Single cell resolution regulatory landscape of the mouse kidney highlights cellular differentiation programs and renal disease targets

Zhen Miao, Michael S. Balzer, Ziyuan Ma, Hongbo Liu, Junnan Wu, Rojesh Shrestha, Tamás Arányi, Amy Kwan, Ayano Kondo, Marco Pontoglio, Junhyong Kim, Mingyao Li, Klaus H. Kaestner, Katalin SusztákbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first single-cell resolution map of open chromatin in the developing and adult mouse kidney, revealing the regulatory networks that drive cell differentiation and identifying key transcription factors involved. This comprehensive atlas helps pinpoint cell types and regulatory mechanisms implicated in kidney diseases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the kidney develops and maintains its complex cellular structure is crucial for addressing kidney diseases. While single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has provided insights into gene expression, it offers limited information about gene regulation, especially for lowly expressed transcription factors (TFs). Similarly, bulk epigenomic analyses can obscure cell-type-specific changes due to variations in cell composition. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a high-resolution view of chromatin accessibility (an indicator of gene regulatory potential) across different kidney cell types and developmental stages, thereby illuminating the regulatory logic governing kidney development and disease.

Methods

The researchers employed single-nucleus ATAC-seq (snATAC-seq) to profile open chromatin regions at single-cell resolution in developing (postnatal day 0) and adult mouse kidneys. This was complemented by single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) to capture gene expression profiles. For data analysis, they utilized:

  • snapATAC for clustering and dimension reduction of snATAC-seq data.
  • Harmony for batch effect correction.
  • MACS2 for peak calling.
  • HOMER and SCENIC for motif enrichment analysis and gene regulatory network inference.
  • Cicero for analyzing peak co-accessibility and predicting cis-regulatory elements.
  • Monocle3 and VelocytoR for inferring developmental trajectories and RNA velocity.
  • CellPhoneDB for analyzing cell-cell communication.

Datasets

The study utilized datasets from:

  • Developing and adult mouse kidneys: snATAC-seq and scRNA-seq data were generated from these samples.
  • Publicly available datasets: This includes ENCODE Encyclopedia data for chromatin ChIP-seq and RNA-seq, and WGBS data.
  • Human kidney disease GWAS data: Three recent kidney disease GWAS datasets were combined to identify potential target genes and cell types.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chromatin accessibility is a powerful tool for cell type identification: snATAC-seq data provided more distinct cell type annotations, even in the developing kidney, compared to scRNA-seq, particularly for lowly expressed genes.
  • Distal regulatory elements (enhancers) are critical for cell-type-specific gene expression: The study highlights the importance of enhancers in establishing unique gene expression patterns in different kidney cell types.
  • Kidney development involves dynamic regulatory changes: The researchers observed significant changes in chromatin accessibility and TF activity throughout nephron progenitor differentiation, revealing key regulatory events.
  • Cell-cell communication, especially stromal-epithelial interactions, is vital for kidney development: The study identified critical communication pathways involving stromal cells that drive kidney development.
  • Single-cell epigenomics can pinpoint kidney disease-associated genes and cell types: By integrating GWAS data with single-cell chromatin accessibility maps, the study identified specific cell types and regulatory regions implicated in kidney diseases.

Key Results

  • The study generated a comprehensive atlas of 28,316 snATAC-seq cells and 43,636 scRNA-seq cells.
  • They identified 13 distinct cell clusters from the snATAC-seq data and 17 from scRNA-seq data, which largely corresponded to known kidney cell types.
  • 60,684 differentially accessible open chromatin peaks (DAPs) were identified across the 13 cell types.
  • The analysis revealed cell type-specific TF landscapes, identifying key TFs like Six2 and Hoxc9 in nephron progenitors, Wt1 and Mafb in podocytes, and Hnf4a in proximal tubules.
  • The study mapped developmental trajectories for podocytes, proximal tubules, and loop of Henle, showing distinct chromatin dynamics and gene expression changes.
  • Analysis of human kidney disease GWAS loci identified specific cell types and regulatory regions associated with diseases like those involving Shroom3, Dab2, and Uncx.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental validation: The authors acknowledge that further experimental validation is needed for many of their findings, which is beyond the scope of the current manuscript.
  • Computational analysis limitations: They note that computational tools like HOMER, SCENIC, and ChromVAR may not always distinguish between TFs with similar binding sites.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that future high-throughput studies analyzing open chromatin and gene expression from the same cells will be crucial for correlating these data along differentiation trajectories. Integrating this data with human kidney tissue samples is also highlighted as essential for understanding molecular pathways altered by genetic variants.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Determining the epigenetic program that generates unique cell types in the kidney is critical for understanding cell-type heterogeneity during tissue homeostasis and injury response. Here, we profiled open chromatin and gene expression in developing and adult mouse kidneys at single cell resolution. We show critical reliance of gene expression on distal regulatory elements (enhancers). We define key cell type-specific transcription factors and major gene-regulatory circuits for kidney cells. Dynamic chromatin and expression changes during nephron progenitor differentiation demonstrated that podocyte commitment occurs early and is associated with sustained Foxl1 expression. Renal tubule cells followed a more complex differentiation, where Hfn4a was associated with proximal and Tfap2b with distal fate. Mapping single nucleotide variants associated with human kidney disease identified critical cell types, developmental stages, genes, and regulatory mechanisms. We provide a global single cell resolution view of chromatin accessibility of kidney development. The dataset is available via interactive public websites.
BibTeX
@misc{miao2020single,
  author = {Zhen Miao and Michael S. Balzer and Ziyuan Ma and Hongbo Liu and Junnan Wu and Rojesh Shrestha and Tamás Arányi and Amy Kwan and Ayano Kondo and Marco Pontoglio and Junhyong Kim and Mingyao Li and Klaus H. Kaestner and Katalin Suszták},
  title = {{Single cell resolution regulatory landscape of the mouse kidney highlights cellular differentiation programs and renal disease targets}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.05.24.113910},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure