Single Cell Spatial Chromatin Analysis of Fixed Immunocytochemically Identified Neuronal Cells

Jaehee Lee, Youtao Lu, Jinchun Wang, Jifen Li, Stephen Fisher, C. Erik Nordgren, Jean G. Rosario, Stewart A. Anderson, Alexandra V. Ulyanova, Steven Brem, H. Isaac Chen, John A. Wolf, M. Sean Grady, Mimi Healy, Junhyong Kim, James EberwinebioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CHEX-seq, a novel method for analyzing open chromatin in individual, fixed cells while preserving their spatial context. This breakthrough allows for "spatial chromatin analysis," revealing the open-chromatin landscape within complex cellular environments, including within intact tissue sections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional methods for studying open chromatin, like ATAC-seq or DNase-seq, require isolating cell nuclei. This process destroys crucial information about the cell's spatial location and its surrounding microenvironment. For complex tissues like the brain, understanding how chromatin structure varies in situ and how it relates to specific cell types and their local context has been a major challenge. This loss of spatial information limits our ability to fully grasp the functional implications of chromatin organization in its native setting.

Methods

The core innovation is CHEX-seq (CHromatin eXposed). Here's how it works:

  1. Light-Activated Probes: The method uses specially designed DNA probes that can anneal to single-stranded DNA regions within open chromatin. These probes are inactive until activated by a laser.
  2. In Situ Laser Activation: A targeted laser pulse activates the probe only in selected cells or regions of interest. This activation releases a 3'-hydroxyl group.
  3. Enzymatic Copying: The activated probe then acts as a primer for in situ enzymatic copying of the single-stranded DNA. This process effectively "tags" the open chromatin regions within the living cell.
  4. Sequencing: The copied DNA is then processed, amplified, and sequenced to map the open chromatin landscape.

This approach allows for the analysis of chromatin in fixed cells, preserving their morphology and spatial relationships, and even within intact tissue sections.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets for benchmarking and validation:

  • Human K562 cells: Used extensively for benchmarking the CHEX-seq procedure.
  • Primary mouse and human brain cells: Both dispersed and in situ (tissue section) preparations were used to demonstrate the method's utility across different cell types and contexts.
  • Immunostained cells in mouse brain sections: Allowed for the co-analysis of chromatin and specific cell markers.
  • Publicly available transcriptome datasets: Used to compare CHEX-seq identified open chromatin regions with gene expression levels.
  • Other open-chromatin assay data: ATAC-seq, DNase-seq, and FAIRE-seq data were used for comparative analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Context is Crucial: The ability to perform chromatin analysis in situ is a game-changer for understanding cell function in complex tissues.
  • Single-Stranded DNA as a Marker: CHEX-seq specifically targets single-stranded DNA regions, which are characteristic of actively transcribed or highly dynamic chromatin, offering a unique perspective compared to methods that target double-stranded DNA.
  • Mitochondrial DNA Openness: The method can also probe the openness of mitochondrial DNA, opening new avenues for studying mitochondrial function and regulation.
  • Cell Type Specificity: CHEX-seq revealed distinct open-chromatin landscapes across different cell types (neurons vs. astrocytes) and even within subtypes of neurons, highlighting the power of this method for cell-type characterization.
  • Promoter Regions are Dynamic: The study observed a strong enrichment of CHEX-seq signals near Transcription Start Sites (TSS), consistent with active gene regulation. Interestingly, promoter regions showed a bias towards sense-strand CHEX-seq reads, potentially reflecting the binding of transcription machinery.

Key Results

  • Successful Benchmarking: CHEX-seq was successfully benchmarked in human K562 cells, showing high proportions of reads mapping to intergenic regions and introns, with promoter enrichment.
  • Correlation with Transcription: A strong correlation was found between the proximity of CHEX-seq priming sites to TSS and mRNA expression levels, suggesting that CHEX-seq sites are indicative of transcriptional activity.
  • Tissue Section Analysis: CHEX-seq successfully identified open-chromatin sites in neurons within fixed mouse brain tissue sections, demonstrating its applicability in complex tissue contexts.
  • Cell Type Differences: Heatmaps of CHEX-seq read density across chromosomes revealed distinct patterns for mouse astrocytes and neurons, highlighting the method's ability to differentiate cell types based on their open-chromatin landscape.
  • Overlap with Transcriptome: Approximately 64% of expressed genes in K562 cells had corresponding CHEX-seq sites, indicating a significant overlap between open chromatin and active transcription.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resolution: While CHEX-seq offers spatial information, the resolution is limited by the diffraction limit of the activating light.
  • Multiplexing Potential: The authors suggest that synthesizing CHEX-seq probes with different barcodes could enable multiplexing for high-throughput analysis of tens of thousands of cells from a single tissue section.
  • Combined Assays: Future work could combine CHEX-seq with genomic DNA chromatin analysis and transcriptome profiling within the same cell.
  • Archival Samples: The ability of CHEX-seq to work with chemically fixed tissue opens the possibility of analyzing open-chromatin landscapes in archival human samples, providing insights into ancient cells.
  • Non-Transcribed Regions: The study identified a significant amount of single-stranded open-chromatin in fixed tissue sections that did not correspond to transcribed mRNA, suggesting potential roles in DNA repair, replication, or other organizational structures, which warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Assays examining the open-chromatin landscape in single cells require isolation of the nucleus, resulting in the loss of spatial/microenvironment information. Here we describe CHEX-seq ( CH romatin EX posed) for identifying single-stranded open-chromatin DNA regions in paraformaldehyde-fixed single cells. CHEX-seq uses light-activated DNA probes that binds to single-stranded DNA in open chromatin. In situ laser activation of the annealed probes’ 3’-Lightning Terminator™ in selected cells permits the probe to act as a primer for in situ enzymatic copying of single-stranded DNA that is then sequenced. CHEX-seq is benchmarked with human K562 cells and its utility is demonstrated in dispersed primary mouse and human brain cells, and immunostained cells in mouse brain sections. Further, CHEX-seq queries the openness of mitochondrial DNA in single cells. Evaluation of an individual cell’s chromatin landscape in its tissue context enables “spatial chromatin analysis”. One Sentence Summary A new method, CHEX-seq ( CH romatin eX posed), identifies the open-chromatin landscape in single fixed cells thereby allowing spatial chromatin analysis of selected cells in complex cellular environments.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2019single,
  author = {Jaehee Lee and Youtao Lu and Jinchun Wang and Jifen Li and Stephen Fisher and C. Erik Nordgren and Jean G. Rosario and Stewart A. Anderson and Alexandra V. Ulyanova and Steven Brem and H. Isaac Chen and John A. Wolf and M. Sean Grady and Mimi Healy and Junhyong Kim and James Eberwine},
  title = {{Single Cell Spatial Chromatin Analysis of Fixed Immunocytochemically Identified Neuronal Cells}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/780387},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure