Simplex free adaptive tree fast sweeping and evolution methods for solving level set equations in arbitrary dimension

Thomas C. Cecil, Stanley J. Osher, Jianliang QianJournal of Computational Physics 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "simplex-free" adaptive tree method for solving complex level set equations in arbitrary dimensions. By leveraging a generalized binary tree structure and a fast sweeping strategy, the method achieves high accuracy and efficiency without the need for complicated n-dimensional triangulations, making it adaptable to a wide range of dimensions with minimal code changes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Level set methods are powerful tools for tracking interfaces and solving partial differential equations (PDEs) that arise in various scientific and engineering fields, such as fluid dynamics, image processing, and material science. A key challenge in these methods, especially in higher dimensions, is the computational cost associated with representing and updating the interface. Traditional methods often require complex data structures and numerical schemes, particularly when dealing with adaptive meshes that refine resolution near the interface. Existing tree-based methods, while offering adaptivity, often rely on n-dimensional simplices for interpolation, which becomes computationally prohibitive and complex in higher dimensions. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing an adaptive tree-based method that is "simplex-free," efficient, and easily scalable to arbitrary dimensions.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a simplex-free adaptive tree numerical method. Instead of using complex n-dimensional triangulations, the method employs a generalized binary tree (like quadtrees or octrees) as its data structure. This tree stores the level set function values at the centers of hypercube cells.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Simplex-Free Interpolation: The method avoids n-dimensional simplices by defining interpolation rules based on local cell configurations. When a cell needs to be split or its neighbors are of different sizes, interpolation is performed using weighted averages of neighboring cell values. This is achieved through a few well-defined cases that are dimension-independent.
  • Local Numerical Hamiltonians: The paper adapts standard numerical Hamiltonians (like Godunov Hamiltonian - GH, Osher-Sethian Hamiltonian - OSH, and Lax-Friedrichs Hamiltonian - LFH) for use with the tree structure. These Hamiltonians are designed to be monotone and consistent, ensuring convergence. The Lax-Friedrichs Hamiltonian is highlighted for its simplicity as it avoids nonlinear inversions.
  • Fast Sweeping Strategy: The method integrates a fast sweeping strategy, which involves sweeping through the grid in multiple directions. The tree structure allows for a custom sweeping order, utilizing preorder traversals of the tree. This strategy, combined with the adaptive grid, significantly speeds up convergence.
  • Adaptive Refinement and Coarsening: The tree structure naturally supports adaptive refinement (adding more detail where needed) and coarsening (reducing detail where not needed). The paper details how these operations are performed while maintaining monotonicity and consistency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on numerical methods and presents results for synthetic problems designed to test the method's capabilities in various dimensions and for different types of PDEs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dimension Independence is Achievable: The most striking insight is that by carefully designing interpolation rules based on local cell configurations and using a generalized binary tree, the complexity of handling arbitrary dimensions can be significantly reduced. The same core algorithms and code can be applied across different dimensions with minimal modification.
  • "Simplex-Free" is a Game Changer: Eliminating the need for n-dimensional simplices for interpolation is a major simplification. This avoids the combinatorial explosion of cases and the complexity of geometric computations that plague traditional adaptive methods in high dimensions.
  • Fast Sweeping on Trees is Efficient: Combining the adaptive tree structure with the fast sweeping method provides a powerful synergy. The tree's inherent structure allows for efficient traversal and data access, while the fast sweeping strategy accelerates the convergence of the numerical solution.
  • Monotonicity and Consistency are Preserved: The paper emphasizes that the proposed methods maintain monotonicity and consistency, which are crucial for the convergence of numerical schemes for Hamilton-Jacobi equations. This is achieved through careful design of the local Hamiltonians and interpolation schemes.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the method's effectiveness across various scenarios:

  • Arbitrary Dimensions: The method was successfully applied to problems in up to n=7 dimensions.
  • Codimension-1, -2, and -n Problems: Numerical results are presented for static and time-dependent problems involving interfaces of different codimensions.
  • Eikonal Equation: For the eikonal equation |∇φ| = 1, the method shows good convergence and adaptivity, with the number of sweeps needed to reach a stopping criterion stagnating rather than increasing linearly with dimension. For example, in 5D, 30 sweeps were needed, in 6D, 35, and in 7D, 32.
  • Time-Dependent Problems: The method accurately simulates constant motion in a normal direction and mean curvature motion, showing good convergence rates across different dimensions.
  • Memory and Time Savings: For a codimension-2 problem, the tree-based method achieved significant memory reduction compared to a uniform grid (34,929 nodes vs. 2,097,152 nodes). The time complexity was also estimated to be significantly lower, potentially by a factor of 5 if adaptation is performed at every time step.
  • Wulff Crystal Shapes: The method was used to simulate the formation of Wulff crystal shapes, demonstrating its ability to handle complex, non-convex Hamiltonians and anisotropic surface tensions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Adaptation Strategy: The authors acknowledge that the adaptation strategy used in some examples (based on distance to a fixed point) is not optimal for minimizing global error in all norms. They suggest that future work should focus on developing better adaptation strategies.
  • Higher-Order Accuracy: While the current method uses standard numerical Hamiltonians, future work could explore improving accuracy by incorporating WENO (Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory) type reconstructions.
  • Extension to Other PDEs: The authors believe the method could be extended to other problems requiring adaptive meshes and function interpolation/reconstruction, including higher-order nonlinear PDEs like "Willmore flows."
  • Optimal Tree-Specific Sweeping: The paper suggests that designing optimal tree-specific sweeping methods by reordering nodes could further improve efficiency.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{cecil2006simplex,
  author = {Thomas C. Cecil and Stanley J. Osher and Jianliang Qian},
  title = {{Simplex free adaptive tree fast sweeping and evolution methods for solving level set equations in arbitrary dimension}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcp.2005.08.020},
}

Loading related content...

Figure