Single-leg stance on a challenging surface can enhance cortical activation in the right hemisphere – A case study

Haroon Khan, Nauman Khalid Qureshi, Anis Yazidi, Håvard Engell, Peyman MirtaheriHeliyon 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses fNIRS to investigate how a professional alpine skier's brain activity changes during single-leg stances on a challenging surface. The findings suggest that a more difficult stance (left-leg stance) leads to increased activation in the right hemisphere's motor cortex, highlighting the brain's effort to maintain balance under challenging conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining balance, especially during dynamic or unstable situations, is crucial for everyday activities and athletic performance. While the importance of sensory and muscular coordination for balance is well-established, the role of complex cortical control, particularly during challenging stances like a single-leg stance (SLS), remains less understood. Previous research has explored plantar pressure and general cortical activation during SLS, but there's a need for more detailed investigation into how specific challenging surfaces and stances influence hemispheric brain activity. This paper aims to shed light on the contralateral cortical activation patterns during SLS on an unstable surface, specifically in a highly skilled athlete.

Methods

The researchers employed continuous-wave functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) to measure hemodynamic responses in the motor cortex of a professional alpine skier. The experimental setup involved three tasks: a barefooted walk (BFW), a right-leg stance (RLS), and a left-leg stance (LLS) performed on a challenging "Kybun mat" designed to induce instability.

The fNIRS data processing involved several steps:

  • Channel Rejection: Channels with high variability (coefficient of variation > 10%) were removed.
  • Optical Density Conversion: Raw intensity data was converted to optical densities.
  • Hemoglobin Concentration Changes: Modified Beer-Lambert Law (MBLL) was used to calculate changes in oxygenated (ΔHbO) and deoxygenated (ΔHbR) hemoglobin.
  • Signal Correction: Temporal Derivative Distribution Repair (TDDR) was applied for motion artifact removal, followed by baseline zero-adjustments and z-normalization.
  • Statistical Analysis: A General Linear Model (GLM) with a 2-gamma hemodynamic response function (HRF) was used to estimate brain activation. Only channels with a p-value < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used data collected from a single participant during the experimental tasks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Right Hemisphere Dominance in Challenging Stances: The study found that during the more challenging left-leg stance (LLS), the right hemisphere showed significantly higher activation in motor-related areas (premotor cortex, supplementary motor area, primary motor cortex) compared to the left hemisphere. This suggests a greater demand on the right hemisphere for maintaining balance under instability.
  • LLS is More Demanding than RLS: The left-leg stance (LLS) consistently elicited higher brain activation across all brain regions compared to the right-leg stance (RLS). This indicates that for this right-leg dominant individual, balancing on the left leg on an unstable surface is a more cognitively demanding task.
  • Kybun Mat's Impact: The use of the Kybun mat, which introduces constant micro-movements to maintain balance, significantly increased the challenge of the SLS, leading to heightened cortical activity.
  • Broca's Area Activation: Broca's temporal lobe was activated during both LLS and RLS, suggesting its involvement in motor control and potentially language processing related to task instructions or internal monitoring.
  • BFW as a Baseline: The barefooted walk (BFW) showed the lowest brain activation, serving as a good baseline for comparison, highlighting the increased neural effort required for even simple stances on an unstable surface.

Key Results

  • Increased ΔHbO during SLS: All tested conditions (BFW, RLS, LLS) showed an increase in ΔHbO during the task periods compared to baseline.
  • Right Hemisphere Activation: The right hemisphere consistently showed more activated regions-of-interest (ROIs) than the left hemisphere across all conditions.
  • LLS vs. RLS: LLS was associated with more contralateral brain activation than RLS.
  • Specific Region Activation in LLS: Higher ΔHbO demands were observed in the dorsolateral prefrontal, pre-motor, supplementary motor cortex, and primary motor cortex of the right hemisphere during LLS.
  • Participant's Struggle: The participant reported struggling with balance during LLS, which correlated with higher ΔHbO in both hemispheres, indicating a greater need for motor control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Case Study: The study is a case study of a single professional alpine skier. The findings may not be generalizable to the broader population or even other athletes without further investigation.
  • Right-Leg Dominance: The participant is right-leg dominant, which influences the observed hemispheric differences. Future studies should explore individuals with different leg dominance and skill levels.
  • Future Investigations: The authors suggest future research focusing on:
  • Larger populations, particularly athletes, to confirm these findings.
  • Investigating the impact of specific physiotherapy sessions designed to enhance balance control on both sides and potentially reduce cortical activation.
  • Planning further investigations after the participant completes physiotherapy to assess its effects on balance and brain activation.
  • Exploring the relationship between brain activation and specific physiotherapy exercises for more efficient rehabilitation and sports training.

Summary updated

Abstract

Maintaining body balance, whether static or dynamic, is critical in performing everyday activities and developing and optimizing basic motor skills. This study investigates how a professional alpine skier's brain activates on the contralateral side during a single-leg stance. Continuous-wave functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) signals were recorded with sixteen sources and detectors over the motor cortex to investigate brain hemodynamics. Three different tasks were performed: barefooted walk (BFW), right-leg stance (RLS), and left-leg stance (LLS). The signal processing pipeline includes channel rejection, the conversation of raw intensities into hemoglobin concentration changes using modified Beer-Lambert law, baseline zero-adjustments, z-normalization, and temporal filtration. The hemodynamic brain signal was estimated using a general linear model with a 2-gamma function. Measured activations (<i>t</i>-values) with <i>p</i>-value <0.05 were only considered as statistically significant active channels. Compared to all other conditions, BFW has the lowest brain activation. LLS is associated with more contralateral brain activation than RLS. During LLS, higher brain activation was observed across all brain regions. The right hemisphere has comparatively more activated regions-of-interest. Higher ΔHbO demands in the dorsolateral prefrontal, pre-motor, supplementary motor cortex, and primary motor cortex were observed in the right hemisphere relative to the left which explains higher energy demands for balancing during LLS. Broca's temporal lobe was also activated during both LLS and RLS. Comparing the results with BFW- which is considered the most realistic walking condition-, it is concluded that higher demands of ΔHbO predict higher motor control demands for balancing. The participant struggled with balance during the LLS, showing higher ΔHbO in both hemispheres compared to two other conditions, which indicates the higher requirement for motor control to maintain balance. A post-physiotherapy exercise program is expected to improve balance during LLS, leading to fewer changes to ΔHbO.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khan2023single,
  author = {Haroon Khan and Nauman Khalid Qureshi and Anis Yazidi and Håvard Engell and Peyman Mirtaheri},
  title = {{Single-leg stance on a challenging surface can enhance cortical activation in the right hemisphere – A case study}},
  booktitle = {Heliyon},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e13628},
}
Figure