Simulation of Non-Carious Cervical Lesions by Computational Toothbrush Model: A Novel Three-Dimensional Discrete Element Method

Jinsu Nam, Duong Hong Nguyen, Seungjun Lee, Seok‐Mo Heo, Junyoung ParkSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel 3D computational model of a toothbrush using the Discrete Element Method (DEM) to simulate non-carious cervical lesions (NCCLs) on teeth. The study reveals that brushing force (depth) has a greater impact on tooth abrasion than brushing speed, with abrasion primarily occurring in the interproximal space, suggesting forceful brushing as a key contributor to NCCLs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Non-carious cervical lesions (NCCLs) are common tooth abrasions near the gum line, but their exact formation mechanisms, especially those related to toothbrushing, are not fully understood due to the complex interplay of factors like mechanical stress, acid erosion, and toothbrushing wear. Existing numerical tools for analyzing toothbrushing abrasion are limited, making it difficult to investigate how different brushing parameters contribute to NCCLs. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a computational model to simulate and quantify toothbrushing abrasion.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional Discrete Element Method (DEM) to model the complex interactions during toothbrushing. Key methodological components include:

  • Computational Toothbrush Model: Bristles were represented using a "connected particle model" (specifically, a worm-like chain model), allowing for the simulation of bending, stretching, and torsion. This approach overcomes the limitations of traditional methods in capturing multiple bristle-tuft contacts.
  • Tooth Model: A simplified tooth model consisting of flat plates and grooves was used to represent anterior teeth and the interproximal space, allowing for the simulation of abrasion in these critical areas.
  • Archard Wear Model: This established model was integrated to quantify the amount of tooth material abraded based on the forces and sliding distances calculated by the DEM simulation.
  • Simulation Parameters: Brushing speed and depth were varied to assess their individual and combined effects on abrasion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on material properties from existing literature for enamel and acrylic.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Forceful Brushing is Key: The study strongly suggests that the depth of brushing (i.e., how hard you press) is a more significant factor in causing tooth abrasion and NCCLs than the speed at which you brush.
  • Interproximal Space is Vulnerable: Abrasion is predominantly concentrated in the interproximal space between teeth. This implies that the forces exerted by bristles in these tight areas are particularly damaging.
  • DEM for Complex Interactions: The successful application of DEM with a connected particle model for toothbrush bristles demonstrates its potential for simulating complex tribological interactions involving flexible elements.
  • Simplified Model's Utility: Even with simplified tooth and bristle models, the simulation provides valuable insights into the mechanics of abrasion, highlighting the feasibility of such computational approaches.

Key Results

  • Brushing Depth Dominance: The difference in abrasion caused by varying brushing depth (dz = r vs. dz = r/4) was more pronounced than the difference observed when varying brushing speed.
  • Abrasion Concentration: Abrasion was most severe on the sides of the interproximal space, indicating that NCCLs likely initiate from this area and spread towards the tooth's center.
  • Force Distribution: Forces were not uniformly distributed across all bristles; they tended to concentrate on specific bristles, especially in the interproximal space.
  • Force Magnitude: The tangential force was generally greater than the normal force. At the interproximal space, peak normal and contact forces were approximately 10 times higher than the average force.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Tooth Model: The study used a flat tooth model, which doesn't fully represent the complex anatomical curvature of real teeth. Future work should involve more detailed tooth models.
  • Simplified Bristle Model: Bristles were modeled as a single tuft in some instances, and the interaction of individual filaments within a tuft could be further refined.
  • Exclusion of Other Factors: Chemical and biological erosions were not considered, focusing solely on mechanical abrasion. Future research could integrate these factors.
  • Scrub Method Focus: The simulation was based on the "scrub" brushing method. Investigating other common brushing techniques (e.g., Bass, Roll) would provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Future Directions: The authors plan to analyze wear by modeling individual bristles on realistic human teeth and propose applying the DEM model in multi-centered clinical trials to investigate the relationship between tooth wear and interdental embrasures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Non-carious cervical lesions (NCCLs) are saucer-shaped abrasions of a tooth. NCCLs can form due to various etiologies, including toothbrushing wear, acid erosion, and mechanical stress. Owing to this complex interplay, the mechanism of NCCLs in tooth abrasion has not been established. This study aims to develop a numerical method using a computational toothbrush to simulate NCCLs. The forces acting on the teeth and the amount of abrasion generated were evaluated. The discrete element method using in-house code, connected particle model, and Archard wear model were applied for brushing. In the toothbrush model, 42 acrylic tufts were fixed into a toothbrush head. The teeth models with enamel properties comprised four flat plates and two grooves to simulate the anterior teeth and NCCLs. The brushing speed and depth for one cycle were established as simulation parameters. The force applied within the ununiform plane was concentrated on several bristles as the toothbrush passed through the interproximal space. The brushing force (depth) had a greater effect on tooth abrasion than the brushing speed. Toothbrushing abrasion was mainly concentrated in the interproximal space. Therefore, forceful tooth brushing can cause NCCLs from the interproximal space to the cervical area of the tooth.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nam2022simulation,
  author = {Jinsu Nam and Duong Hong Nguyen and Seungjun Lee and Seok‐Mo Heo and Junyoung Park},
  title = {{Simulation of Non-Carious Cervical Lesions by Computational Toothbrush Model: A Novel Three-Dimensional Discrete Element Method}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22114183},
}
Figure