Simulations Of Galaxy Clusters With And Without Winds: I. The Structure Of Clusters

Christopher A. Metzler, A. E. EvrardarXiv 1997 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study utilizes gas dynamic simulations to investigate the impact of galactic winds on the evolution and structure of galaxy clusters. By comparing two ensembles of 18 realizations—evolved with and without feedback—we demonstrate that energy injection from winds significantly alters the intracluster medium (ICM). While the mass-temperature relation remains largely stable, the non-gravitational energy boosts ICM entropy, resulting in more extended density profiles. This effect is most pronounced in low-mass clusters, providing a potential explanation for observed deviations from self-similar scaling and the systematic underestimation of the cosmic baryon fraction in smaller systems.

Introduction

In the classical "Standard Model" of cluster formation, the hot gas within the intracluster medium (ICM) was treated as primordial material heated solely by gravitational collapse. However, this model fails to account for two critical observational realities: the presence of heavy elements like iron, which necessitates a stellar origin, and the "$\beta$-discrepancy," where the gas appears more spatially extended than the underlying dark matter potential suggests.

This paper addresses the active role of galaxies in cluster evolution. By simulating the ejection of mass and energy from galaxies into the ICM, we explore how galactic winds reshape the density, temperature, and chemical distribution of clusters, and whether these processes can explain why clusters do not follow simple self-similar scaling laws.

Methodology

The research employs an ensemble of 36 cosmological simulations using the P3MSPH algorithm, which integrates Particle-Particle-Particle-Mesh ($P^3M$) for gravitational calculations with Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) for gas dynamics.

The study utilizes a controlled ensemble approach, featuring 18 different initial density realizations. Each realization is evolved under two distinct scenarios:

  1. Two-Fluid (2F) Model: A baseline model consisting only of dark matter and gas.
  2. Ejection (EJ) Model: A model incorporating "galaxy particles" that simulate feedback.

Because resolving individual star formation was computationally prohibitive at the time, galaxies were identified as peaks in the initial density field. These particles were programmed to lose 50% of their initial mass as 8 keV winds at a constant rate from redshift $z=4.5$ to the present. The simulations were conducted within a Cold Dark Matter (CDM) framework ($\Omega=1, \Omega_b=0.1, h=0.5$), generating a synthetic dataset of clusters spanning a decade in temperature (1 to 10 keV).

The Energetics of Feedback: Energy vs. Work

A primary finding of this study is that the energy injected by galactic winds does not primarily manifest as a temperature increase in the ICM. Instead, the wind energy is consumed as mechanical work to "lift" the gas within the dark matter-dominated potential well. Consequently, while the final gas temperature remains relatively unaffected—maintaining a consistent mass-temperature relation across both models—the central gas density drops significantly as the material is pushed toward the cluster outskirts.

Breaking Self-Similarity

The impact of these winds is highly mass-dependent, breaking the "self-similarity" expected in purely gravitational models. In massive, high-temperature clusters, the energy injected by winds is a negligible fraction of the total gravitational binding energy. However, in smaller, cooler clusters, the wind energy is comparable to the gas's thermal energy. This leads to a significant flattening of the gas density profiles in low-mass systems. Specifically, the outer power-law slope of the gas density ($\alpha_{gas}$) flattens from approximately 0.87 in the no-wind case to 0.70 in the wind-inclusive case for cool clusters.

Observational Implications

The Baryon Fraction

The redistribution of gas has profound implications for measuring the cosmic baryon fraction. Because winds push gas toward the cluster periphery, measurements taken within standard radii (such as $r_{500}$) tend to underestimate the true baryon content. In 1 keV clusters, the local baryon fraction was found to be only ~50% of the cosmic mean, whereas 10 keV clusters retained ~90%. This suggests that low-temperature clusters are particularly susceptible to "baryon deficiency" in X-ray observations.

Velocity Bias and Metallicity Gradients

The simulations reveal a persistent velocity bias, with galaxies moving more slowly than dark matter particles ($\sigma_{gal} \simeq 0.84\sigma_{DM}$). This bias stems from the initial placement of galaxies on density peaks and subsequent dynamical friction. Furthermore, because the sources of enrichment (galaxies) are more centrally concentrated than the extended gas, the models produce strong, negative radial gradients in metallicity, consistent with observed iron abundance patterns in the ICM.

Conclusions and Limitations

While galactic winds successfully explain the flattening of density profiles and the mass-dependent scaling of the ICM, some discrepancies remain. The simulations still struggle to produce the large, flat "gas cores" observed in many X-ray clusters, a failure likely linked to the numerical limitations of SPH smoothing or the specific timing of the wind injection. Future work incorporating radiative cooling, more complex star formation histories, and higher resolution will be necessary to fully reconcile these models with the detailed internal structures of galaxy clusters.

Summary updated

Abstract

We use gas dynamic simulations to explore the effects of galactic winds on galaxy clusters. Two ensembles of 18 realizations, spanning a decade in temperature, are evolved with and without winds in an underlying biased CDM cosmology. Galaxies are identified as peaks in the initial density field, and are assumed to lose half their initial mass over a Hubble time in winds with an effective temperature of 8 keV. The energy input through winds boosts the entropy of the ICM above that generated by infall, resulting in a more extended density profile. The magnitude of this effect increases with decreasing mass or temperature, consistent with observations. The extended nature of the ICM with winds can lead to underestimates of the global baryon fraction, with low-temperature clusters particularly deficient. We calibrate the amplitude of this effect at density contrasts of 170 and 500. On the other hand, the final temperature of the gas is relatively unaffected; a similar mass-temperature relation exists with or without winds. The input wind energy is effectively consumed as work to lift the gas in the dark matter dominated potential. While the dark matter profile exhibits a self-similar form seen in other studies, the galaxy distribution is more centrally concentrated than either the dark matter or gas, and evidences a mild velocity bias. The gradient of galaxies with respect to primordial gas produces strong, negative radial gradients in metallicity within the ICM.
BibTeX
@misc{metzler1997simulations,
  author = {Christopher A. Metzler and A. E. Evrard},
  title = {{Simulations Of Galaxy Clusters With And Without Winds: I. The Structure Of Clusters}},
  year = {1997},
  eprint = {astro-ph/9710324},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9710324},
}

Loading related content...

Figure