Single-cell multiome uncovers differences in glycogen metabolism underlying species-specific speed of development

Alexandra de la Porte, Julia Schröder, Moritz Thomas, Johanna Geuder, Michael Sterr, Xavier Pastor Hostench, Leslie E. Sanderson, Tahsin Stefan Barakat, Wolfgang Enard, Carsten Marr, Christian Schröter, Micha DrukkerbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Embryos from different mammalian species develop at characteristic timescales. These timescales are recapitulated during the differentiation of pluripotent stem cells in vitro. Specific genes and molecular pathways that modulate cell differentiation speed between mammalian species remain to be determined. Here we use single-cell multi-omic analysis of neural differentiation of mouse, cynomolgus and human pluripotent cells to identify regulators for differentiation speed. We demonstrate that species-specific transcriptome dynamics are mirrored at the chromatin level, but that the speed of neural differentiation is insensitive to manipulations of cell growth and cycling. Exploiting the single-cell resolution of our data, we identify glycogen storage levels regulated by UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase 2 (UGP2) as a species-dependent trait of pluripotent cells, and show that lowered glycogen storage in UGP2 mutant cells is associated with accelerated neural differentiation. The control of energy storage could be a general strategy for the regulation of cell differentiation speed.

Introduction

One of the most striking mysteries in biology is the variation in developmental "tempo." A mouse embryo progresses from fertilization to gastrulation in about six days, whereas a human embryo takes nearly two weeks. Remarkably, this speed difference is cell-intrinsic—it persists even when cells are grown in vitro, isolated from the maternal environment. While it has long been known that human cells develop more slowly than mouse cells, the molecular mechanisms governing this biological clock have remained elusive. Previous hypotheses suggested cell division rates or protein stability as drivers, but these factors do not fully account for the observed differences. This study aims to identify the specific genetic and metabolic pathways that set the pace of mammalian development.

Experimental Design and Multi-omic Profiling

To investigate the molecular basis of developmental speed, researchers employed a harmonized approach to compare mouse (Mus musculus), cynomolgus monkey (Macaca fascicularis), and human (Homo sapiens) pluripotent stem cells (PSCs). By adapting all three species to the same growth medium, environmental influences were minimized, allowing for a direct comparison of intrinsic developmental rates.

Experimental design and multi-omic characterization of cross-species neural differentiation across mouse, monkey, and human cells.

The study utilized single-cell multiome sequencing to simultaneously measure gene expression (RNA) and chromatin accessibility (ATAC) in over 74,000 single cells across eight time points (0 hours to 10 days) during neural differentiation. This high-resolution dataset allowed the team to mathematically project primate data onto a mouse reference trajectory, revealing that mouse cells differentiate approximately 2.2 to 2.4 times faster than their primate counterparts.

Key Insights

Chromatin and RNA Dynamics are Synchronized

The multi-omic analysis revealed that species-specific developmental speed is not merely a product of transcription rates. Instead, the physical structure of DNA—the epigenetic landscape—opens and closes at the same species-specific tempo as the transcriptome. As shown in the ATAC-seq tracks for markers like OCT4 and PAX6, the timing of chromatin accessibility changes mirrors the shifts in gene expression across the three species.

Decoupling of Cell Cycle and Differentiation Speed

A common hypothesis suggests that slower human development is a consequence of slower cell division. However, perturbation experiments using the mTOR inhibitor INK128 to slow cell growth demonstrated that differentiation speed is independent of the cell cycle. Even when growth was artificially retarded, cells maintained their species-specific developmental tempo, suggesting that growth and differentiation are uncoupled processes.

Glycogen as a Metabolic Brake

The most significant finding was the identification of a metabolic divergence: human and monkey cells store substantially more glycogen than mouse cells—approximately 13.5 times more in humans. The enzyme UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase 2 (UGP2) was identified as the key regulator of this storage.

Functional validation using CRISPR/Cas9 to knock out UGP2 in human cells—thereby preventing glycogen accumulation—resulted in a significant acceleration of neural differentiation. In these mutant cells, neural markers such as FOXG1 appeared days earlier than in wild-type human cells, suggesting that high glycogen storage acts as a "metabolic buffer" or brake on developmental speed.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research identifies UGP2-mediated glycogen storage as a critical regulator of the developmental clock in primates. While the study establishes a clear link between energy storage and differentiation speed, the precise downstream mechanisms—whether involving energy sensing pathways like AMPK or alterations in carbon partitioning—remain to be fully elucidated. Furthermore, while this study focused on neural lineages, future work will determine if this metabolic brake is a universal regulator of developmental tempo across different tissues and species.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Embryos from different mammalian species develop at characteristic timescales. These timescales are recapitulated during the differentiation of pluripotent stem cells in vitro . Specific genes and molecular pathways that modulate cell differentiation speed between mammalian species remain to be determined. Here we use single-cell multi-omic analysis of neural differentiation of mouse, cynomolgus and human pluripotent cells to identify regulators for differentiation speed. We demonstrate that species-specific transcriptome dynamics are mirrored at the chromatin level, but that the speed of neural differentiation is insensitive to manipulations of cell growth and cycling. Exploiting the single-cell resolution of our data, we identify glycogen storage levels regulated by UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase 2 (UGP2) as a species-dependent trait of pluripotent cells, and show that lowered glycogen storage in UGP2 mutant cells is associated with accelerated neural differentiation. The control of energy storage could be a general strategy for the regulation of cell differentiation speed.
BibTeX
@misc{porte2024single,
  author = {Alexandra de la Porte and Julia Schröder and Moritz Thomas and Johanna Geuder and Michael Sterr and Xavier Pastor Hostench and Leslie E. Sanderson and Tahsin Stefan Barakat and Wolfgang Enard and Carsten Marr and Christian Schröter and Micha Drukker},
  title = {{Single-cell multiome uncovers differences in glycogen metabolism underlying species-specific speed of development}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.09.03.610938},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure