Simultaneous motor preparation and execution in a last-moment reach correction task

K. Cora Ames, Stephen I. Ryu, Krishna V. ShenoyNature Communications 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Motor preparation typically precedes movement and is thought to determine properties of upcoming movements. However, preparation has mostly been studied in point-to-point delayed reaching tasks. Here, we ask whether preparation is engaged during mid-reach modifications. Monkeys reach to targets that occasionally jump locations prior to movement onset, requiring a mid-reach correction. In motor cortex and dorsal premotor cortex, we find that the neural activity that signals when to reach predicts monkeys' jump responses on a trial-by-trial basis. We further identify neural patterns that signal where to reach, either during motor preparation or during motor execution. After a target jump, neural activity responds in both preparatory and movement-related dimensions, even though error in preparatory dimensions can be small at that time. This suggests that the same preparatory process used in delayed reaching is also involved in reach correction. Furthermore, it indicates that motor preparation and execution can be performed simultaneously.

Introduction

In classical motor control theory, reaching for an object involves a sequential "prepare-then-execute" pipeline. This model suggests that the brain first calculates a trajectory (preparation) and then sends motor commands to the muscles (execution). While this framework holds for static tasks, it remains unclear how the brain handles dynamic environments where targets move mid-reach. Does the brain skip preparation during rapid corrections to save time, or is preparation a mandatory bottleneck that must be re-processed, even while the arm is already in motion?

Experimental Design and Methods

To investigate this, researchers trained rhesus macaques to perform a "target jump" task. Monkeys reached for a target that occasionally jumped to a new location either just before movement onset or after the reach had already begun.

Experimental setup showing the target jump task where a monkey corrects its reach mid-flight.

Neural activity was recorded from the primary motor cortex (M1) and dorsal premotor cortex (PMd). To analyze the complex neural firing patterns, the team employed dimensionality reduction to isolate three distinct neural subspaces:

  1. Preparatory Subspace: Signals where to reach before movement.
  2. Trigger Subspace: Signals when to initiate movement.
  3. Movement Subspace: Generates the actual motor commands.
Dimensionality reduction technique used to separate neural firing into preparatory, trigger, and movement dimensions.

Key Insights

The "Always Prepare" Hypothesis

The study found that the brain must re-prepare a movement to change it. Even when a target jumped late and the arm was already in motion, neural activity "re-entered" the preparatory subspace. This suggests that preparation is not just a pre-flight check but a necessary component of motor control that can be re-engaged as needed.

Parallel Processing and Orthogonality

Because preparatory and movement signals reside in "orthogonal" (independent) subspaces, they do not interfere with one another. This allows the motor cortex to act as a parallel processor, preparing a new reach trajectory while simultaneously executing the current motor command. During the delay period, approximately 70% of variance was found in preparatory dimensions; during movement, this flipped to 70% in movement dimensions, yet preparatory activity remained detectable during corrections.

The Trigger Bottleneck

A specific "trigger" signal was identified that predicts, on a trial-by-trial basis, whether the monkey will reach directly to a new target or initially follow the old plan before correcting. This suggests that once a movement is triggered, the initial plan is temporarily locked in, and modifications require a new preparatory cycle.

Results

  • Trigger Prediction: The neural trigger signal predicted the monkey's initial reach angle with high accuracy, explaining a median of 52% of variance in Monkey K.
  • Preparatory Re-entry: Following a target jump, there was a significant increase in activity within preparatory dimensions during the movement epoch. This shift in neural space was significantly larger than the distance between standard reach trajectories (p < 10⁻⁵).
  • Speedup Mechanism: Reach corrections are typically faster than initial reaction times. This research suggests the speedup occurs because the preparation for the correction happens in parallel with the ongoing movement, rather than waiting for the arm to stop.

Discussion and Future Directions

While this study focuses on the cortex, subcortical structures like the cerebellum likely contribute to ultra-fast automatic corrections. Future work may explore more complex movements, such as grasping, to see if they follow similar parallel-processing rules. Additionally, causal studies using optogenetics could confirm if disrupting the preparatory subspace specifically impairs the ability to correct reaches without halting movement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motor preparation typically precedes movement and is thought to determine properties of upcoming movements. However, preparation has mostly been studied in point-to-point delayed reaching tasks. Here, we ask whether preparation is engaged during mid-reach modifications. Monkeys reach to targets that occasionally jump locations prior to movement onset, requiring a mid-reach correction. In motor cortex and dorsal premotor cortex, we find that the neural activity that signals when to reach predicts monkeys' jump responses on a trial-by-trial basis. We further identify neural patterns that signal where to reach, either during motor preparation or during motor execution. After a target jump, neural activity responds in both preparatory and movement-related dimensions, even though error in preparatory dimensions can be small at that time. This suggests that the same preparatory process used in delayed reaching is also involved in reach correction. Furthermore, it indicates that motor preparation and execution can be performed simultaneously.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ames2019simultaneous,
  author = {K. Cora Ames and Stephen I. Ryu and Krishna V. Shenoy},
  title = {{Simultaneous motor preparation and execution in a last-moment reach correction task}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-10772-2},
}
Figure