Simulating Mold Filling in Compression Resin Transfer Molding (CRTM) Using a Three-Dimensional Finite-Volume Formulation

Julian Seuffert, Luise Kärger, Frank HenningJournal of Composites Science 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel 3D finite-volume (FV) method for simulating Compression Resin Transfer Molding (CRTM), a key process for mass-producing lightweight composite parts. The method accurately captures the complex interplay of resin flow, air entrapment, and changing mold geometry during CRTM, offering a significant advancement over existing simulation tools.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The mass production of lightweight structural components using continuous fiber reinforced plastics (CoFRP) is crucial for industries like aerospace and automotive. Resin Transfer Molding (RTM) processes, particularly Compression RTM (CRTM), offer high automation potential for this. However, optimizing CRTM for cost-efficiency and quality requires accurate numerical simulations to avoid expensive experimental trials. Traditional RTM simulations often struggle with the dynamic nature of CRTM, specifically the changing cavity height and the resulting variations in fiber volume fraction and permeability. Furthermore, existing commercial software often lacks the ability to simulate complex 3D geometries with non-constant cavity heights or to accurately model the two-phase flow (resin and air) in such dynamic scenarios. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and validating a robust 3D FV simulation method for CRTM.

Methods

The core of this work is a new three-dimensional finite-volume (FV) method implemented within the OpenFOAM framework. Key innovations include:

  • Compressible Two-Phase/Volume-of-Fluid (VoF) Description: Unlike many FE methods that treat the filled domain only, this FV approach models both the resin and air phases simultaneously using a VoF scheme. This allows for accurate tracking of the flow front and the behavior of entrapped air.
  • Moving Mesh: To account for the changing cavity height during the CRTM compression step, a dynamic mesh capability is employed. This ensures that the simulation mesh deforms to match the changing geometry, which is critical for accurately updating fiber volume fractions and, consequently, local permeabilities.
  • Integration with OpenFOAM: Leveraging the open-source nature of OpenFOAM allows for flexibility and integration into broader virtual process chains for composite manufacturing.
  • Darcy-Forchheimer Model: The porous media flow is modeled using a generalized Darcy-Forchheimer equation, which includes terms for both viscous flow and inertial effects, providing a more comprehensive description of fluid behavior in the fibrous preform.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets for training. Instead, it relies on:

  • Experimental Permeability Measurements: Permeability data for a specific unidirectional carbon fiber preform (Zoltek™ PX35UD0300) was obtained from process-oriented experiments using a unidirectional permeability test setup. This data was used to validate the material models.
  • Analytic Solutions: The developed simulation method is rigorously verified against established analytic solutions derived from Darcy's law for one-dimensional flow scenarios.
  • Commercial Software Results: Simulation results from a state-of-the-art commercial RTM mold filling software (PAM-RTM® by ESI Group) are used for comparison, particularly for injection-RTM cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Necessity of 3D FV for Complex CRTM: The paper strongly suggests that simulating CRTM for complex geometries, especially those with varying wall inclinations and embedded core materials, necessitates a full 3D approach. Simplified 2D or 2.5D methods are insufficient.
  • VoF is Crucial for Air Management: Accurately capturing the behavior of entrapped air, its compression, and dispersion is vital for predicting the final part quality and avoiding defects. The FV-VoF approach proves effective here.
  • Dynamic Mesh is Non-Negotiable for CRTM: The changing cavity height in CRTM directly impacts fiber volume fraction and permeability. The dynamic mesh approach is essential for accurately reflecting these changes and their influence on the filling process.
  • OpenFOAM as a Powerful Platform: The successful implementation and validation within OpenFOAM highlight its potential as a flexible and extensible platform for advanced composite manufacturing simulations.

Key Results

  • Accurate Verification: The simulation method demonstrated excellent agreement with analytic solutions for one-dimensional injection-RTM and compression-RTM scenarios.
  • Comparison with Commercial Software: The results from the developed FV method closely matched those from the commercial PAM-RTM® software for injection-RTM, validating its accuracy.
  • Simulation of Complex Geometries: The paper successfully simulated the mold filling of a complex part with inclined walls and a sandwich part with an embedded rigid core. These examples showcase the method's ability to handle intricate geometries and material arrangements.
  • Prediction of Flow Front Behavior: The simulations accurately predicted the flow front behavior, including delays in areas with lower permeability (e.g., inclined walls) and the impact of varying fiber volume fractions.
  • Pressure Evolution Analysis: The method accurately predicted pressure evolution at various points within the mold during both injection and compression phases, aligning well with analytic and commercial software results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Open Gap Modeling: The authors acknowledge that the current method does not explicitly model an "open gap" that can occur above the preform, especially at large mold openings during the injection stage. This is identified as a key area for future improvement.
  • Deforming Core Materials: While the current method can simulate rigid cores, extending it to handle deforming core materials is suggested as a future development.
  • Non-Constant Compression Velocities and Articulated Molds: The paper points to the potential for simulating CRTM with non-constant compression velocities and articulated molds as future applications.
  • Pressure-Controlled CRTM: The method's adaptability to simulate pressure-controlled CRTM variants by adjusting boundary conditions is also highlighted as a future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Light-weight structural components are increasingly made of continuous fiber reinforced plastics (CoFRP), but their mass production is still very expensive. Because of its high automation potential, especially the Compression Resin Transfer Molding (CRTM) process gains more and more attention. Numerical mold filling simulations help to optimize this process and can avoid expensive experimental studies. Here, we present a new method to simulate mold filling in CRTM using a full three-dimensional finite-volume (FV) method. In comparison to known finite-element (FE) methods, it contains a compressible two-phase/Volume-of-Fluid description of the air- and resin-phase. This approach is combined with a moving mesh to account for the change of cavity height during the process, which results in a change of fiber volume fractions and thus permeabilities. We verify the method by comparison to analytic solutions of the Darcy equation and to solutions of state-of-the-art mold filling simulation software. The presented method enables CRTM mold filling simulation of complex parts, which is shown in two application examples. Furthermore, this shows the potential of using FV-based tools to simulate mold filling in RTM process variants containing non-constant cavity geometries.
BibTeX
@article{seuffert2018simulating,
  author = {Julian Seuffert and Luise Kärger and Frank Henning},
  title = {{Simulating Mold Filling in Compression Resin Transfer Molding (CRTM) Using a Three-Dimensional Finite-Volume Formulation}},
  journal = {Journal of Composites Science},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/jcs2020023},
}
Figure