Single-photon detectors based on InP avalanche diodes: status and prospects

Mark A. Itzler, Xudong Jiang, Mark Entwistle, Bora M. Onat, Krystyna SlomkowskiProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details advancements in InP-based single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) for 1.55 µm detection, focusing on improving the trade-off between dark count rate (DCR) and photon detection efficiency (PDE). The authors present a novel "negative feedback" approach integrated directly into the SPAD structure, significantly reducing charge flow per avalanche and paving the way for higher repetition rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting single photons is crucial for applications like quantum communication, advanced imaging, and high-sensitivity spectroscopy. Avalanche photodiodes (APDs) operating in Geiger mode (SPADs) are excellent candidates due to their high gain and sensitivity. However, two key limitations have historically hindered their widespread adoption: a fundamental trade-off between photon detection efficiency (PDE) and dark count rate (DCR), and a limited maximum count rate due to afterpulsing. Afterpulsing occurs when carriers trapped during an avalanche event are released later, triggering spurious counts. This paper tackles both these challenges by improving the understanding of DCR mechanisms and introducing a new device architecture to mitigate afterpulsing.

Methods

The authors employed a combination of detailed numerical modeling and experimental validation.

  • DCR Modeling: They used McIntyre's formulations for breakdown voltage and avalanche probability, incorporating impact ionization coefficients from Zappa et al. Crucially, they modeled dark carrier generation through thermal (SRH) and field-mediated tunneling (TAT) processes, analyzing their temperature and bias dependence.
  • Device Design and Fabrication: Based on modeling insights, they designed and fabricated InGaAs/InP SPADs with a Separate Absorption and Multiplication (SAM) region. A key innovation is the monolithic integration of negative feedback elements (thin film resistors) directly onto the SPAD chip. This "negative feedback avalanche diode" (NFAD) concept aims to achieve rapid self-quenching.
  • Experimental Characterization: They performed extensive measurements of DCR, PDE, and afterpulsing over various temperatures and excess bias voltages. Techniques included time-correlated carrier counting and measurements of DCR versus hold-off time and repetition rate.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental data generated from their fabricated devices and simulation results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DCR Mechanisms Unveiled: The paper clearly identifies trap-assisted tunneling (TAT) as the dominant DCR mechanism at low temperatures (<200 K) and thermal generation as the primary contributor at higher temperatures. This understanding is crucial for optimizing device performance across different operating conditions.
  • Activation Energy (Ea) as a Diagnostic Tool: By analyzing the temperature dependence of DCR through its activation energy (Ea), the authors could distinguish between tunneling and thermal generation processes, validating their modeling.
  • Negative Feedback for Self-Quenching: The core innovation is the monolithic integration of negative feedback resistors. This allows the device to rapidly "self-quench" after an avalanche event, significantly reducing the charge flow per event.
  • Partial Capacitive Discharge: The NFADs exhibit evidence of partial discharge of the detector capacitance during an avalanche, leading to much smaller charge flows (~3x10^5 carriers) than predicted by simple models, suggesting faster re-arming and reduced afterpulsing.
  • Bridging the Gap to Higher Repetition Rates: While traditional methods for higher repetition rates rely on very short, periodic gates, the NFAD approach offers a more flexible solution for free-running and longer-gate operation.

Key Results

  • Improved DCR vs. PDE: The designed SPADs achieve a better trade-off, with devices routinely exhibiting DCR of a few kHz for PDE ~ 20%. "Hero" devices demonstrate sub-kHz DCR performance at temperatures accessible by thermoelectric coolers.
  • Reduced Charge Flow: NFADs show charge flows per avalanche as low as ~3 x 10^5 carriers, significantly lower than the expected ~1 x 10^6 carriers for full capacitive discharge.
  • Evidence of Reduced Afterpulsing: The reduced charge flow in NFADs is expected to lead to reduced carrier trapping and thus lower afterpulsing, enabling higher repetition rates.
  • Experimental Validation of Modeling: The experimental data for DCR activation energy closely matched the simulation results, confirming the validity of their DCR mechanism models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Afterpulsing Still a Factor: While the NFAD approach shows promise for reducing afterpulsing, it's not entirely eliminated. The paper notes that afterpulsing remains a limitation for achieving the highest repetition rates, though the NFADs offer a significant improvement over conventional SPADs.
  • Further Optimization Needed: The authors suggest that further optimization of the negative feedback element and device design could lead to even smaller avalanches and faster re-arming.
  • Exploring Other Negative Feedback Schemes: The paper hints at the potential for other negative feedback implementations beyond simple resistors.
  • Commercialization and Broader Applications: The work lays the groundwork for more robust and higher-performance SPADs, opening doors for their use in a wider range of demanding photon-counting applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report on progress in improving fundamental properties of InP-based single photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) and recent trends for overcoming dominant performance limitations. Through experimental and modeling work focused on the trade-off between dark count rate (DCR) and photon detection efficiency (PDE), we identify the key mechanisms responsible for DCR over a range of operating temperatures and excess bias voltages. This work provides a detailed description of temperature- and bias-dependent DCR thermal activation energy E<sub>a</sub>(T,V), including the crossover from low E<sub>a</sub> for trap-assisted tunneling at temperatures below ~230 K to larger E<sub>a</sub> for thermal generation at temperatures approaching room temperature. By applying these findings to new device design and fabrication, the fundamental tradeoff between PDE and DCR for InP/InGaAs SPADs designed for 1.55 &mu;m photon detection has been managed so that for PDE ~ 20%, devices routinely exhibit DCR values of a few kHz, while "hero" devices demonstrate that it is possible to achieve sub-kHz DCR performance at temperatures readily accessible using thermoelectric coolers. However, important limitations remain, particularly with respect to maximum count rates. Strategies adopted recently to circumvent some of these present limitations include new circuit-based solutions involving high-speed very short-duration gating as well as new monolithic chip-level concepts for obtaining improved performance through avalanche self-quenching. We discuss these two approaches, and we describe recent results from devices with monolithically integrated quench resistors that achieve rapid self-quenching, accompanied by evidence for a partial discharge of the detector capacitance leading to charge flows as low as ~3 ×10<sup>5</sup> carriers associated with each avalanche event.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{itzler2010single,
  author = {Mark A. Itzler and Xudong Jiang and Mark Entwistle and Bora M. Onat and Krystyna Slomkowski},
  title = {{Single-photon detectors based on InP avalanche diodes: status and prospects}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1117/12.852705},
}
Figure