Single-Cell Atlas of Common Variable Immunodeficiency reveals germinal center-associated epigenetic dysregulation in B cell responses

Javier Rodríguez‐Ubreva, Anna Arutyunyan, Marc Jan Bonder, Lucía del Pino Molina, Stephen J. Clark, Carlos de la Calle‐Fabregat, Luz García‐Alonso, Louis‐François Handfield, Laura Ciudad, Eduardo Andrés‐León, Felix Krueger, Francesc Català‐Moll, Virginia Rodríguez-Cortez, Krzysztof Polański, Lira Mamanova, Stijn van Dongen, Vladimir Yu Kiselev, María T. Martínez-Saavedra, Holger Heyn, Javier Martı́n, Klaus Warnatz, Eduardo López‐Granados, Carlos Rodríguez‐Gallego, Oliver Stegle, Gavin Kelsey, Roser Vento‐Tormo, Esteban BallestarbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses single-cell multi-omics to reveal widespread epigenetic dysregulation in memory B cells of individuals with Common Variable Immunodeficiency (CVID), specifically linked to germinal center responses. These epigenetic changes appear to drive defective B cell activation and communication, offering new avenues for understanding and potentially treating this complex immune disorder.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Common Variable Immunodeficiency (CVID) is a primary immunodeficiency characterized by impaired B cell differentiation and antibody production. Despite known genetic factors, a significant portion of CVID cases exhibit incomplete genetic penetrance and diverse clinical presentations, suggesting that non-genetic factors, like epigenetics, play a crucial role. Understanding these epigenetic contributions is key to unraveling CVID pathogenesis and developing better diagnostics and therapies. The authors leverage monozygotic (MZ) twins discordant for CVID, a powerful model for dissecting epigenetic influences, to investigate these mechanisms.

Methods

The study employs a suite of cutting-edge single-cell technologies to create a comprehensive atlas of B cell differentiation in CVID. Key methods include:

  • Single-cell whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (scBS-seq): To map DNA methylation patterns at single-cell resolution.
  • Single-cell ATAC-seq (scATAC-seq): To assess chromatin accessibility, revealing regulatory element activity.
  • Single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq): Using both plate-based Smart-seq2 and droplet-based 10x Genomics methods to capture gene expression profiles.
  • CellPhoneDB: A database and computational framework to infer cell-cell communication networks based on ligand-receptor interactions.
  • Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS): Applied to the MZ twins to identify potential genetic underpinnings of their discordance.
  • Amplicon sequencing: Used for targeted validation of DNA methylation alterations in a larger cohort.

These techniques were integrated to provide a multi-omics view of B cell function and interaction.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • A pair of monozygotic (MZ) twins discordant for CVID.
  • An additional cohort of 10 CVID patients and 10 healthy donors.
  • Publicly available datasets for various B cell populations (naïve, GC, S-mem B cells, and PCs) from the Blueprint Consortium for comparative analysis.
  • Publicly available ChIP-seq datasets for transcription factor binding and histone modifications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Epigenetic "episignature" for CVID: The study identifies distinct DNA methylation patterns in memory B cells of CVID patients, suggesting a potential diagnostic "episignature" for the disease.
  • Germinal Center (GC) focus: The observed epigenetic dysregulation is primarily localized to memory B cells and appears to be associated with defects in germinal center responses, a critical process for antibody maturation.
  • Beyond B cells: The research highlights that CVID is not solely a B cell-intrinsic defect, as alterations in cell-cell communication involving other immune cells (T cells, NK cells) also contribute to impaired B cell responses.
  • Timing matters: Naïve B cells in the CVID twin showed minimal epigenetic differences compared to the healthy twin, suggesting that these defects are established later during B cell activation and memory formation in secondary lymphoid organs.

Key Results

  • Widespread DNA methylation and chromatin accessibility defects: Prevalent and heterogeneous alterations were found in memory B cells of CVID patients, impacting specific genomic regions.
  • Impaired DNA demethylation: Switched memory (S-mem) B cells in the CVID twin showed significantly impaired DNA demethylation, particularly in non-PMDs, suggesting issues with active demethylation mechanisms.
  • Transcriptional perturbations upon activation: While steady-state B cells showed similar transcriptional profiles between twins, activated B cells, especially memory B cells, displayed a substantial number of dysregulated genes (over 5,000 in activated memory B cells).
  • Cell-cell communication defects: CellPhoneDB analysis revealed significant dysregulation in ligand-receptor pairs relevant to B cell regulation, with activated memory B cells showing the highest number of affected interactions. Notably, negative regulators of B cell receptor (BCR) function were upregulated in CVID B cells.
  • Validation in a cohort: Key findings from the twin study, including DNA methylation alterations and gene expression changes, were validated in an independent cohort of CVID patients.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample size for twin study: While MZ twins are invaluable, the analysis of a single pair has inherent limitations. The validation in a larger cohort helps to mitigate this.
  • In vitro activation: The use of in vitro activated B cells to emulate the GC reaction is a necessary constraint due to ethical considerations but may not fully replicate the in vivo environment.
  • Causality: While the study strongly implicates epigenetic alterations in CVID pathogenesis, definitively proving causality requires further experimental manipulation.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that the identified epigenetic signatures could pave the way for improved diagnosis and novel therapeutic strategies targeting these epigenetic dysregulations. Further research into the precise mechanisms by which these epigenetic changes impact B cell function and cell-cell interactions is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID), the most prevalent symptomatic primary immunodeficiency, is characterized by impaired terminal B-cell differentiation and defective antibody responses. Incomplete genetic penetrance and a wide range of phenotypic expressivity in CVID suggest the participation of additional pathogenic mechanisms. Monozygotic (MZ) twins discordant for CVID are uniquely valuable for studying the contribution of epigenetics to the disease. We used single-cell epigenomics and transcriptomics to create a cell census of naïve-to-memory B cell differentiation in a pair of CVID-discordant MZ twins. Our analysis identifies DNA methylation, chromatin accessibility and transcriptional defects in memory B cells that mirror defective cell-cell communication defects following activation. These findings were validated in a cohort of CVID patients and healthy donors. Our findings provide a comprehensive multi-omics map of alterations in naïve-to-memory B-cell transition in CVID and reveal links between the epigenome and immune cell cross-talk. Our resource, publicly available at the Human Cell Atlas, paves the way for future diagnosis and treatments of CVID patients.
BibTeX
@misc{rodriguezubreva2021single,
  author = {Javier Rodríguez‐Ubreva and Anna Arutyunyan and Marc Jan Bonder and Lucía del Pino Molina and Stephen J. Clark and Carlos de la Calle‐Fabregat and Luz García‐Alonso and Louis‐François Handfield and Laura Ciudad and Eduardo Andrés‐León and Felix Krueger and Francesc Català‐Moll and Virginia Rodríguez-Cortez and Krzysztof Polański and Lira Mamanova and Stijn van Dongen and Vladimir Yu Kiselev and María T. Martínez-Saavedra and Holger Heyn and Javier Martı́n and Klaus Warnatz and Eduardo López‐Granados and Carlos Rodríguez‐Gallego and Oliver Stegle and Gavin Kelsey and Roser Vento‐Tormo and Esteban Ballestar},
  title = {{Single-Cell Atlas of Common Variable Immunodeficiency reveals germinal center-associated epigenetic dysregulation in B cell responses}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.12.20.473453},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure