Significance of Gradient Information in Bayesian Optimization

Shubhanshu Shekhar, Tara JavidiAISTATS 2021 · OpenReview

Abstract

In Bayesian Optimization (BO), the objective is to design an adaptive strategy to optimize a function $f:[0,1]^d \to \mathbb{R}$ sampled from a Gaussian Process. While standard BO relies on a Zeroth-Order Oracle (ZOO) providing noisy function values, this paper investigates the advantages of a First-Order Oracle (FOO) that also provides noisy gradients. We prove that any ZOO-based algorithm faces a cumulative regret lower bound of $\Omega(\sqrt{2^d n})$, illustrating a significant curse of dimensionality. In contrast, we introduce a two-phase algorithm for FOO access that achieves a regret of $\mathcal{O}(d (\log n)^2)$. These results quantify the exponential value of gradient information in accelerating convergence within BO frameworks.

Introduction

Bayesian Optimization (BO) is the standard paradigm for optimizing expensive, black-box functions where evaluations are limited. Traditionally, BO algorithms operate under the assumption of a Zeroth-Order Oracle (ZOO), receiving only noisy function values $y = f(x) + \eta$. However, in many modern machine learning contexts—such as those utilizing automatic differentiation—noisy gradients $\nabla f(x) + \xi$ are also available.

This paper provides a rigorous theoretical foundation for the "value of information" provided by these gradients. By establishing fundamental limits for both ZOO and First-Order Oracle (FOO) settings, the authors demonstrate that gradients allow algorithms to bypass the traditional curse of dimensionality that plagues value-only optimization.

The Fundamental Limits of Zeroth-Order BO

A primary contribution of this work is the establishment of a tighter, algorithm-independent lower bound for ZOO. By employing a novel reduction from BO to a multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem, the authors prove that for any ZOO-based strategy, the expected cumulative regret $R_n$ must satisfy:

$$R_n = \Omega(\sqrt{2^d n})$$

where $d$ is the dimension and $n$ is the query budget. This result confirms that without gradient information, the difficulty of finding an optimum increases exponentially with the number of dimensions, making high-dimensional BO inherently inefficient.

AlgFOO: Exploiting First-Order Information

To demonstrate how gradients can overcome these limits, the authors propose AlgFOO, a two-phase optimization strategy:

  1. Phase 1: Zooming. The algorithm initially employs a standard ZOO strategy (such as GP-UCB) to locate a "near-optimal" region. This phase continues until the algorithm enters a neighborhood where the function can be locally approximated as a quadratic.
  2. Phase 2: Refining. Once inside the target region, the algorithm switches to a gradient-based refinement. Because the FOO provides noisy gradients, AlgFOO uses a RepeatQuery subroutine. This mechanism repeatedly samples the gradient at the same point to compute an average estimate, ensuring the variance is low enough to guarantee that each step moves closer to the global optimum.

Theoretical and Empirical Performance

The theoretical analysis of AlgFOO reveals a dramatic improvement in regret scaling. Assuming the global optimizer lies in the interior of the search space, the algorithm achieves:

$$R_n = \mathcal{O}(d (\log n)^2)$$

This shift from exponential/polynomial growth (in ZOO) to logarithmic growth (in FOO) relative to the query budget $n$ represents a massive theoretical gain.

Empirical Validation

The authors validated these findings using a heuristic version of the algorithm, AlgFOO-h, on standard benchmarks:

  • Himmelblau Function: A multi-modal landscape used to test global search capabilities.
  • Booth Function: A quadratic-like function used to evaluate local convergence speed.

In these experiments, the gradient-aware heuristic consistently outperformed the standard GP-UCB baseline in terms of mean and median regret, although it exhibited higher variance across trials.

Key Insights

  • Gradients as a Shortcut: In a ZOO setting, an algorithm must "probe" the surrounding space to infer the direction of the maximum. A FOO provides this direction directly, allowing for geometric convergence once the algorithm is sufficiently localized.
  • The Importance of the Interior: The logarithmic regret bound is contingent on the optimizer being in the interior of the domain. If the optimum lies on the boundary, the gradient does not necessarily vanish, which alters the convergence dynamics and requires different theoretical treatment.

Conclusion

This research quantifies the significant advantage of incorporating first-order information into Bayesian Optimization. By proving an exponential gap in cumulative regret between ZOO and FOO, the authors provide a compelling theoretical argument for the development of gradient-aware BO tools. While AlgFOO currently requires prior knowledge of certain function constants, it paves the way for future practical algorithms that can achieve logarithmic regret in high-dimensional optimization tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of Bayesian Optimization (BO) in which the goal is to design an adaptive querying strategy to optimize a function $f:[0,1]^d\mapsto \reals$. The function is assumed to be drawn from a Gaussian Process, and can only be accessed through noisy oracle queries. The most commonly used oracle in BO literature is the noisy Zeroth-Order-Oracle (ZOO) which returns noise-corrupted function value $y = f(x) + \eta$ at any point $x \in \domain$ queried by the agent. A less studied oracle in BO is the First-Order-Oracle (FOO) which also returns noisy gradient value at the queried point. In this paper we consider the fundamental question of quantifying the possible improvement in regret that can be achieved under FOO access as compared to the case in which only ZOO access is available. Under some regularity assumptions on $K$, we first show that the expected cumulative regret with ZOO of any algorithm must satisfy a lower bound of $\Omega(\sqrt{2^d n})$, where $n$ is the query budget. This lower bound captures the appropriate scaling of the regret on both dimension $d$ and budget $n$, and relies on a novel reduction from BO to a multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem. We then propose a two-phase algorithm which, with some additional prior knowledge, achieves a vastly improved $\mc{O}\lp d (\log n)^2 \rp$ regret when given access to a FOO. Together, these two results highlight the significant value of incorporating gradient information in BO algorithms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shekhar2021significance,
  author = {Shubhanshu Shekhar and Tara Javidi},
  title = {{Significance of Gradient Information in Bayesian Optimization}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8cpPO7lkcyG},
}
Figure