Simulation of classical Ising-like magnetism with a Mott insulator of paired atoms

Ren Liao, Jingxin Sun, Hui Li, Shifeng Yang, Pengju Zhao, Xinyi Huang, Wei Xiong, Xiaoji Zhou, Dingping Li, Xiongjun Liu, Xuzong ChenarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Quantum simulation of the XXZ model with a two-component Bose or Fermi Hubbard model based on a Mott insulator background has been widely used in the investigations of quantum magnetism with ultracold neutral atoms. In most cases, the diagonal spin-spin interaction is always accompanied by a large spin-exchange interaction which hinders the formation of long-range magnetic order at low temperature. Here we show that the spin-exchange interaction can be strongly reduced in a Mott insulator of paired atoms, while the diagonal spin-spin interaction remains unaffected. Thus, the effective magnetic model is quite close to an exact classical Ising model in the textbook. And we analysed an experimentally achievable three-component Fermi-Hubbard model of $\mathrm{{}^{6}Li}$ with two hyperfine levels of atoms paired in the lattice. We find the long-range antiferromagnetic order of such a three-component Fermi-Hubbard model can be much stronger than that of a typical two-component Fermi-Hubbard model at low temperature. And we discussed the possiblity of simulating an exact two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model in a Mott insulator of paired bosonic atoms. Our results may be useful for experimental investigation of the long-range Ising-like magnetism with ultracold neutral atoms under thermal equilibrium.

Introduction

Quantum simulators using ultracold atoms in optical lattices are powerful tools for exploring fundamental magnetic models. Typically, these systems implement the Hubbard model, which in the Mott insulating regime maps to the XXZ model. This model consists of a diagonal "Ising-like" interaction ($J_z$) and a transverse spin-exchange interaction ($J_\perp$). In standard experimental setups, $J_\perp$ is often large, introducing quantum fluctuations that wash out long-range magnetic order. This makes it challenging to observe the clean phase transitions associated with the classical Ising model ($J_\perp = 0$).

The Paired-Atom Mapping Mechanism

To address this, researchers propose a novel mapping using paired atoms. Instead of a single atom representing a spin state, a pair of atoms on a lattice site is used. In a standard Mott insulator, superexchange allows spins to swap easily via second-order processes. However, when using atom pairs, the physical process required to swap the effective spins of adjacent sites becomes a higher-order perturbation.

Schematic of the mapping from a Mott insulator of paired atoms to an effective spin model. (a) Standard mapping of single atoms. (b) Second-order hopping processes for paired atoms. (c) Mapping for bosonic pairs.

As illustrated in Figure 1, this pairing acts as a symmetry-based filter. It preserves the strength of the diagonal interaction ($J_z$) while significantly suppressing the unwanted spin-exchange interaction ($J_\perp$). This results in an effective Hamiltonian that closely approximates the classical Ising model.

Implementation in Three-Component Fermi-Hubbard Systems

The study focuses on an experimentally viable three-component Fermi-Hubbard (TFH) model using $^{6}\text{Li}$ atoms. By utilizing three hyperfine states—where state $|a\rangle$ represents "spin up" and a pair of atoms in states $|b\rangle$ and $|c\rangle$ represents "spin down"—the system can be tuned to a "sweet spot." For $^{6}\text{Li}$, a magnetic field range of approximately 570–590 Gauss minimizes three-body recombination losses while optimizing interaction strengths. At 576 G, for instance, the diagonal interaction $J_z \approx 29$ nK dominates the suppressed exchange $J_{xy} \approx 6.3$ nK.

Enhanced Magnetic Order and Stability

Numerical simulations using Exact Diagonalization demonstrate that this TFH model supports much stronger long-range antiferromagnetic order than the standard two-component Fermi-Hubbard (FH) model at comparable temperatures.

Comparison of magnetic order between the standard FH and the proposed TFH models. (a) Staggered magnetization $m_z$ and nearest-neighbor correlation $C_1$ vs temperature. (b) Spatial correlation maps $C_{\mathbf{d}}$ showing enhanced checkerboard patterns in the TFH model.

As shown in Figure 4, the staggered magnetization ($m_z$) in the TFH model remains significantly higher as temperature increases. The spatial correlation maps further confirm that the signature checkerboard pattern of antiferromagnetism is far more robust in the paired-atom system. This suggests that long-range Ising-like magnetism can be observed at temperatures already achievable in current experimental laboratories.

Conclusion

By utilizing paired atoms in a Mott insulator, researchers can effectively "mute" quantum noise from spin-exchange interactions. This approach provides a stable, experimentally feasible path to simulating classical Ising magnetism. Future work may extend this to bosonic systems to explore ferromagnetic Ising models in higher dimensions, potentially unlocking insights into 3D phase transitions that lack exact analytical solutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum simulation of the XXZ model with a two-component Bose or Fermi Hubbard model based on a Mott insulator background has been widely used in the investigations of quantum magnetism with ultracold neutral atoms. In most cases, the diagonal spin-spin interaction is always accompanied by a large spin-exchange interaction which hinders the formation of long-range magnetic order at low temperature. Here we show that the spin-exchange interaction can be strongly reduced in a Mott insulator of paired atoms, while the diagonal spin-spin interaction remains unaffected. Thus, the effective magnetic model is quite close to an exact classical Ising model in the textbook. And we analysed an experimentally achievable three-component Fermi-Hubbard model of $\mathrm{{}^{6}Li}$ with two hyperfine levels of atoms paired in the lattice. We find the long-range antiferromagnetic order of such a three-component Fermi-Hubbard model can be much stronger than that of a typical two-component Fermi-Hubbard model at low temperature. And we discussed the possiblity of simulating an exact two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model in a Mott insulator of paired bosonic atoms. Our results may be useful for experimental investigation of the long-range Ising-like magnetism with ultracold neutral atoms under thermal equilibrium.
BibTeX
@misc{liao2021simulation,
  author = {Ren Liao and Jingxin Sun and Hui Li and Shifeng Yang and Pengju Zhao and Xinyi Huang and Wei Xiong and Xiaoji Zhou and Dingping Li and Xiongjun Liu and Xuzong Chen},
  title = {{Simulation of classical Ising-like magnetism with a Mott insulator of paired atoms}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.06422},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.06422},
}

Loading related content...

Figure