Silp_nlp at SemEval-2023 Task 2: Cross-lingual Knowledge Transfer for Mono-lingual Learning

Sumit Singh, Uma TiwaryACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of Named Entity Recognition (NER) for multiple languages and complex entity types within the SemEval-2023 Task 2. The team "silp_nlp" developed a two-stage cross-lingual transfer learning approach using pre-trained transformer models (Muril and XLM-R) to improve performance on individual, mono-lingual tracks. Their method achieved top-10 rankings in four languages, demonstrating the effectiveness of leveraging knowledge from a diverse set of languages.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the complex task of Multilingual Complex Named Entity Recognition (MultiCoNER II), which involves identifying and classifying named entities across various languages and domains. This task is particularly challenging due to:

  • Fine-grained entity taxonomy: Over 30 distinct entity types, making precise classification difficult.
  • Multilingual nature: Requiring models to perform well across 12 different languages.
  • Noisy test data: The test sets were intentionally corrupted with simulated errors, mimicking real-world data imperfections.
  • Limited training data for some languages: Certain languages had significantly less training data than others, posing a challenge for model generalization.

The core problem is how to effectively transfer knowledge learned from a broad set of languages and entity types to improve performance on individual, mono-lingual NER tasks, especially when data is scarce or noisy.

Methods

The "silp_nlp" team employed a two-stage training strategy, inspired by previous cross-lingual transfer learning approaches:

  1. Stage 1: Multi-lingual Checkpoint Construction:
    • They utilized powerful pre-trained transformer models with strong cross-lingual capabilities: Muril (for Indic and English languages) and XLM-R (for a broader range of languages).
  2. These models were fine-tuned on a combined dataset of all 11 mono-lingual tracks. This stage aims to create a "checkpoint" that encapsulates knowledge from multiple languages and entity types.
  3. The training was conducted for 10 epochs, and the best checkpoint was selected based on average validation loss.
  4. Stage 2: Fine-tuning on Individual Mono-lingual Tracks:
    • The multi-lingual checkpoint generated in Stage 1 was then used as the initial model for fine-tuning each mono-lingual track individually.
  5. This stage involved training with different hyperparameters for each specific track, optimizing for the validation loss of that track.

This approach leverages the idea that a model trained on a diverse set of languages can learn generalizable linguistic patterns and entity recognition strategies that can then be adapted to improve performance on individual languages.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the MultiCoNER II dataset, which was provided for SemEval-2023 Task 2. This dataset consists of:

  • 12 mono-lingual tracks: Covering languages like Hindi, Bangla, English, German, Spanish, French, Italian, Portuguese, Swedish, Ukrainian, and Chinese.
  • Coarse-grained entities: Six broad categories (person, location, group, product, medical, creative work).
  • Fine-grained entities: Over 30 specific sub-types within the coarse-grained categories.
  • Multi-language data: Encouraging cross-lingual approaches.
  • Noisy test sets: Created by adding simulated errors to the original test data.

The paper also mentions using data from previous SemEval tasks (e.g., MultiCoNER v2) as context for their work.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cross-lingual transfer is powerful: The core insight is that training a model on a diverse set of languages (even if the ultimate goal is mono-lingual performance) significantly enhances its ability to recognize entities in individual languages.
  • Two-stage training is effective: The proposed two-stage approach (global multi-lingual training followed by individual fine-tuning) is a robust strategy for knowledge transfer.
  • Model choice matters: The choice between Muril and XLM-R had a noticeable impact on performance, with Muril showing an advantage for Hindi and Bangla, while XLM-R was better for English. This highlights the importance of selecting models pre-trained on relevant language families.
  • Coarse-grained entities are easier: The results indicate that models generally perform better on coarse-grained entity recognition than on fine-grained entities, suggesting that distinguishing subtle differences between fine-grained types is a greater challenge.
  • Noisy data impacts performance: As expected, the models performed worse on the intentionally noisy test data compared to clean data, underscoring the need for robust models that can handle imperfect inputs.

Key Results

The "silp_nlp" team achieved competitive results, securing top-10 rankings in four of the 11 mono-lingual tracks:

  • Hindi: 7th rank with a macro F1 score of 74.32% (achieved with the Muril setup).
  • Bangla: 9th rank with a macro F1 score of 73.22% (achieved with the Muril setup).
  • The system also secured top-10 positions in two other languages, though specific ranks are not detailed for those.

The paper also highlights that their two-stage approach showed improvement over baseline models that were only fine-tuned on individual languages.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Confusion with "OtherLOC": The entity-wise evaluation revealed that the model struggled with the "OtherLOC" entity, often confusing it with other Location entities. This suggests a need for more specific disambiguation strategies for such ambiguous categories.
  • Noisy Data Robustness: The performance drop on noisy data indicates that the training data, while structured, was not augmented to specifically improve robustness against noise.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to explore more language models to further leverage their knowledge for NER and other NLP tasks. They also aim to investigate methods for improving robustness against noisy data and better handling of ambiguous entity types.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{singh2023silp,
  author = {Sumit Singh and Uma Tiwary},
  title = {{Silp\_nlp at SemEval-2023 Task 2: Cross-lingual Knowledge Transfer for Mono-lingual Learning}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure