Simultaneous Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping of Articular Cartilage and Cortical Bone of Human Knee Joint Using Ultrashort Echo Time Sequences

Ming Zhang, Zhihui Li, Hanqi Wang, Tongtong Chen, Yong Lü, Fuhua Yan, Yuyao Zhang, Hongjiang WeiFrontiers in Endocrinology 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Endocrinology, presents a novel MRI-based approach to simultaneously map the magnetic susceptibility of both articular cartilage and cortical bone in the human knee. By utilizing Ultrashort Echo Time (UTE) sequences, the researchers successfully captured signals from tissues that are typically "invisible" to standard MRI, providing a potential radiation-free alternative to CT scans for assessing joint health.

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a UTE-QSM (Ultrashort Echo Time Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping) technique that simultaneously quantifies the magnetic properties of knee cartilage and bone in vivo. The study demonstrates that bone susceptibility correlates significantly with CT values, suggesting a new path for radiation-free bone mineral density and microstructure assessment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of MRI, cortical bone and deep articular cartilage are "difficult" tissues. They have extremely short T2* relaxation times, meaning their signal decays almost instantly after excitation. On conventional Gradient Recalled Echo (GRE) sequences, these areas appear as "signal voids"—essentially black holes of data.

Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping (QSM) is a powerful tool for measuring the magnetic properties of tissues (like iron content or mineralization), but it usually fails in the musculoskeletal system because these signal voids are masked out during processing. This leaves a gap in our ability to non-invasively and simultaneously monitor the degradation of cartilage (as seen in osteoarthritis) and the density of cortical bone without resorting to ionizing radiation from CT scans.

Methods

The researchers employed a 3D multi-echo radial UTE sequence on a 3T MRI scanner. The "secret sauce" is the shortest echo time (TE) of just 0.07 ms, which is fast enough to capture the signal from bone before it disappears.

The processing pipeline involved several sophisticated steps:

  • Water-Fat Separation: Because the knee is rich in marrow and fat, the team used a graph-cut-based algorithm to prevent fat signals from corrupting the magnetic field map.
  • Background Field Removal: They used the V-SHARP algorithm to isolate the local magnetic fields of interest.
  • Susceptibility Reconstruction: They utilized STAR-QSM (Streaking Artifact Reduction for QSM) to create the final quantitative maps.
  • Validation: To validate the bone findings, participants also underwent low-dose CT scans. The researchers then performed a Spearman’s correlation analysis between the MRI-derived susceptibility and CT Hounsfield Units (HU) across 158 regions of interest.

Datasets

The study was prospective and involved:

  • Human Subjects: Five healthy young volunteers (4 males, 1 female; mean age 23.6 years).
  • Imaging Data: Bilateral knee joints (10 total) were scanned using both MRI and low-dose CT.
  • ROIs: 158 representative regions of interest in the cortical bone were used for the correlation analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Breaking the Signal Void: The primary "aha" moment is that UTE-QSM successfully turns the "black holes" of bone into quantitative data points. Bone is no longer just a mask; it is a measurable volume.
  • Laminar Cartilage Structure: The UTE-QSM maps revealed a distinct laminar structure in articular cartilage. Susceptibility changed from diamagnetic in the deep layers (near the bone) to more paramagnetic in the superficial layers. This likely reflects the changing orientation of collagen fibers, which are known to be orientation-dependent in QSM.
  • Bone is Diamagnetic: As expected, cortical bone was found to be mostly diamagnetic. This is due to the high concentration of calcium (in the form of hydroxyapatite), which is a diamagnetic mineral.
  • The MRI-CT Link: The finding of a significant negative correlation between susceptibility and CT values is crucial. It suggests that as bone becomes denser (higher CT value), it becomes more diamagnetic (lower/more negative susceptibility value).

Key Results

  • Simultaneous Mapping: The study is the first to report simultaneous in vivo mapping of both cartilage and bone susceptibility in humans.
  • Quantitative Correlation: A significant negative correlation of r = −0.43 (p < 0.001) was found between the mean susceptibility value and the CT value in cortical bone.
  • Spatial Resolution: The UTE sequence achieved an isotropic spatial resolution of 0.9 mm, allowing for visualization in multiple planes (axial and sagittal) which is vital for complex joint geometry.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles before this enters routine clinical use:

  • Sample Size: The study was limited to five healthy, young volunteers. The performance of UTE-QSM in elderly patients or those with advanced osteoarthritis (OA) or osteoporosis remains to be seen.
  • Resolution vs. SNR: While 0.9 mm is good, the deep layer of articular cartilage is very thin (1-2 pixels). Higher resolution is needed to better characterize the cartilage-bone interface.
  • Registration: The alignment between MRI and CT was checked visually; future studies would benefit from more rigorous, automated quantitative metrics for registration accuracy.
  • Clinical Application: Future work will likely focus on using this tool to track the progression of osteoarthritis, where both cartilage thinning and subchondral bone changes occur simultaneously.

Summary updated

Abstract

UTE-QSM enables simultaneous susceptibility mapping of the articular cartilage and cortical bone of human <i>in vivo</i>. Good association between susceptibility and CT values in cortical bone suggests the potential of UTE-QSM for bone mapping for further clinical application.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022simultaneous,
  author = {Ming Zhang and Zhihui Li and Hanqi Wang and Tongtong Chen and Yong Lü and Fuhua Yan and Yuyao Zhang and Hongjiang Wei},
  title = {{Simultaneous Quantitative Susceptibility Mapping of Articular Cartilage and Cortical Bone of Human Knee Joint Using Ultrashort Echo Time Sequences}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Endocrinology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fendo.2022.844351},
}
Figure