Simplicially driven simple contagion

Maxime Lucas, Iacopo Iacopini, Thomas Robiglio, Alain Barrat, Giovanni PetriarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In classical epidemiology, "simple" contagions, such as those described by the Susceptible-Infected-Susceptible (SIS) model, spread through independent pairwise contacts. These models typically predict a smooth, continuous transition: as the infectivity of a pathogen increases, the number of infected individuals grows gradually. However, real-world outbreaks often exhibit "abrupt" or discontinuous transitions—sudden jumps from zero to a large-scale epidemic.

While previous research has attributed these jumps to "complex" contagions (requiring multiple sources of exposure) or symmetric cooperation between two diseases, these models often overlook the asymmetric reality of human systems. For instance, a social behavior, such as refusing to wear masks, might drive the spread of a disease, but the disease itself does not necessarily drive the adoption of the behavior in the same way. This paper investigates how a "simplicial" driver (group-based social behavior) affects a "simple" (pairwise) infectious process.

Methodology: A Coupled Simplicial Framework

The researchers developed a mathematical framework for two interacting processes, $A$ and $B$, on a simplicial complex—a network structure that includes both links between pairs and "triangles" representing groups of three.

Schematic of the uni-directionally coupled simplicial contagion model showing states and transition rates.
  • Process A (The Driver): Represents a social behavior spreading as a simplicial contagion through both pairwise links and group-based "2-hyperedges" (triangles).
  • Process B (The Driven): Represents an infectious disease spreading only through standard pairwise links.
  • The Coupling: The interaction is uni-directional. Individuals who have adopted behavior $A$ are $\epsilon_{AB}$ times more likely to contract disease $B$.

The system was analyzed using Mean-Field (MF) equations and Microscopic Markov-Chain simulations on synthetic random simplicial complexes with controlled average links ($\langle k \rangle = 20$) and triangles ($\langle k_\Delta \rangle = 6$).

Key Insights: Inherited Complexity

The most striking finding is that a simple disease can "inherit" the complex behavior of its driver. Even though Process $B$ only spreads via pairwise links, it can exhibit abrupt transitions and bi-stability if the driving behavior $A$ is simplicial and the coupling strength $\epsilon_{AB}$ exceeds a critical threshold.

Comparison of disease prevalence ($\rho_{B_{tot}}^*$) under simple vs. simplicial drivers. Panels (c) and (d) highlight the emergence of bi-stability and abrupt jumps when driven by simplicial processes.

The "Hidden" Driver Problem

From an observer's perspective, a disease might appear to have intrinsic higher-order spreading mechanisms. In reality, it may simply be a pairwise disease pushed by a hidden social behavior. The authors derived an analytical expression for a critical coupling strength, $\epsilon_{AB}^c$. Below this value, the disease transition remains smooth; above it, the transition becomes discontinuous, meaning a marginal increase in infectivity can trigger a massive, sudden outbreak.

Bi-stability and Initial Conditions

In the bi-stable regime, the final epidemic state depends heavily on the initial adoption level of the social behavior. Two identical populations could experience vastly different outcomes based solely on the starting prevalence of the "risky" behavior.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that the nature of an epidemic's phase transition is not solely a property of the pathogen but can be fundamentally altered by the dynamics of its social drivers. While this study focused on uni-directional coupling, real-world systems often involve feedback loops where outbreaks eventually alter behavior.

Future work aims to apply this framework to real-world time-series data to detect the "footprints" of hidden drivers in historical epidemics. Developing tools for the full reconstruction of underlying network structures and contagion types from observed data remains a primary goal for improving public health monitoring and intervention strategies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lucas2022simplicially,
  author = {Maxime Lucas and Iacopo Iacopini and Thomas Robiglio and Alain Barrat and Giovanni Petri},
  title = {{Simplicially driven simple contagion}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.07645},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.07645},
}
Figure