Single-Particle Emission Spectroscopy Resolves d-Hole Relaxation in Copper Nanocubes

Yiyu Cai, Sean S. E. Collins, M. J. Gallagher, Ujjal Bhattacharjee, Runmin Zhang, Tsz Him Chow, Arash Ahmadivand, Behnaz Ostovar, Alexander Al-Zubeidi, Jianfang Wang, Peter Nordlander, Christy F. Landes, Stephan LinkACS 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses single-particle spectroscopy to reveal how "d-holes" (excited electrons in copper's d-band) relax in copper nanocubes, a crucial step for designing better photocatalysts. They found that interband transitions, not the surface plasmon resonance, are key to copper nanocube emission, and that excitation energy significantly impacts d-hole behavior, more so than in gold.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Metal nanoparticles, especially copper nanocubes (CuNCs), are promising for renewable energy applications like photocatalysis due to their catalytic activity and ability to absorb light. When light hits these nanoparticles, it excites electrons, creating "hot carriers" that can drive chemical reactions. A key part of this process involves excited electrons in the d-band, known as "d-holes," and understanding how they relax (lose energy) is vital for optimizing photocatalytic efficiency. Previous studies often used ensemble measurements, which average out individual nanoparticle behavior and can obscure important details. Furthermore, the role of the localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) – the collective oscillation of electrons – in this relaxation process, especially in copper, was not fully clear, particularly when compared to other plasmonic materials like gold. This paper aims to resolve these dynamics at the single-particle level to better understand the fundamental photophysics of CuNCs for photocatalysis.

Methods

The researchers employed a suite of single-particle spectroscopy techniques:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Used to precisely measure the size of individual copper nanocubes.
  • Dark-field Scattering Spectroscopy: To probe the optical resonance (LSPR) of individual nanocubes.
  • Single-Particle Emission Spectroscopy: The core technique, used to measure the light emitted by individual nanocubes after excitation. This allows for the resolution of spectral features and quantum yields that are masked in ensemble measurements.
  • Time-Correlated Single-Photon Counting (TCSPC): Used to measure the emission lifetimes of single CuNCs, providing insights into the speed of relaxation processes.
  • Finite-Difference Time-Domain (FDTD) and COMSOL Simulations: Used to model the optical properties (scattering and absorption) of the nanocubes and understand the electromagnetic field distributions.

They also compared their copper nanocube results with gold nanocubes (AuNCs) of similar sizes and shapes to highlight differences arising from their distinct electronic band structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements from synthesized copper and gold nanocubes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interband Transitions Dominate Emission: Unlike gold nanorods where LSPR strongly influences emission, in copper nanocubes (60-160 nm), the emission primarily arises from interband transitions (electrons moving between the d-band and the sp-band), not the LSPR.
  • Plasmonic Enhancement is Subtle: While LSPR plays a role, its enhancement effect on emission in CuNCs is "hidden" in ensemble measurements and is less dominant than in other plasmonic systems like gold nanorods.
  • Size Matters for Emission: The size of the copper nanocube significantly impacts its emission line shape and quantum yield (QY), revealing a size-dependent plasmonic enhancement that is not apparent from bulk measurements. Smaller CuNCs show stronger plasmonic enhancement.
  • D-Hole Lifetime is Energy-Dependent: By analyzing the excitation wavelength-dependent QY, the researchers inferred that the lifetimes of d-holes are energy-dependent. Specifically, d-holes created by lower-energy excitations (longer wavelengths) tend to have longer lifetimes.
  • Copper vs. Gold: Band Structure Differences: The effect of excitation energy on QY is more pronounced in copper nanocubes than in gold nanocubes of equivalent size. This is attributed to differences in their band structures and how easily d-holes scatter with sp-band electrons, leading to faster decay in gold.

Key Results

  • Single-particle scattering spectra showed that the LSPR peak red-shifts and broadens with increasing CuNC size.
  • Emission spectra from CuNCs were found to be dominated by interband transitions, with no clear plasmonic feature at the LSPR resonance.
  • The quantum yield (QY) of emission from CuNCs was found to be higher for smaller nanocubes, indicating a stronger plasmonic enhancement in this regime.
  • Analysis of QY as a function of excitation wavelength revealed that d-hole lifetimes are energy-dependent, with longer lifetimes observed for d-holes created by lower-energy excitations.
  • The excitation wavelength dependence of d-hole lifetimes was significantly stronger in CuNCs (average D ratio of 7.9) compared to AuNCs (average D ratio of 2.5), highlighting the influence of metal band structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ligand/Oxide Layer: The authors note that the presence of ligands or a thin oxide layer on the CuNC surface might explain the lack of environmental dependence observed in their experiments. Further studies could explore the impact of surface passivation.
  • Complex Nanostructures: While this study focuses on single nanocubes, the authors suggest that emission spectroscopy can be extended to study hole transfer at interfaces in more complex nanostructures, which is crucial for designing advanced plasmonic catalytic systems.
  • Direct Correlation with Photocatalysis: While the study provides fundamental insights into d-hole dynamics relevant to photocatalysis, future work could directly correlate these findings with specific photocatalytic reaction efficiencies and selectivities.
  • Theoretical Modeling: While simulations were used, further detailed theoretical modeling could provide deeper quantitative understanding of the observed d-hole dynamics and their interplay with plasmonic fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Resolving the dynamics of photoexcited d-holes in metallic nanostructures is one step in the rational design of plasmonic photocatalysis. Here, we track the creation and relaxation of charge carriers in catalytically important plasmonic copper nanocubes using single-particle spectroscopy. We show that interband transitions dominate the absorption and emission of 60–160 nm copper nanocubes, and in contrast to gold nanorods, the LSPR is less important to the emission. We uncover the plasmonic enhancement of emission hidden in ensemble measurements by resolving the size-dependent line shape and quantum yield. Quantum yield analysis reveals the energy dependence of d-hole lifetimes. We demonstrate that the effect of excitation energy on quantum yield is stronger in copper nanocubes than in gold nanocubes of equivalent size due to differences in the band structure and the probabilities of hole scattering. Finally, we establish that emission spectroscopy is useful to understand the physical chemistry of d-holes in plasmonic photocatalysts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cai2019single,
  author = {Yiyu Cai and Sean S. E. Collins and M. J. Gallagher and Ujjal Bhattacharjee and Runmin Zhang and Tsz Him Chow and Arash Ahmadivand and Behnaz Ostovar and Alexander Al-Zubeidi and Jianfang Wang and Peter Nordlander and Christy F. Landes and Stephan Link},
  title = {{Single-Particle Emission Spectroscopy Resolves d-Hole Relaxation in Copper Nanocubes}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acsenergylett.9b01747},
}
Figure