Single Ventricle Reconstruction III: Brain Connectome and Neurodevelopmental Outcomes: Design, Recruitment, and Technical Challenges of a Multicenter, Observational Neuroimaging Study

Vanessa Schmithorst, Rafael Ceschin, Vincent Lee, Julia Wallace, Aurelia Sahel, Thomas L. Chenevert, Hemant Parmar, Jeffrey Berman, Arastoo Vossough, Deqiang Qiu, Nadja Kadom, P. Ellen Grant, Borjan Gagoski, Peter S. LaViolette, Mohit Maheshwari, Lynn A. Sleeper, David C. Bellinger, Dawn Ilardi, Sharon O’Neil, Thomas A. Miller, Jon Detterich, Kevin D. Hill, Andrew M. Atz, Marc E. Richmond, James Cnota, William T. Mahle, Nancy S. Ghanayem, J. William Gaynor, Caren S. Goldberg, Jane W. Newburger, Ashok PanigrahyDiagnostics 2023 · DOI

ClinicalTrials.gov Registration Number: NCT02692443

Introduction

Advances in cardiothoracic surgery have significantly improved survival rates for children born with Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome (HLHS), a complex congenital heart defect where the left side of the heart is severely underdeveloped. While the Fontan procedure has allowed these children to survive into adolescence and adulthood, a "hidden cost" has emerged: a high prevalence of neurodevelopmental and psychosocial impairments.

Traditional clinical models—which rely on factors such as birth weight, socioeconomic status, or surgical bypass time—account for only about one-third of the variation in neurodevelopmental outcomes. To address this "missing link," the Single Ventricle Reconstruction III (SVRIII) Brain Connectome study was launched. This multicenter, observational study aims to determine if the brain’s "connectome"—the global organization of structural and functional neural pathways—can serve as a more precise biomarker for long-term outcomes.

The Connectome Hypothesis

Rather than focusing on isolated brain lesions, the SVRIII study adopts a systems-level approach. The researchers hypothesize that the cumulative stress of living with a single-ventricle physiology, combined with the impact of multiple open-heart surgeries, alters the brain's network topology. By mapping these networks, the team hopes to identify specific patterns of connectivity that correlate with executive dysfunction, lower IQ, and behavioral challenges.

Methodological Framework

Imaging Modalities

The study utilized 3T MRI to capture a comprehensive view of brain architecture:

  • Structural Connectivity: Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) and High Angular Resolution Diffusion Imaging (HARDI) were employed to map white matter tracts, the "cables" of the brain.
  • Functional Connectivity: Resting-state BOLD fMRI was used to monitor spontaneous neural activity and map how different brain regions communicate during rest.

Graph Theory and Analysis

To quantify the complexity of these networks, the researchers applied graph theory. By constructing adjacency matrices, they calculated several key metrics:

  • Global Efficiency: A measure of how effectively information is integrated across the entire brain.
  • Modularity: The degree to which the brain is organized into specialized, functional sub-units.
  • Transitivity: A measure of local segregation and the robustness of neural clusters.

Overcoming Technical and Logistical Hurdles

Conducting high-quality neuroimaging across multiple institutions presents significant challenges, particularly when using different MRI hardware (e.g., Siemens vs. Philips platforms).

Multicenter Harmonization

To ensure data comparability, the study implemented a rigorous three-tier harmonization strategy:

  1. Protocol Standardization: Imaging parameters were aligned with the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study standards.
  2. Phantom Calibration: The team used "human phantoms" (the same individuals scanned at multiple sites) and "synthetic phantoms" (textile-based models mimicking brain fibers) to identify and correct hardware-specific biases.
  3. Statistical Correction: The ComBat (empirical Bayes) method was applied retrospectively to remove residual "site effects" from the data.

Participant Engagement

Recruitment for the SVRIII study faced a unique challenge: participant fatigue. Adolescents in the cohort were already undergoing two days of intensive cardiac and exercise testing for the parent study. Adding a lengthy, noisy MRI session led to initial dropout risks. The study team mitigated this through coordinator-led engagement and flexible scheduling, emphasizing the importance of the brain-heart connection to the families involved.

Study Cohort and Data Integrity

The study successfully built a specialized dataset comprising:

  • SVRIII Cohort: 125 participants (116 with analyzable scans) aged 10–15 years.
  • Healthy Controls: 93 age-matched referents (89 with analyzable scans).
  • Phantom Database: A unique collection of over 100 scans used for cross-site calibration.

Data was managed via a secure, XNAT-based cloud portal, allowing 24 different sites to upload de-identified DICOM images while maintaining strict quality control and privacy standards.

Preliminary Results and Future Directions

While primarily a design and methods paper, the authors reported successful proof-of-concept for their infrastructure. Despite the disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the study reached its target enrollment of 218 subjects, providing 80% power to detect small effect sizes in network changes. Technical analysis confirmed that the signal-to-noise ratio (tSNR) for functional imaging was consistent across different scanner brands after harmonization.

Moving forward, the research team is entering the analytical phase, using mediation analysis to determine if medical factors (like bypass time) cause specific changes in brain network topology that subsequently lead to neurocognitive deficits. By bridging the gap between cardiac history and brain health, the SVRIII study aims to pave the way for targeted interventions to improve the quality of life for survivors of complex congenital heart disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

Patients with hypoplastic left heart syndrome who have been palliated with the Fontan procedure are at risk for adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes, lower quality of life, and reduced employability. We describe the methods (including quality assurance and quality control protocols) and challenges of a multi-center observational ancillary study, SVRIII (Single Ventricle Reconstruction Trial) Brain Connectome. Our original goal was to obtain advanced neuroimaging (Diffusion Tensor Imaging and Resting-BOLD) in 140 SVR III participants and 100 healthy controls for brain connectome analyses. Linear regression and mediation statistical methods will be used to analyze associations of brain connectome measures with neurocognitive measures and clinical risk factors. Initial recruitment challenges occurred that were related to difficulties with: (1) coordinating brain MRI for participants already undergoing extensive testing in the parent study, and (2) recruiting healthy control subjects. The COVID-19 pandemic negatively affected enrollment late in the study. Enrollment challenges were addressed by: (1) adding additional study sites, (2) increasing the frequency of meetings with site coordinators, and (3) developing additional healthy control recruitment strategies, including using research registries and advertising the study to community-based groups. Technical challenges that emerged early in the study were related to the acquisition, harmonization, and transfer of neuroimages. These hurdles were successfully overcome with protocol modifications and frequent site visits that involved human and synthetic phantoms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schmithorst2023single,
  author = {Vanessa Schmithorst and Rafael Ceschin and Vincent Lee and Julia Wallace and Aurelia Sahel and Thomas L. Chenevert and Hemant Parmar and Jeffrey Berman and Arastoo Vossough and Deqiang Qiu and Nadja Kadom and P. Ellen Grant and Borjan Gagoski and Peter S. LaViolette and Mohit Maheshwari and Lynn A. Sleeper and David C. Bellinger and Dawn Ilardi and Sharon O’Neil and Thomas A. Miller and Jon Detterich and Kevin D. Hill and Andrew M. Atz and Marc E. Richmond and James Cnota and William T. Mahle and Nancy S. Ghanayem and J. William Gaynor and Caren S. Goldberg and Jane W. Newburger and Ashok Panigrahy},
  title = {{Single Ventricle Reconstruction III: Brain Connectome and Neurodevelopmental Outcomes: Design, Recruitment, and Technical Challenges of a Multicenter, Observational Neuroimaging Study}},
  booktitle = {Diagnostics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/diagnostics13091604},
}
Figure