Single nucleotide variation catalogue from clinical isolates mapped on tertiary and quaternary structures of ESX-1 related proteins reveals critical regions as putative Mtb therapeutic targets

Oren Tzfadia, Axel Siroy, Alexandra Vujkovic, Abril Gijsbers, Jihad Snobre, Roger Vargas, Wim Mulders, Conor J. Meehan, Maha Farhat, Peter J. Peters, Bouke C. de Jong, Raimond B. G. RavellibioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study maps genetic variations (SNVs) onto the 3D structures of ESX-1 proteins, crucial for Mycobacterium tuberculosis virulence. They identified highly conserved regions on protein surfaces and within intrinsically disordered regions, suggesting these are key targets for new anti-TB drugs and vaccines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) is a major global health threat, causing tuberculosis (TB). While the ESX-1 secretion system is known to be essential for MTB's virulence across all its lineages, specific targets for therapeutic intervention have been elusive. The challenge lies in identifying which parts of these complex protein systems are critical for virulence and thus represent promising targets for drugs or vaccines. Previous research has focused on specific lineages or proteins, but a comprehensive, structure-based analysis across the entire ESX-1 system and all major MTB lineages was lacking.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS) and SNP Cataloging: They analyzed WGS data from over 32,000 clinical MTB isolates, identifying single nucleotide variations (SNVs). This created a comprehensive catalog of genetic changes across different MTB lineages.
  • 3D Structure Mapping: They mapped these identified SNVs onto the known and AlphaFold-predicted 3D structures of the 34 ESX-1 related proteins. This allowed them to visualize where genetic variations occur in relation to the protein's physical form.
  • Identification of Conserved Regions: By mapping SNVs, they could pinpoint regions of the proteins that are highly conserved, meaning they have very few genetic variations. This was done for both surface-exposed areas and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs).
  • Analysis of Hotspots and Convergent Evolution: They identified "hotspots" – mutations found in a significant percentage of isolates, suggesting clonal expansion. They also investigated instances of convergent evolution, where similar mutations arise independently in different lineages.
  • Quaternary Structure Analysis: They examined how SNVs affect protein-protein interaction interfaces within the ESX-1 complex, using tools like PISA.

Datasets

  • Clinical MTB Isolates: A large dataset of over 32,000 whole-genome sequences from clinical Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBc) isolates, spanning multiple lineages (L1-L8), as well as M. bovis. This dataset was curated from publicly available sources and unpublished data.
  • AlphaFold-Predicted Protein Structures: 3D structural models for the 34 ESX-1 related proteins were obtained from the EBI/AlphaFold database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface Conservation is Key: Highly conserved regions on the surface of ESX-1 proteins are prime candidates for therapeutic targets. These areas are accessible to drugs and immune responses.
  • Intrinsically Disordered Regions (IDRs) Matter: Surprisingly, intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) within ESX-1 proteins, which lack a defined 3D structure, also show remarkable conservation. This suggests they play critical, yet perhaps less understood, roles in virulence and host interaction.
  • Hotspots Reveal Evolutionary Pressures: "Hotspot" mutations, found in a high percentage of isolates, often occur in surface regions where no known interactions have been reported. This hints at areas that can tolerate variation without losing function, or perhaps are involved in yet-undiscovered interactions.
  • ESX-1 is a Highly Variable but Critically Conserved System: While the ESX-1 GOI (genes of interest) is the most SNV-dense group of genes in the MTB genome, indicating high genetic plasticity, specific functional regions within these proteins remain remarkably conserved, highlighting their essential role.

Key Results

  • 34 ESX-1 Genes Analyzed: The study focused on 34 genes encoding ESX-1 related proteins, totaling over 11,000 amino acids.
  • Extensive SNV Catalog: A total of 8616 SNVs were identified, with 2742 synonymous and 5874 non-synonymous. Nearly 40% of the encoded amino acids had at least one non-synonymous SNP.
  • 21 Hotspots Identified: 21 "hotspots" (mutations in >1% of isolates) were identified across 14 of the 34 ESX-1 GOIs, indicating clonal expansion events.
  • Conserved Regions Mapped: The analysis revealed varying sizes of conserved regions on protein surfaces, with some showing clear polarity of SNP distribution.
  • Functional Regions Largely Conserved: Despite the overall mutation load, functional regions within the ESX-1 GOI set were found to be largely conserved, particularly in motifs and binding regions.
  • IDRs Show High Conservation: Thirteen of the 34 ESX-1 GOI proteins contained IDRs, and these regions showed a strikingly low percentage of mutations, suggesting their crucial role in virulence.
  • Interaction Sites Highly Conserved: Notably, interaction sites between proteins and with DNA showed a high degree of conservation, underscoring their functional importance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation Needed: While the study provides a strong structural and genetic basis for identifying therapeutic targets, experimental validation of the identified conserved regions and their roles in virulence is the crucial next step.
  • Functional Consequences of Mutations: The precise functional consequences of many identified mutations, especially those in "hotspot" regions, require further investigation.
  • IDR Functionality: The exact roles of the conserved intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) in MTB pathogenesis and host interaction are still not fully understood and warrant deeper study.
  • Broader Pathogen Application: The authors suggest that this structure-based SNV analysis approach could be extended to other pathogens, offering a novel resource for developing control strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Proteins encoded by the ESX-1 genes of interests are essential for full virulence in all Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBc) lineages, the pathogens with the highest mortality worldwide. Identifying critical regions in these ESX-1 related proteins could provide preventive or therapeutic targets for MTB infection, the game changer needed for tuberculosis control. We analysed a compendium of whole genome sequences of clinical MTB isolates from all lineages from >32,000 patients and identified single nucleotide variations (SNV). When mutations corresponding to all nonsynonymous SNPs were mapped on the surface of known and AlphaFold-predicted ternary protein structures, fully conserved regions emerged. Some could be assigned to known quaternary structures, whereas others could be predicted to be involved in yet-to-be-discovered interactions. Some mutants had clonally expanded (found in >1% of the isolates): these were mostly located at the surface of globular domains, remote from known intra- and inter-molecular protein–protein interactions. Fully conserved intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) of proteins were found, suggesting that these are crucial for the pathogenicity of the MTBc. Altogether, our findings provide an evolutionary structural perspective on MTB virulence and highlight fully conserved regions of proteins as attractive vaccine antigens and drug targets. Extending this approach to other pathogens can provide a novel critical resource for the development of innovative tools for pathogen control.
BibTeX
@misc{tzfadia2023single,
  author = {Oren Tzfadia and Axel Siroy and Alexandra Vujkovic and Abril Gijsbers and Jihad Snobre and Roger Vargas and Wim Mulders and Conor J. Meehan and Maha Farhat and Peter J. Peters and Bouke C. de Jong and Raimond B. G. Ravelli},
  title = {{Single nucleotide variation catalogue from clinical isolates mapped on tertiary and quaternary structures of ESX-1 related proteins reveals critical regions as putative Mtb therapeutic targets}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.06.22.507254},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure