Simulation and Reconstruction of Runoff in the High-Cold Mountains Area Based on Multiple Machine Learning Models

Shuyang Wang, Meiping Sun, Guoyu Wang, Xiaojun Yao, Meng Wang, Jiawei Li, Hongyu Duan, Zhenyu Xie, Ruiyi Fan, Yang YangWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tackles the challenge of simulating and reconstructing river runoff in the data-scarce, high-cold mountain regions of the Hotan River Basin. By employing a suite of machine learning models and rigorous feature selection, the researchers identified air temperature as the dominant factor influencing runoff and demonstrated the effectiveness of gradient boosting and random forest models for accurate simulation and reconstruction, even with limited data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate forecasting of river runoff is crucial for managing water resources, especially in arid and semi-arid regions that rely on meltwater from high-cold mountain areas (HCMA). However, these regions often suffer from a scarcity of meteorological and hydrological monitoring stations, leading to inconsistent and incomplete time-series data. This data deficit makes traditional hydrological modeling difficult and hinders effective water resource management, potentially leading to issues like increased flooding or water scarcity downstream. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using machine learning to simulate and reconstruct runoff in the Yurungkash and Kalakash river basins, tributaries of the Hotan River, despite these data limitations.

Methods

The study employed a multi-stage approach:

  1. Feature Selection: To identify the most influential factors for runoff prediction, the researchers used two primary methods:
  2. Pearson Correlation Coefficient: This statistical measure quantified the linear relationship between various input variables (meteorological data, atmospheric circulation indices) and runoff.
  3. Random Forest Feature Importance: This machine learning technique assessed the contribution of each input feature to the model's predictive accuracy.
  4. These methods helped select a parsimonious set of 12 key input variables.
  5. Machine Learning Model Application: Eight different machine learning regression models were utilized for runoff simulation: Random Forest (RF), Gradient Boosting (GB), Support Vector Regression (SVR), AdaBoost, K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN), Bagging, Ridge, and Linear Regression. These models were trained on historical data and then used to simulate runoff.
  6. Model Evaluation: The performance of the models was assessed using standard hydrological metrics:
  7. Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE): Measures the goodness of fit between simulated and observed runoff.
  8. Percentage Bias (PBIAS): Indicates the average tendency of the simulated data to be larger or smaller than the observed data.
  9. Root Mean Square Error (RMSE): Reflects the overall deviation between predictions and observations.
  10. Mean Absolute Error (MAE): Measures the average magnitude of prediction errors.
  11. Runoff Reconstruction: For the Kalakash River, where data was missing for a specific period, the best-performing models from the simulation phase were used to reconstruct the historical runoff data.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Meteorological Data (1958-2019): Monthly data including air temperature (T_mean), soil temperature (DT_mean), total precipitation (P20_20), relative humidity (RH), sunshine hours (Sun), and wind speed (Wind) from the Hotan Meteorological Station.
  • Hydrological Data:
    • Monthly runoff data for the Yurungkash River (1958-2019) from the Tongguzilouke Hydrographic Station.
  • Monthly runoff data for the Kalakash River (1958-1998) from the Wuluwati Hydrographic Station (data for 1999-2019 was missing).
  • Atmospheric Circulation Data (1958-2019): Monthly indices including El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO), Arctic Oscillation (AO), Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO), North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), and Western Pacific Subtropical High Pressure Intensity (WPSHI).

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study used existing historical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Air Temperature Reigns Supreme: The study strongly highlights air temperature as the most critical driver of runoff variability in this high-cold mountain region. This is likely due to its direct impact on glacier and snowmelt processes, which are the primary sources of water in this arid environment.
  • Machine Learning's Power in Data Scarcity: The research demonstrates that machine learning models can effectively simulate and reconstruct runoff even with limited and inconsistent historical data, a significant advantage over traditional methods in such challenging environments.
  • Model Ensemble is Key: No single machine learning model is universally best. The study's success stems from comparing multiple models and identifying the top performers (Gradient Boosting and Random Forest) for specific tasks.
  • Feature Engineering Matters: The rigorous feature selection process, combining correlation analysis and feature importance, was crucial for building accurate and efficient models by focusing on the most relevant input variables.

