Significant Unconventional Anomalous Hall Effect in Heavy Metal/Antiferromagnetic Insulator Heterostructures

Yuhan Liang, Liang Wu, Minyi Dai, Yujun Zhang, Qinghua Zhang, Jie Wang, Nian Zhang, Wei Xu, Le Zhao, Hetian Chen, Ji Ma, Jialu Wu, Yanwei Cao, Di Yi, Wanjun Jiang, Jia‐Mian Hu, Ce‐Wen Nan, Yuanhua LinarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The anomalous Hall effect (AHE) is a quantum coherent transport phenomenon that conventionally vanishes at elevated temperatures because of thermal dephasing. Therefore, it is puzzling that the AHE can survive in heavy metal (HM)/antiferromagnetic (AFM) insulator (AFMI) heterostructures at high temperatures yet disappears at low temperatures. In this paper, we report that an unconventional high-temperature AHE in HM/AFMI is observed only around the Néel temperature of AFM, with large anomalous Hall resistivity up to 40 n$Ω$ cm. This mechanism is attributed to the emergence of a noncollinear AFM spin texture with a non-zero net topological charge. Atomistic spin dynamics simulation shows that such a unique spin texture can be stabilized by the subtle interplay among the collinear AFM exchange coupling, interfacial Dyzaloshinski-Moriya interaction, thermal fluctuation, and bias magnetic field.

Introduction

The Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE)—a transverse voltage drop induced by an electric current in a magnetic material—is a cornerstone of spintronics. Traditionally, AHE is associated with ferromagnets. In antiferromagnets (AFMs), where neighboring spins cancel each other out, the net magnetization is zero, and AHE is conventionally expected to vanish.

However, recent experiments on certain AFM insulators, such as $Cr_2O_3$, have revealed a puzzling "high-temperature AHE" that appears near the Néel temperature ($T_N$) but vanishes at low temperatures. This behavior contradicts standard quantum transport theory, where thermal fluctuations typically destroy the coherence required for AHE. This study clarifies the mechanism behind this phenomenon using NiO, an antiferromagnetic insulator with a high $T_N$, demonstrating that the effect is driven by thermally-stabilized topological spin textures rather than simple proximity-induced ferromagnetism.

Experimental Observation of High-Temperature AHE

Researchers fabricated ultrathin (1–7 unit cells) epitaxial NiO films on MgO substrates using Pulsed Laser Deposition (PLD), capped with heavy metals such as Platinum (Pt) or Tungsten (W). Transport measurements were conducted from 5 K to 400 K to isolate the AHE component from the ordinary Hall signal.

Structural characterization and transport measurements of Pt/NiO/MgO heterostructures. (a) Cross-sectional TEM image. (b) Field-dependent Hall resistivity at various temperatures for a 3 uc NiO film. (c, d) Color maps showing the dependence of AHE on temperature and layer thickness.

A significant anomalous Hall resistivity ($\rho_{AHE}$) reaching approximately 40 n$Ω$ cm was observed in Pt(3 nm)/NiO(3 uc)/MgO(001) samples. As shown in Figure 1, the AHE signal is strongest between 250 K and 400 K, disappearing entirely below 200 K. This "Goldilocks" temperature dependence is highly sensitive to the NiO thickness; the effect is prominent only in ultrathin films (under 6 unit cells), where the bulk AFM order is sufficiently flexible to allow interfacial spin twisting.

To rule out simple Spin Hall Magnetoresistance (SMR) or proximity effects, the authors tested heterostructures with Tungsten (W), which has a Spin Hall Angle opposite to that of Platinum. The sign of the AHE remained consistent, pointing toward a more complex interfacial origin. Furthermore, the effect was observed on both MgO(001) and MgO(111) substrates, suggesting it is an intrinsic property of the HM/AFMI interface.

Mechanism: Thermally Driven Topological Spin Textures

The emergence of AHE specifically during the AFM-to-paramagnetic phase transition suggests a mechanism linked to magnetic fluctuations. The authors employed X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS) at the Ni $L_2$ edge to track the magnetic state of the NiO films as a function of temperature.

Correlation between the magnetic phase transition and the emergence of the AHE. (a) XAS spectra showing the transition from AFM to paramagnetic states. (b) Schematic illustrating how AHE peaks near $T_N$ due to the formation of noncollinear spin textures with non-zero topological charge.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the AHE does not exist when the NiO is a rigid antiferromagnet (low T) or a fully disordered paramagnet (very high T). Near $T_N$, the AFM order "softens," allowing the interfacial Dyzaloshinski-Moriya interaction (DMI) to compete with exchange coupling. Atomistic spin dynamics simulations confirm that this interplay, combined with thermal fluctuations and an external bias field, creates noncollinear spin textures (such as skyrmions or merons). These textures carry a non-zero net topological charge, which acts as an effective magnetic field for conduction electrons in the heavy metal, generating the observed AHE.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates a robust, unconventional AHE in HM/AFMI heterostructures that is driven by thermally-induced topological spin textures. The discovery that these textures can be stabilized at high temperatures in common materials like NiO opens new avenues for AFM spintronics. Future research will explore the electrical control of these topological charges, potentially leading to high-speed, energy-efficient memory and logic devices that operate at or above room temperature.

Summary updated

Abstract

The anomalous Hall effect (AHE) is a quantum coherent transport phenomenon that conventionally vanishes at elevated temperatures because of thermal dephasing. Therefore, it is puzzling that the AHE can survive in heavy metal (HM)/antiferromagnetic (AFM) insulator (AFMI) heterostructures at high temperatures yet disappears at low temperatures. In this paper, we report that an unconventional high-temperature AHE in HM/AFMI is observed only around the Néel temperature of AFM, with large anomalous Hall resistivity up to 40 n$Ω$ cm. This mechanism is attributed to the emergence of a noncollinear AFM spin texture with a non-zero net topological charge. Atomistic spin dynamics simulation shows that such a unique spin texture can be stabilized by the subtle interplay among the collinear AFM exchange coupling, interfacial Dyzaloshinski-Moriya interaction, thermal fluctuation, and bias magnetic field.
BibTeX
@misc{liang2023significant,
  author = {Yuhan Liang and Liang Wu and Minyi Dai and Yujun Zhang and Qinghua Zhang and Jie Wang and Nian Zhang and Wei Xu and Le Zhao and Hetian Chen and Ji Ma and Jialu Wu and Yanwei Cao and Di Yi and Jing Ma and Wanjun Jiang and Jia‐Mian Hu and Ce‐Wen Nan and Yuanhua Lin},
  title = {{Significant Unconventional Anomalous Hall Effect in Heavy Metal/Antiferromagnetic Insulator Heterostructures}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2301.05486},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05486},
}
Figure