Significant chlorine emissions from biomass burning affect the long-term atmospheric chemistry in Asia

Di Chang, Qinyi Li, Zhe Wang, Jianing Dai, Xiao Fu, Jia Guo, Lei Zhu, Dongchuan Pu, Carlos A. Cuevas, Rafael P. Fernández, Weigang Wang, Maofa Ge, Jimmy Chi Hung Fung, Alexis K.h. Lau, Claire Granier, Guy Brasseur, Andrea Pozzer, Alfonso Saiz‐Lopez, Yu Song, Tao WangNational 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper quantifies for the first time the significant long-term emissions of chlorine from biomass burning (BB) in Asia and their impact on atmospheric chemistry. By developing a novel, high-resolution emission inventory and integrating it into a global chemistry-climate model, the study reveals that BB is a major, previously underestimated source of reactive chlorine, significantly influencing atmospheric oxidants and air quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While biomass burning (BB) is recognized as a major source of atmospheric pollutants like carbon and nitrogen compounds, its contribution to chlorine emissions has been largely overlooked. Reactive chlorine chemistry plays a crucial role in atmospheric processes, affecting air quality, radiative balance, and climate by influencing the concentrations of key species like ozone and hydroxyl radicals. However, a lack of quantitative data on long-term chlorine emissions from BB, especially in rapidly developing regions like Asia, has hindered a comprehensive understanding of its atmospheric impact. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by providing a detailed, long-term emission inventory of chlorine compounds from BB in Asia and assessing their atmospheric consequences.

Methods

The researchers developed a high-resolution (500 m) emission inventory for chlorine-containing compounds (HCl, chloride, and CH<sub>3</sub>Cl) from open biomass burning in Asia for the period 2001-2018. This inventory was constructed by combining satellite observations of burned areas with emission factors (EFs), fuel loads (FLs), and combustion factors (CFs). The EFs were derived from vegetation-specific local measurements, offering a more accurate representation than previous global uniform data.

To assess the atmospheric impact, this new emission inventory was incorporated into the global chemistry-climate model CAM-Chem. The model was run under various scenarios: "noBB" (without BB or anthropogenic emissions), "BB" (with BB but without anthropogenic emissions), "noBB_ANT" (without BB but with anthropogenic emissions for 2014), and "BB_ANT" (with both BB and anthropogenic emissions for 2014). This allowed for the isolation and quantification of the effects of BB-derived chlorine.

Datasets

  • MODIS burned area product (MCD64A1 version 6): Used to produce 500 m resolution burned area maps.
  • MODIS Land Cover Type Product (MCD12Q1): Used for land cover information.
  • Fuel load (FL) data: Derived from aboveground biomass (AGB) density.
  • Emission factors (EFs): Obtained from vegetation-specific local measurements in the study regions.
  • Anthropogenic chlorine emissions: Data from Fu et al. [30] were used for the "noBB_ANT" and "BB_ANT" scenarios.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilizes existing satellite products and local measurement data to construct a novel emission inventory.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biomass burning is a major, overlooked source of atmospheric chlorine: The study unequivocally demonstrates that BB is a significant contributor to atmospheric chlorine, a fact that has been underappreciated in previous research.
  • Asia is a key region for BB-derived chlorine emissions: The developed inventory highlights Asia as a hotspot for these emissions, with specific regions like China, Myanmar, and India being major contributors.
  • Chlorine from BB significantly impacts atmospheric oxidants: The model simulations show that BB-chlorine emissions lead to substantial increases in reactive chlorine species, which in turn alter the concentrations of crucial oxidants like ozone (O<sub>3</sub>) and hydroxyl radicals (OH). This suggests BB plays a more active role in atmospheric chemistry than previously thought.
  • BB-chlorine's influence is complex and region-specific: The study reveals that the impact of BB-chlorine on oxidants can be positive or negative depending on the altitude and local atmospheric conditions (e.g., NOx and VOC concentrations, relative humidity, temperature).
  • Future projections indicate a growing importance of BB-chlorine: With projected increases in BB activity and potential decreases in anthropogenic emissions, BB-chlorine is expected to become even more critical for atmospheric composition in the future.

