Simulation and Experiment of Substation Grounding Resistance Measurement Based on Pseudorandom Signal

Qingming Duan, Bofeng Zou, Shanshan Li, Hu Zhao2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for measuring substation grounding resistance using pseudorandom signals and correlation identification. By leveraging the anti-interference capabilities of m-sequence signals, the proposed technique offers a more accurate and robust alternative to traditional methods, especially in noisy environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate measurement of substation grounding resistance is crucial for ensuring the safety and reliability of electrical power systems. However, existing methods, like the fall-of-potential technique, are susceptible to various interferences, including electromagnetic fields and soil resistivity variations, leading to inaccurate readings. This complexity makes it challenging for engineers to reliably assess and maintain grounding systems, potentially leading to operational accidents. The paper aims to address this by developing a measurement method that is less affected by noise and provides more stable and accurate results.

Methods

The core of this research lies in applying system identification principles, specifically using the m-sequence pseudorandom signal and correlation analysis.

  • Pseudorandom Signal Generation: The study utilizes m-sequence signals, which are known for their desirable autocorrelation properties, closely resembling white noise within a certain frequency range. These signals are generated using a shift register.
  • Correlation Identification: The method involves injecting the pseudorandom signal (as the excitation signal) into the grounding resistance model and measuring the response. The autocorrelation function of the excitation signal and the cross-correlation function between the excitation and response signals are computed.
  • System Identification: By dividing the power spectrum of the cross-correlation function by the power spectrum of the autocorrelation function, the grounding resistance is estimated. This process effectively filters out noise and isolates the system's response.
  • Simulation and Experimentation: The proposed method was first simulated using LabVIEW, modeling the grounding grid as a pure resistance. This was followed by a laboratory experiment where a physical grounding resistance measurement device was built and tested.

The paper contrasts this approach with using a sinusoidal signal as the excitation, highlighting the pseudorandom signal's superior ability to separate from noise.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses simulated grounding resistance models and laboratory tests with controlled resistance values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pseudorandom Signals as a Superior Excitation: The research strongly suggests that pseudorandom signals (specifically m-sequences) are more effective than sinusoidal signals for grounding resistance measurement due to their inherent anti-interference properties. They are easier to separate from noise, leading to more stable and accurate results.
  • Correlation Identification for Noise Mitigation: The correlation identification technique, when applied with pseudorandom signals, acts as a powerful denoising mechanism. It allows for the extraction of the system's impulse response even in the presence of significant external noise.
  • Practicality of the Method: The study demonstrates that the proposed method is not only theoretically sound but also practically feasible, as validated by both simulation and laboratory experiments.
  • Efficiency Improvement: Compared to complex numerical methods (like FEM), the correlation identification approach offers a more efficient way to measure grounding resistance.

Key Results

  • Simulation Accuracy: In simulations, the pseudorandom signal method yielded grounding resistance values very close to the standard values, with error percentages generally below 0.29%, even with superimposed Gaussian white noise. In contrast, the sinusoidal signal method showed significantly higher errors (up to 2.83%) and unstable readings.
  • Laboratory Validation: The laboratory tests confirmed the simulation findings. The developed grounding resistance measurement device using the pseudorandom signal method achieved errors less than 4% compared to actual resistance values, which is within an acceptable range for practical applications.
  • Robustness to Noise: The paper highlights that the pseudorandom signal method is robust to various interferences common in substation environments, such as harmonic and Gaussian noise.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Electrode Arrangement: The paper acknowledges that in actual measurements, avoiding coupling issues between current and voltage leads requires careful electrode placement and technicians need to be mindful of underground metal and electromagnetic interference sources.
  • ADC Precision: The authors suggest that high-precision ADCs are necessary for accurate current and voltage signal collection to further enhance measurement accuracy.
  • Further Research: While not explicitly detailed as future work, the paper implies that the developed device and method can be further refined and deployed for real-world substation grounding resistance monitoring. The focus on practical implementation and the demonstration of high precision and robustness suggest a pathway for future development and adoption.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{duan2022simulation,
  author = {Qingming Duan and Bofeng Zou and Shanshan Li and Hu Zhao},
  title = {{Simulation and Experiment of Substation Grounding Resistance Measurement Based on Pseudorandom Signal}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22155777},
}

Loading related content...

Figure