Single-particle diffusional fingerprinting: A machine-learning framework for quantitative analysis of heterogeneous diffusion

Henrik Dahl Pinholt, Søren S.-r. Bohr, Josephine F. Iversen, Wouter Boomsma, Nikos S. HatzakisProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "diffusional fingerprinting," a novel machine-learning framework that analyzes single-particle tracking (SPT) data to quantitatively identify and classify diffusing particles based on their motion patterns, independent of the underlying biological system. This approach overcomes the limitations of existing methods by not requiring prior knowledge of diffusion types and provides mechanistic insights by ranking the most discriminative motion features.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-particle tracking (SPT) is a powerful technique for observing dynamic biological processes at high spatial and temporal resolutions. However, biological systems exhibit highly heterogeneous diffusion, meaning particle movement can vary drastically over time and across different systems. This complexity poses significant analytical challenges, often requiring researchers to have a priori knowledge of the specific diffusion model or system being studied. Existing classification methods frequently rely on training with simulated data, which may not transfer well to real-world experimental data. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a general, robust, and data-driven method for analyzing SPT data that can identify molecular identity and reveal mechanistic insights without prior assumptions about diffusion types.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is "diffusional fingerprinting." This involves extracting a set of 17 descriptive features from each observed particle trajectory. These features are designed to capture various aspects of diffusion, including:

  • Hidden Markov Model (HMM) features: Residence times in different states and average residence times, derived from fitting a four-state HMM with Gaussian emissions to the trajectories. This provides a representation learning platform for heterogeneous, state-shifting diffusion.
  • Anomalous diffusion features: Parameters from fitting a power law to the mean-squared displacement (MSD), such as the anomalous diffusion exponent.
  • Trajectory shape features: Kurtosis, dimension, efficiency, and trappedness to describe motion persistence and confinement.
  • Non-Brownian displacement features: Gaussianity to capture deviations from random motion.
  • General trajectory features: Average speed, track duration, and MSD value.

Once these 17 features are extracted for each trajectory, a diffusional fingerprint is generated. This fingerprint, essentially a distribution of these features, is then used to train a simple logistic regression model for classification. Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) is employed to rank the features, highlighting those that contribute most to distinguishing between different particle types or conditions, thereby providing mechanistic insights. A key innovation is that the method trains and predicts on experimental data directly, avoiding the need for pretraining on simulated data.

Datasets

The paper utilizes several datasets for training and evaluation:

  • Simulated Data:
    • Speed-switching trajectories with different diffusion rates.
  • Trajectories with varying degrees of confinement.
  • These simulated datasets were generated to test the method's ability to identify different diffusion behaviors and to benchmark against other classification approaches.
  • Experimental Data:
    • Tracked lipases on fat substrates (specifically, two variants of Thermomyces lanuginosus lipase, TLL).
  • Transcription factors diffusing in cells (data from Hansen et al., 2018).
  • Nanoparticles diffusing in mucus on a lipid membrane (data from Wan et al., 2020).

These diverse experimental datasets were chosen to demonstrate the universality and broad applicability of the diffusional fingerprinting approach across different biological entities and environments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Universality of Motion Descriptors: The 17 extracted features provide a common language to describe a wide range of diffusion behaviors, allowing for comparisons across vastly different biological systems.
  • Mechanistic Insights from Feature Ranking: The LDA-based feature ranking is crucial. It not only helps classify particles but also reveals why they are different by identifying the specific motion characteristics that are most discriminative. This moves beyond simple classification to understanding underlying mechanisms.
  • No A Priori Knowledge Needed: The method's ability to train and predict on experimental data without assuming diffusion types is a significant advantage over many existing techniques, making it more broadly applicable.
  • Robustness to Heterogeneity: The framework effectively handles complex, heterogeneous diffusion patterns, including state-shifting and anomalous diffusion, which are common in biological systems.
  • Simplicity and Effectiveness: A simple logistic regression classifier, when trained on the carefully selected features, achieves high accuracy, demonstrating the power of well-chosen features over complex models alone.

Key Results

  • Simulated Data: Achieved high F1 scores (e.g., 95.7 ± 0.4% for speed-switching, 91.1 ± 0.4% for confinement) with excellent classification accuracies (up to 98.4 ± 0.3%). The method also outperformed traditional feature-based classifiers and performed comparably to a state-of-the-art CNN on a stress test dataset, while additionally providing feature rankings.
  • Enzyme Identification: Differentiated between two functionally similar lipase variants (native TLL and L3) with an F1 score of 65.7 ± 0.4%, revealing that L3 uses different diffusional strategies (larger jumps) to achieve similar catalytic efficiency.
  • Transcription Factor Classification: Successfully classified transcription factor motion (Sox2 vs. NLS) with an F1 score of 72.7 ± 0.1%, identifying key features related to diffusion dynamics.
  • Nanoparticle Tracking: Differentiated between two types of nanoparticles (PLGA and TPGS) in mucus with an F1 score of 93 ± 1% and 91 ± 1% respectively, revealing how TPGS coating alters diffusion by lifting subdiffusive-like states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Feature Optimization: While the 17 features are powerful, the authors acknowledge that further improvements in classification accuracy might be possible with more advanced feature sets or by using more complex machine learning models like LSTMs or CNNs, though these may sacrifice mechanistic interpretability.
  • Data Imbalance: In cases of significant data imbalance (e.g., the TLL dataset), the F1 score can be lower than classification accuracy, which is a standard metric consideration.
  • Unsupervised Learning: The paper focuses on supervised learning. The authors suggest that the features could be extended to unlabeled data for unsupervised identification of distinct diffusion characteristics through clustering.
  • Library of Diffusional Traits: The vision is to build a comprehensive "dictionary" of diffusional traits that can be used for high-throughput screening, identifying ligand-mediated changes, or characterizing diffusion media.

Summary updated

Abstract

Single-particle tracking (SPT) is a key tool for quantitative analysis of dynamic biological processes and has provided unprecedented insights into a wide range of systems such as receptor localization, enzyme propulsion, bacteria motility, and drug nanocarrier delivery. The inherently complex diffusion in such biological systems can vary drastically both in time and across systems, consequently imposing considerable analytical challenges, and currently requires an a priori knowledge of the system. Here we introduce a method for SPT data analysis, processing, and classification, which we term "diffusional fingerprinting." This method allows for dissecting the features that underlie diffusional behavior and establishing molecular identity, regardless of the underlying diffusion type. The method operates by isolating 17 descriptive features for each observed motion trajectory and generating a diffusional map of all features for each type of particle. Precise classification of the diffusing particle identity is then obtained by training a simple logistic regression model. A linear discriminant analysis generates a feature ranking that outputs the main differences among diffusional features, providing key mechanistic insights. Fingerprinting operates by both training on and predicting experimental data, without the need for pretraining on simulated data. We found this approach to work across a wide range of simulated and experimentally diverse systems, such as tracked lipases on fat substrates, transcription factors diffusing in cells, and nanoparticles diffusing in mucus. This flexibility ultimately supports diffusional fingerprinting's utility as a universal paradigm for SPT diffusional analysis and prediction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pinholt2021single,
  author = {Henrik Dahl Pinholt and Søren S.-R. Bohr and Josephine F. Iversen and Wouter Boomsma and Nikos S. Hatzakis},
  title = {{Single-particle diffusional fingerprinting: A machine-learning framework for quantitative analysis of heterogeneous diffusion}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2104624118},
}

Loading related content...

Figure