Key Results

  • Average chlorine emissions from BB in Asia: Estimated at 730 Gg yr<sup>-1</sup>, with significant interannual variability (240-1083 Gg yr<sup>-1</sup>) between 2001 and 2018.
  • Top contributing countries: China (24.2%, 177 Gg Cl yr<sup>-1</sup>), Myanmar (18.7%), and India (18.3%).
  • Regional hotspots: Identified in Northeast China (NEC), North China Plain (NCP), South Asia (SA), Indochina (IC), and Indonesia (INDO), accounting for 81% of Asian BB-Cl emissions.
  • Impact on HCl and CH<sub>3</sub>Cl levels: Elevated monthly averages up to 2062 pptv for HCl and 1421 pptv for CH<sub>3</sub>Cl.
  • Impact on oxidants: Noticeable changes in O<sub>3</sub> (up to 3.1% increase) and OH radicals (up to 17% increase).
  • CINO<sub>2</sub> increase: Simulated increases of 10 to 60 pptv, with a maximum of 1200 pptv in monthly concentrations.
  • Surface O<sub>3</sub> impact: Mild increases (1.63% ± 0.87% in NEC, 1.56% ± 0.43% in NCP, etc.), but negative effects in the free troposphere and stratosphere.
  • OH radical impact: Significant monthly changes, reaching up to 17% in NEC in November 2015.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model uncertainties: While the CAM-Chem model was validated against observations, uncertainties inherent in global chemistry-climate models remain. The paper notes that the effects of BB-Cl on O<sub>3</sub> were larger in regions with higher NOx and VOC concentrations, and a negative correlation was found between OH changes and temperature, highlighting the complexity of these interactions.
  • Data limitations for certain regions: The paper points out that while simulated CINO<sub>2</sub> was elevated in SA and IC regions, no direct measurements are available for these areas, calling for more field studies.
  • CH<sub>3</sub>Cl's long-term impact: The study acknowledges that CH<sub>3</sub>Cl, a long-lived chlorine species, also affects upper tropospheric and lower stratospheric ozone, with a projected impact of approximately -0.25% O<sub>3</sub> mixing ratio changes above 400 hPa.
  • Future projections: The authors project future BB-Cl emissions under different Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) scenarios, suggesting that BB-Cl levels might remain similar to current levels under SSP1-2.6 and SSP2-4.5 but could significantly increase under SSP5-8.5, particularly in SA and the NCP.
  • Need for in-situ observations: The paper emphasizes the need for more in-situ observations to refine the understanding of BB-derived Cl sources and their atmospheric impacts.
  • Integrated policy implications: The authors stress that failure to account for BB-Cl in air pollution mitigation policies could lead to underestimation of required reductions in anthropogenic sources. Future investigations should focus on identifying and quantifying Cl emissions from BB to better understand its role in shaping atmospheric chemistry, air pollution, and climate.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biomass burning (BB) is a major source of trace gases and particles in the atmosphere, influencing air quality, radiative balance, and climate. Previous studies have mainly focused on the BB emissions of carbon and nitrogen species with less attention on chlorine. Reactive chlorine chemistry has significant effects on atmospheric chemistry and air quality. However, quantitative information on chlorine emissions from BB, particularly the long-term trend and associated atmospheric impacts, is limited both on regional and global scales. Here, we report a long-term (2001-2018) high-resolution BB emission inventory for the major chlorine-containing compounds (HCl, chloride, and CH<sub>3</sub>Cl) in Asia based on satellite observations. We estimate an average of 730 Gg yr<sup>-1</sup> chlorine emitted from BB activity in Asia, with China contributing the largest share at 24.2% (177 Gg yr<sup>-1</sup>), followed by Myanmar at 18.7% and India at 18.3%. Distinct seasonal patterns and significant spatial and interannual variability are observed, mainly driven by human-mediated changes in agricultural activity. By incorporating the newly developed chlorine emission inventory into a global chemistry-climate model (CAM-Chem), we find that the BB-chlorine emissions lead to elevated levels of HCl and CH<sub>3</sub>Cl (monthly average up to 2062 and 1421 parts per trillion by volume (pptv), respectively), subsequently resulting in noticeable changes in oxidants (up to 3.1% in O<sub>3</sub> and 17% in OH radicals). The results demonstrate that BB is not only a significant source of air pollutants but also of oxidants, suggesting a larger role of BB emissions in the atmospheric chemistry and oxidation process than previously appreciated. In light of the projected increase in BB activity toward the end of the century and the extensive control of anthropogenic emissions worldwide, the contribution of BB emissions may become fundamental to air quality composition in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chang2024significant,
  author = {Di Chang and Qinyi Li and Zhe Wang and Jianing Dai and Xiao Fu and Jia Guo and Lei Zhu and Dongchuan Pu and Carlos A. Cuevas and Rafael P. Fernández and Weigang Wang and Maofa Ge and Jimmy Chi Hung Fung and Alexis K.H. Lau and Claire Granier and Guy Brasseur and Andrea Pozzer and Alfonso Saiz‐Lopez and Yu Song and Tao Wang},
  title = {{Significant chlorine emissions from biomass burning affect the long-term atmospheric chemistry in Asia}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwae285},
}
Figure