Key Results

  • Top Performers: Gradient Boosting and Random Forest models consistently outperformed others in simulating the Yurungkash River runoff, achieving Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) scores of 0.84 and 0.82, respectively.
  • Feature Importance: Air temperature (T_mean) was identified as the most influential input parameter, with a Pearson correlation coefficient (ρXY) of 0.63 and a Random Forest Feature Importance (FI) of 0.723. Soil temperature was the next most important factor.
  • Kalakash River Reconstruction: The selected models (Gradient Boosting, Random Forest, AdaBoost, and Bagging) successfully simulated the Kalakash River runoff (NSE > 0.75) and accurately reconstructed the missing data from 1999-2019, capturing intra-annual and inter-annual runoff variations.
  • Model Performance: For the Yurungkash River, Gradient Boosting achieved the best NSE (0.84), followed closely by Random Forest (0.82). Linear regression and Ridge models performed poorly (NSE < 0.53).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Capture of Runoff Extremes: The authors acknowledge that while the models achieved high accuracy, they sometimes struggled to precisely capture the timing and magnitude of runoff peaks. This is attributed to the inherent non-stationarity and complexity of hydrological processes in HCMA, as well as the monthly scale of the data.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: The study notes that while some models were tuned, a more extensive hyperparameter optimization across all models could further improve performance.
  • Model Interpretability: Machine learning models, particularly "black box" models, offer limited insight into the underlying physical processes, making direct comparison and theoretical understanding challenging.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest incorporating more variable daily-scale meteorological and hydrological data, as well as remote sensing data (e.g., glacier and snowmelt area changes), to further optimize runoff simulation and reconstruction. They also propose exploring hybrid approaches that combine machine learning with traditional physical hydrological models to leverage the strengths of both.

Summary updated

Abstract

Runoff from the high-cold mountains area (HCMA) is the most important water resource in the arid zone, and its accurate forecasting is key to the scientific management of water resources downstream of the basin. Constrained by the scarcity of meteorological and hydrological stations in the HCMA and the inconsistency of the observed time series, the simulation and reconstruction of mountain runoff have always been a focus of cold region hydrological research. Based on the runoff observations of the Yurungkash and Kalakash Rivers, the upstream tributaries of the Hotan River on the northern slope of the Kunlun Mountains at different time periods, and the meteorological and atmospheric circulation indices, we used feature analysis and machine learning methods to select the input elements, train, simulate, and select the preferences of the machine learning models of the runoffs of the two watersheds, and reconstruct the missing time series runoff of the Kalakash River. The results show the following. (1) Air temperature is the most important driver of runoff variability in mountainous areas upstream of the Hotan River, and had the strongest performance in terms of the Pearson correlation coefficient (ρXY) and random forest feature importance (FI) (ρXY = 0.63, FI = 0.723), followed by soil temperature (ρXY = 0.63, FI = 0.043), precipitation, hours of sunshine, wind speed, relative humidity, and atmospheric circulation were weakly correlated. A total of 12 elements were selected as the machine learning input data. (2) Comparing the results of the Yurungkash River runoff simulated by eight machine learning methods, we found that the gradient boosting and random forest methods performed best, followed by the AdaBoost and Bagging methods, with Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency coefficients (NSE) of 0.84, 0.82, 0.78, and 0.78, while the support vector regression (NSE = 0.68), ridge (NSE = 0.53), K-nearest neighbor (NSE = 0.56), and linear regression (NSE = 0.51) were simulated poorly. (3) The application of four machine learning methods, gradient boosting, random forest, AdaBoost, and bagging, to simulate the runoff of the Kalakash River for 1978–1998 was generally outstanding, with the NSE exceeding 0.75, and the results of reconstructing the runoff data for the missing period (1999–2019) could well reflect the characteristics of the intra-annual and inter-annual changes in runoff.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023simulation,
  author = {Shuyang Wang and Meiping Sun and Guoyu Wang and Xiaojun Yao and Meng Wang and Jiawei Li and Hongyu Duan and Zhenyu Xie and Ruiyi Fan and Yang Yang},
  title = {{Simulation and Reconstruction of Runoff in the High-Cold Mountains Area Based on Multiple Machine Learning Models}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15183222},
}
Figure