Simulation Analysis of the Distance Between Tunnels at the Bridge-Tunnel Junction of Mountainous Expressway on Driving Safety Under Crosswinds

Lu Wang, Shuqi Li, Bing HuiIEEE Access 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract: To analyze the influence of the distance between tunnels at the bridge-tunnel junction in the mountainous area on the driving safety under crosswind, a vehicle dynamics model is established by Carsim software. Under the conditions of different driving speeds (60km/h, 80km/h and 100km/h), different wind scales (level 6–9) and three alignment combinations of the tunnels (tunnel-straight road-tunnel, tunnel-curving road-tunnel, tunnel-the combination of straight and curves road-tunnel), the vehicle’s lateral offset and lateral force coefficient are used as evaluation indexes to study the influence of distance between tunnels on driving safety. When the distance is small, the lateral offset and lateral force coefficient of vehicle driving on the bridge-tunnel junction increase firstly and then decrease as the distance increases. But the changes of the lateral offset and lateral force coefficient are not synchronized, and the peak value of the lateral force coefficient occurs earlier than the lateral offset. Finally, the minimum safety spacing of each condition and speed limits for different distances are proposed. Under the condition of the straight-tunnel, 20m distance between tunnels cannot ensure the driving safety when the wind scale reaches level 9, and the road should be closed. Under the conditions of the curve and the combination of straights and curves, driving safety cannot be maintained at each spacing at wind scale level 8 and 9, and the road should be closed. However, when the wind speed is level 6 or 7, speed limits can be adopted to ensure driving safety. The results suggest that vehicles’ lateral offset and lateral force coefficient can be effectively reduced by reducing the driving speed or increasing the distance between tunnels, so the risk of accidents caused by the crosswind can be reduced.

Navigating the "Black Spots": How Tunnel Spacing Impacts Driving Safety Under Crosswinds

Driving through mountainous expressways often feels like a rhythmic transition between the darkness of tunnels and the sudden glare of open bridges. While scenic, these "bridge-tunnel junctions" are notorious "black spots" for traffic accidents. A study by researchers at Chang’an University, published in IEEE Access, uses high-fidelity simulations to quantify exactly how the distance between these tunnels—and the sudden gusts of crosswinds—affects driving safety.

The Problem: Aerodynamic Transitions

In mountainous regions, bridges and tunnels constitute a significant portion of highway infrastructure. The transition zone, where a vehicle exits a sheltered tunnel onto an exposed bridge, is particularly dangerous. Here, vehicles are suddenly subjected to crosswinds that can be amplified by the local topography. Current road design specifications often lack detailed guidance on the optimal "safe distance" between consecutive tunnels under these aerodynamic stresses.

Methods: Modeling the Physics of Motion

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach to model the complex physics of a vehicle in a gale. They used Carsim software to build a high-fidelity model of a standard passenger car (a FAW-VW Jetta). Unlike simplified models, this approach accounts for 3D aerodynamic forces: lift, drag, and lateral force, along with pitching, yawing, and rolling moments.

Vehicle dynamics model showing aerodynamic forces and moments acting on the car.

To ensure the simulation was grounded in reality, the team conducted physical experiments in a wind tunnel using a 1:30 scale vehicle model to verify aerodynamic coefficients. They simulated three road alignments (straight, curved, and a combination) across various driving speeds (60, 80, and 100 km/h) and wind scales (Level 6 to 9). Safety was judged by two thresholds: a Lateral Force Coefficient ($f \le 0.4$) for instantaneous risk and a Lateral Offset ($\le 0.5m$) for cumulative lane departure risk.

Key Insights: The Acceleration Effect

One of the most critical findings involves the "acceleration effect." When tunnels are close together (e.g., 20m), the wind speed at the junction can increase by up to 33.5% due to the canyon effect. The simulation modeled the wind speed profile as a vehicle moves from the sheltered environment of a tunnel into the open junction.

Wind speed profile illustrating the sudden increase in wind speed as a vehicle enters the junction from a tunnel.

Asynchronous Risks

The study revealed that peak lateral force occurs earlier than the peak lateral offset. This means a driver might feel a sudden "jerk" before the vehicle actually drifts out of its lane, providing a very narrow window for corrective action.

The Danger of Curves

On curved bridge-tunnel junctions, centrifugal forces and crosswind forces are superimposed. The study found that at wind scales of Level 8 or 9, driving safety cannot be maintained on curves regardless of tunnel spacing, necessitating immediate road closures. Even at Level 7 wind, a 60 km/h speed limit requires at least 200m of spacing to remain safe.

Results and Safety Recommendations

The authors established definitive safety thresholds and speed limits based on their simulations. Key recommendations include:

  • Straight Roads: At Level 9 wind, a 20m gap is unsafe; the road should be closed. At 60 km/h, a minimum of 30m is required.
  • Speed Limits: Reducing driving speed or increasing tunnel distance effectively reduces risk. For example, on a straight road with a 50m gap during Level 9 winds, speed must be capped at 60 km/h.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a theoretical framework for safer expressway design in mountainous areas. By quantifying the relationship between tunnel spacing, wind intensity, and vehicle stability, engineers can better implement speed limits and road closure protocols. While focused on sedans, future work aims to include heavy vehicles like buses and trucks, which face even stricter safety requirements due to their higher centers of gravity.

Summary updated

Abstract

To analyze the influence of the distance between tunnels at the bridge-tunnel junction in the mountainous area on the driving safety under crosswind, a vehicle dynamics model is established by Carsim software. Under the conditions of different driving speeds (60km/h, 80km/h and 100km/h), different wind scales (level 6–9) and three alignment combinations of the tunnels (tunnel-straight road-tunnel, tunnel-curving road-tunnel, tunnel-the combination of straight and curves road-tunnel), the vehicle’s lateral offset and lateral force coefficient are used as evaluation indexes to study the influence of distance between tunnels on driving safety. When the distance is small, the lateral offset and lateral force coefficient of vehicle driving on the bridge-tunnel junction increase firstly and then decrease as the distance increases. But the changes of the lateral offset and lateral force coefficient are not synchronized, and the peak value of the lateral force coefficient occurs earlier than the lateral offset. Finally, the minimum safety spacing of each condition and speed limits for different distances are proposed. Under the condition of the straight-tunnel, 20m distance between tunnels cannot ensure the driving safety when the wind scale reaches level 9, and the road should be closed. Under the conditions of the curve and the combination of straights and curves, driving safety cannot be maintained at each spacing at wind scale level 8 and 9, and the road should be closed. However, when the wind speed is level 6 or 7, speed limits can be adopted to ensure driving safety. The results suggest that vehicles’ lateral offset and lateral force coefficient can be effectively reduced by reducing the driving speed or increasing the distance between tunnels, so the risk of accidents caused by the crosswind can be reduced.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021simulation,
  author = {Lu Wang and Shuqi Li and Bing Hui},
  title = {{Simulation Analysis of the Distance Between Tunnels at the Bridge-Tunnel Junction of Mountainous Expressway on Driving Safety Under Crosswinds}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ylsfDPm2mv},
}
Figure