Simulation results of transverse-optical confinement in airpost, regrown, and oxidized vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser structures

Peter Bienstman, B. Demeulenaere, Bart Dhoedt, Roel BaetsJournal of the Optical Society of America B 1999 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a sophisticated vectorial optical model to simulate vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs). By applying this model to different VCSEL structures (airpost, regrown, and oxide-apertured), the authors reveal a fundamental trade-off between achieving low threshold gain for the fundamental laser mode and maintaining good modal stability, a critical consideration for device performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs) are crucial components in modern optoelectronics, but their performance is heavily influenced by how the laser light is confined within the device. This confinement, known as transverse-optical confinement, is typically achieved through physical structures like airpost pillars or oxide apertures. However, designing these structures to simultaneously minimize the threshold current (requiring low gain) and ensure the laser operates stably on its fundamental mode (avoiding higher-order modes) is a complex challenge. Existing models often struggle to accurately capture the behavior of these structures, especially those with strong index contrasts and dimensions close to the wavelength of light. This paper aims to address this by providing a rigorous vectorial model and using it to systematically investigate the impact of different confinement strategies on VCSEL performance.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel numerical optical model based on a vectorial eigenmode expansion. Unlike previous methods that either used simplified scalar equations or only considered guided modes, this model incorporates both guided and radiation modes. This allows for the accurate simulation of diffraction effects, which are significant in VCSELs. The model also accounts for the gain profile within the active region, enabling "hot-cavity" calculations.

The simulation geometry involves enclosing the VCSEL structure within a perfectly conducting cylinder to discretize the radiative mode spectrum. Within each layer, the total electromagnetic field is expressed as a superposition of forward and backward propagating eigenmodes. For non-uniform layers, these modes are further decomposed into simpler eigenmodes of a uniformly filled cylinder. The reflection and transmission matrices at layer interfaces are calculated using a mode-matching technique, and the overall stack behavior is determined via a scattering matrix approach.

The threshold material gain and lasing wavelength are found by solving a resonance condition derived from the round-trip reflection matrices of the cavity. This involves finding eigenvalues of a specific matrix that correspond to unity gain. Singular value decomposition is used to enhance numerical stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors present simulation results based on their developed model, rather than experimental data or pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Fundamental Trade-off: The most significant insight is the clear demonstration of a trade-off between low threshold gain for the fundamental mode and good modal stability across various VCSEL structures. This means optimizing for one often compromises the other.
  • Structure-Specific Behavior: Different confinement strategies (airpost, regrown, oxide) exhibit distinct performance characteristics. Airpost structures, for instance, offer better confinement and lower thresholds compared to regrown structures due to a higher index contrast.
  • Oxide Aperture Placement is Crucial: For oxide-apertured VCSELs, the position of the oxide aperture relative to the standing wave pattern within the cavity is critical. Antinode placement (at a field maximum) leads to reduced threshold gain but sacrifices modal selectivity, while node placement (at a field minimum) enhances modal stability at the cost of a higher threshold.
  • Device Size Matters: Smaller VCSEL devices generally suffer from higher diffraction losses, leading to increased threshold gain, a finding consistent across different structures.
  • Model Validation: The simulation trends generally align with experimental observations, lending credibility to the developed vectorial model.

Key Results

  • Airpost VCSELs: Increasing the etch depth in airpost VCSELs leads to lower threshold gains due to improved mode confinement. Modal stability is better for smaller devices and deeper etches, though deep etches can reduce the gain difference between the fundamental and higher-order modes.
  • Regrown VCSELs: These structures generally exhibit higher threshold gains than airpost VCSELs due to lower index contrast. The threshold gain behavior with etch depth is more complex, initially increasing before decreasing as waveguiding becomes dominant. Modal stability is significantly better in regrown structures compared to airpost ones.
  • Oxide-Apertured VCSELs (980 nm):
    • Antinode oxide placement results in significantly reduced threshold gain for the fundamental mode but also leads to a reduced modal selectivity.
  • Node oxide placement provides good modal stability but at the expense of a higher threshold for the fundamental mode.
  • All simulated oxide-apertured structures exhibit a blueshift in their lasing wavelength compared to the design wavelength.
  • A thick $\lambda/4$ oxide aperture provides thresholds comparable to a thin antinode oxide but with smaller blueshifts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Discrepancy: The model predicts that regrown devices should lase down to smaller diameters than airpost structures, which contradicts experimental findings. The authors attribute this discrepancy to the superior heat conductivity of regrown InP, allowing for more efficient cooling, a factor not explicitly included in the current optical model.
  • Oscillations in Losses: The paper notes that oscillations in losses as a function of etch depth, observed in other studies, are not clearly reproduced in their results. This is attributed to the deeper etching in their simulated structures and the fact that oscillations tend to decrease with deeper etching in other reported devices.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their model can be used for further optimization of VCSEL properties. The insights gained regarding the trade-offs in different structures provide a roadmap for designing improved VCSELs. The model's ability to handle complex structures and vectorial effects opens avenues for simulating more advanced VCSEL designs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on a numerical optical model for calculating threshold material gain in vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser, we investigate the influence of transverse-optical confinement in airpost, regrown, and oxidized structures. In each of these cases, we demonstrate the trade-off that needs to be made between low threshold for the fundamental laser mode and good modal stability.
BibTeX
@article{bienstman1999simulation,
  author = {Peter Bienstman and B. Demeulenaere and Bart Dhoedt and Roel Baets},
  title = {{Simulation results of transverse-optical confinement in airpost, regrown, and oxidized vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser structures}},
  journal = {Journal of the Optical Society of America B},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1364/josab.16.002055},
}
Figure