automated, and robust system for managing these experimental workflows.

Methods

Sisyphus is built around the concept of Jobs, which represent individual computational tasks. These Jobs are organized into a directed acyclic graph (DAG), where edges represent dependencies (files or parameters). The core innovation lies in its ability to:

  • Define Workflows in Python: This allows for immense flexibility, enabling users to leverage the rich Python ecosystem for scripting, debugging, and documentation.
  • Automatic Dependency Management: Sisyphus constructs the DAG and determines the optimal order of execution for Jobs, automatically handling parallelization where possible.
  • Reusability and Caching: By computing a hash based on a Job's input parameters, Sisyphus can identify and reuse previously computed results, avoiding redundant calculations and saving disk space.
  • Error Handling and Resumption: The system includes robust error checking, flagging issues when shell commands fail, variables are uninitialized, or Python code throws exceptions. It also supports marking tasks as "resumeable" to automatically handle interruptions due to resource limits.
  • Separation of Workflow Description and Execution: This allows for storing workflow definitions on stable storage while experiment outputs can reside on larger, potentially less reliable file systems.
  • Generalizability: Sisyphus is designed to integrate any external tool with a command-line interface, making it highly adaptable.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly list specific datasets used for training or evaluation of Sisyphus itself. However, it mentions that Sisyphus is extensively used for machine translation and automatic speech recognition tasks, implying its application on standard datasets within these fields, such as those used in WMT (Workshop on Machine Translation) and IWSLT (International Workshop on Spoken Language Translation) competitions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Python as a Universal Language for Workflows: Leveraging Python for workflow definition is a powerful choice, offering unparalleled flexibility and integration with existing tools. This moves away from specialized workflow languages towards a more accessible and extensible paradigm.
  • The Power of Hashing for Reproducibility and Efficiency: Using parameter-based hashing to identify and reuse Jobs is a crucial mechanism for avoiding redundant computations and ensuring that identical experiments yield identical results.
  • Structured Experiment Management: Sisyphus provides a clear directory structure and naming conventions that alleviate the common problem of managing a large number of complex, interrelated experiments.
  • Implicit Parallelism and Error Recovery: The system's ability to automatically schedule jobs in parallel and its mechanisms for error detection and potential resumption significantly reduce the manual burden on researchers.

Key Results

The paper highlights the practical success of Sisyphus through its extensive use in real-world research:

  • Extensive Use in MT and ASR: Sisyphus has been used for all WMT and IWSLT submissions by the RWTH Aachen University since 2015.
  • Speech Recognition Applications: It was employed for speech recognition in research by Zeyer et al. (2017).
  • Industry Adoption: AppTek also uses Sisyphus internally, indicating its practical utility beyond academia.
  • Scalability: The system has been successfully tested in large-scale setups and can handle thousands of tasks within a workflow.

While specific quantitative results (e.g., percentage of time saved, reduction in errors) are not detailed, the widespread adoption and successful application in high-stakes research competitions serve as strong qualitative evidence of its effectiveness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Input File Changes: Sisyphus assumes that input files remain static. If an input file changes, the user must manually tell Sisyphus to invalidate all dependent jobs. The paper suggests that automatic handling of changing input files is beyond its current scope.
  • Reproducibility of Asynchronous Tasks: While Sisyphus aims for reproducibility, it cannot guarantee exact same results for asynchronous tasks like neural network training if randomness is not explicitly controlled via seeds.
  • Shared File System Requirement: All currently supported engine implementations require nodes to have access to a shared file system.

Future work is not explicitly detailed, but the existing features and the open-source nature of Sisyphus suggest potential for further development in areas like more sophisticated handling of dynamic inputs, enhanced distributed computing capabilities, and broader integration with emerging ML frameworks.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{peter2018sisyphus,
  author = {Jan-Thorsten Peter and Eugen Beck and Hermann Ney},
  title = {{Sisyphus, a Workflow Manager Designed for Machine Translation and Automatic Speech Recognition}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure