Simulation of Runoff and Glacier Mass Balance and Sensitivity Analysis in a Glacierized Basin, North-Eastern Qinhai-Tibetan Plateau, China

Xiaopeng Zhang, Xiang Qin, Chunhai Xu, Yushuo LiuWater 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses the HBV-light hydrological model to simulate runoff and glacier mass balance in China's Laohugou Glacier Basin (LHGB) from 1959-2015. It reveals a significant increase in runoff driven by rising temperatures, alongside a negative glacier mass balance, indicating a weakening of glaciers' role in regulating water resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mountainous regions with glaciers, like the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, are crucial water sources. However, the impact of climate change on their hydrology and glacier mass balance, particularly over long historical periods, remains poorly understood. This paper addresses this knowledge gap by quantifying the historical trends in runoff and glacier mass balance in the Laohugou Glacier Basin (LHGB) and analyzing the sensitivity of these hydrological processes to changes in temperature, precipitation, and glacier area. Understanding these dynamics is vital for managing water resources in downstream arid and semi-arid regions.

Methods

The researchers employed the HBV-light conceptual hydrological model, enhanced with a Glacier Ablation Module (GAM). This model was forced with reconstructed daily temperature and precipitation data, along with digital elevation model (DEM) and evaporation data. The model was calibrated using a Genetic Algorithm Calibration Procedure (GAP) to optimize its parameters for simulating runoff depth and glacier mass balance. Sensitivity analyses were conducted by systematically altering temperature, precipitation, and glacier area to assess their individual and combined impacts on runoff.

Datasets

  • Geographical Data: Digital vector map of modern glaciers and a 30-m resolution Global Digital Elevation Model (DEM) from the Chinese Glacier Inventory.
  • Meteorological Data:
    • Historical data from the first Chinese Alpine glacier, hydrology and meteorological observation station (1958-1962).
  • Data from three automatic weather stations (AWS1, AWS2, AWS3) in the LHGB (2008-present).
  • Reconstructed daily air temperature and precipitation data from 1959-2015, derived from six national weather stations and the AWS1 data.
  • Hydrological Data:
    • Historical hydrological data from the LHGB (1959-1961).
  • Updated water level and flow velocity data from an automatic HOBO meter (2014-2015).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Glaciers as sensitive climate indicators: The study reinforces the understanding that glaciers are highly responsive to climate shifts, making them crucial barometers of change.
  • Warming drives increased runoff, but at a cost: While rising temperatures have led to increased meltwater and thus higher runoff, this comes at the expense of glacier mass balance, suggesting a potentially unsustainable water supply in the long term.
  • Temperature is the dominant driver: The research highlights that temperature plays a more significant role in influencing runoff in this high-altitude, glacier-dominated basin than precipitation alone.
  • Future water resource vulnerability: The projected weakening of glaciers' buffering capacity for low flows and peak flow regulation poses a significant risk to water security in downstream arid and semi-arid regions.

Key Results

  • Warming Trend: The LHGB experienced a warming trend of 0.40 °C per decade and a precipitation increase of 1.6 mm per year from 1959 to 2015.
  • Runoff Increase: Simulated annual runoff depth increased significantly at a rate of 5.7 mm per year (p < 0.01) from 1959 to 2015.
  • Negative Glacier Mass Balance: The modeled glacier mass balance (GMB) for the LHGB was -280.5 mm w.e. per year, and the overall glacier mass balance showed a thinning of 17.55 m w.e. from 1959 to 2015.
  • Sensitivity to Temperature: Runoff was found to be more sensitive to temperature variations than precipitation. A 4°C temperature increase led to a 169% increase in annual runoff.
  • Impact of Glacier Area Loss: A 10% decrease in glacier area resulted in a 20.4% decrease in peak runoff (July), highlighting the critical role of glaciers in regulating seasonal water availability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Reconstructed Data Uncertainty: While efforts were made to reconstruct temperature and precipitation, uncertainties remain, particularly for precipitation due to its complex spatial variability.
  • Constant Glacier Area Assumption: For the historical simulation period, a constant glacier area was assumed, which introduces uncertainty as glacier areas have changed over time. The sensitivity analysis using different glacier areas partially addresses this.
  • Model Parameterization: The use of single values for temperature and precipitation gradients, and the assumption that model parameters remain constant over time and space, are simplifications.
  • Exclusion of Permafrost Thaw: The contribution of permafrost thaw to runoff was not considered, potentially leading to an overestimation of glacier mass loss.
  • Simplified Ablation Model: The degree-day factor model does not account for radiation ablation, which can affect accuracy, especially with finer temporal resolutions.

Future work could focus on incorporating spatially variable parameters, modeling the dynamic changes in glacier area, and potentially including permafrost dynamics for a more comprehensive understanding. Despite these limitations, the study provides valuable insights into the long-term hydrological trends and climate change impacts in this critical region.

Summary updated

Abstract

Glaciers have been recognized as the most sensitive indicators of climate change. Mountainous areas, with their characteristic snow and glacier cover, have long been recognized as special hydrological environments, receiving above-average amounts of precipitation. The streams originating in the mountains, nourished with distinct seasonal variations, provide water for the populations of the adjacent lowland. Little is known about the effect of climate change on snow and glacier hydrology and glacier mass balance in the Laohugou Glacier Basin (LHGB) over the past 50 years. A study of the glacier basin was performed to quantify the expected impact of climate change on the hydrology in the north-eastern Qinghai-Tibet Plateau. The DEM (Digital Elevation Model) data, daily temperature, daily precipitation, and evaporation data were applied to force the HBV (Hydrologiska Byrans Vattenbalansavdelning)-light conceptual model to simulate runoff depth and glacier mass balance in the historical period (1959–2015). A genetic calibration algorithm approach (GAP method) was used to obtain parameter sets that reproduced observed runoff depth well. The results suggested a drastic increase of the runoff depth from 1995 to 2015 in the Laohugou glacier basin driven by increased temperature. Temperature and precipitation increased by 0.40 °C (10a)−1 and 1.6 mm·a−1 (p &lt; 0.01), respectively, at AWS1 (the automatic weather station at 4192 m a.s.l. near the hydrological station) in the LHGB from 1959 to 2015. The simulated runoff depth increased at 5.7 mm·a−1 (p &lt; 0.01), the glacier mass balance (GMB) of the LHGB was −280.5 mm·a−1, and the overall glacier mass balance was −17.55 m w.e. from 1959 to 2015. The runoff is found to be more sensitive to the variation of temperature than the variation of precipitation. When the glacier area is decreased by 10%, 53%, and 100%, the peak runoff (July) decreased by 20.4%, 54.2%, and 72.3% relative to the baseline, respectively. In the future climate, the function of glaciers in compensating a potential low flow and regulating peak flow will be weakened in the critical months.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018simulation,
  author = {Xiaopeng Zhang and Xiang Qin and Chunhai Xu and Yushuo Liu},
  title = {{Simulation of Runoff and Glacier Mass Balance and Sensitivity Analysis in a Glacierized Basin, North-Eastern Qinhai-Tibetan Plateau, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/w10091259},
}
Figure