Signatures of coherent electronic quasiparticles in the paramagnetic Mott insulator

Mats Granath, Johan SchöttPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We study the Mott insulating state of the half-filled paramagnetic Hubbard model within dynamical mean field theory using a recently formulated stochastic and nonperturbative quantum impurity solver. The method is based on calculating the impurity self energy as a sample average over a representative distribution of impurity models solved by exact diagonalization. Due to the natural parallelization of the method, millions of poles are readily generated for the self energy which allows us to work with very small pole-broadening $\eta$. Solutions at small and large $\eta$ are qualitatively different; solutions at large $\eta$ show featureless Hubbard bands whereas solutions at small $\eta \le 0.001$ (in units of half bare band width) show a band of electronic quasiparticles with very small quasiparticle weight at the inner edge of the Hubbard bands. The validity of the results are supported by agreement within statistical error $\sigma_{\text{QMC}} \sim 10^{-4}$ on the imaginary frequency axis with calculations using a continuous time quantum Monte Carlo solver. Nevertheless, convergence with respect to finite size of the stochastic exact diagonalization solver remains to be rigourously established.

Introduction: The Mott Insulator Paradox

In condensed matter physics, the Mott insulator presents a classic paradox: according to standard band theory, these materials should be metals, yet strong electron-electron interactions lock electrons in place, rendering them insulators. The prevailing view has been that Mott insulators lack the coherent, electron-like excitations known as "quasiparticles" found in metals, instead exhibiting broad, featureless "Hubbard bands" separated by an energy gap.

Capturing the fine details of these bands is notoriously difficult. Most numerical tools, such as Dynamical Mean Field Theory (DMFT), rely on solvers that either lack the resolution to detect sharp features or operate on the imaginary frequency axis, requiring a "blurry" mathematical translation to real-world observables. This study investigates whether higher numerical resolution reveals a more complex structure at the gap's edge.

Methodology: Distributional Exact Diagonalization (Dist-ED)

The researchers employed a relatively new technique called Distributional Exact Diagonalization (Dist-ED) within the DMFT framework. Instead of solving a single, massive impurity model, Dist-ED solves millions of small, stochastically generated impurity models using exact diagonalization.

Because the method is highly parallelizable, the team generated over $10^8$ poles for the self-energy. This allowed for an extremely small broadening parameter ($\eta \le 0.001$), providing a level of spectral resolution that traditional methods struggle to achieve. The results were cross-checked against Continuous-Time Quantum Monte Carlo (CT-QMC) data on the imaginary frequency axis to ensure physical accuracy.

Key Results: Resolution and the Discovery of Sharp Peaks

The most striking finding is that the perceived featureless nature of Hubbard bands is largely a consequence of numerical broadening. At standard levels of numerical "blurring" ($\eta = 0.1$), the bands appear smooth. However, at $\eta = 0.001$, sharp peaks emerge at the inner edges of the Hubbard bands.

Comparison of the spectral function $A(\omega)$ and self-energy $\Sigma(\omega)$ at high ($\eta=0.001$) and low ($\eta=0.1$) resolution. Sharp peaks emerge at the gap edges in the high-resolution limit.

For an interaction strength of $U=4$, the local density of states shows narrow bands at the gap edge, distinct from the broad incoherent background. The Dist-ED results matched CT-QMC data with a statistical error of only $\sigma \sim 10^{-4}$, providing strong evidence that these real-frequency peaks are physical realities rather than numerical noise.

Physical Insight: Quasiparticles at the Gap Edge

The study identifies actual quasiparticle solutions at the inner edges of the Hubbard bands. A quasiparticle exists where the real part of the self-energy cancels out the energy terms, a condition the authors visualized by examining the intersection of $\omega - \text{Re}\Sigma$ with the quasiparticle condition.

Zoom-in of the gap edge showing the intersection of $\omega - \text{Re}\Sigma$ (blue) with the quasiparticle condition (black line), which coincides with the sharp spectral peak (purple).

While the calculated quasiparticle weight is small ($Z \approx 1/25$), it indicates that a finite fraction of the electron's identity remains coherent at the band edge. These features are not mathematical artifacts; they are iteratively enhanced during the DMFT self-consistency cycle, representing a genuinely non-perturbative effect of electron correlation.

Limitations and Future Work

The study utilized small impurity clusters ($n_s = 3, 5, 7$ levels). While results were qualitatively consistent, rigorous convergence for an infinite bath ($n_s \to \infty$) remains an open challenge. Future work will explore how these gap-edge quasiparticles behave in antiferromagnetic phases or under doping. Additionally, a major next step is determining how these sharp features might be detected experimentally using techniques like Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES).

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the Mott insulating state of the half-filled paramagnetic Hubbard model within dynamical mean field theory using a recently formulated stochastic and nonperturbative quantum impurity solver. The method is based on calculating the impurity self energy as a sample average over a representative distribution of impurity models solved by exact diagonalization. Due to the natural parallelization of the method, millions of poles are readily generated for the self energy which allows us to work with very small pole-broadening $\ensuremath{\eta}$. Solutions at small and large $\ensuremath{\eta}$ are qualitatively different; solutions at large $\ensuremath{\eta}$ show featureless Hubbard bands whereas solutions at small $\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremath{\le}0.001$ (in units of half bare band width) show a band of electronic quasiparticles with very small quasiparticle weight at the inner edge of the Hubbard bands. The validity of the results are supported by agreement within statistical error ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\text{QMC}}\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}4}$ on the imaginary frequency axis with calculations using a continuous time quantum Monte Carlo solver. Nevertheless, convergence with respect to finite size of the stochastic exact diagonalization solver remains to be rigourously established.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{granath2014signatures,
  author = {Mats Granath and Johan Schött},
  title = {{Signatures of coherent electronic quasiparticles in the paramagnetic Mott insulator}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.90.235129},
}
Figure