SiFT: uncovering hidden biological processes by probabilistic filtering of single-cell data

Zoe Piran, Mor NitzanNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Single-cell data often hides important biological signals within complex noise. SiFT is a new method that filters out known "nuisance" signals (like cell cycle or spatial location) from gene expression data, revealing previously obscured biological processes. This allows for a deeper understanding of cellular behavior in various biological contexts, from development to disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) allows us to measure the gene expression of individual cells, providing a detailed snapshot of cellular states. However, these datasets are incredibly complex. Cells simultaneously encode information about their identity, location, developmental stage, and interactions. Often, strong signals like spatial organization or cell cycle can overshadow weaker, but equally important, signals like temporal dynamics or subtle disease responses. Existing methods tend to focus on reconstructing or removing one specific signal, often requiring prior knowledge of marker genes or specific data structures. This leaves a gap for methods that can flexibly filter out any known signal to reveal other hidden biological processes, especially when that signal isn't easily defined by simple marker genes.

Methods

SiFT (Signal FilTering) is a kernel-based projection method. The core idea is to build a "similarity kernel" that captures how cells relate to each other based on the signal you want to filter out. This kernel is then used to project the gene expression data onto that signal. By subtracting this projection from the original data, SiFT effectively "filters" out the unwanted signal, leaving behind the residual variation that represents other biological processes.

Key components of SiFT:

  • Cell-cell similarity kernel: This is the heart of SiFT. It can be constructed in several ways:
  • Mapping kernel: Uses deterministic or stochastic mappings of cells to a domain (e.g., cell cycle stage, spatial coordinates, pseudotime bins).
  • k-nearest-neighbor (knn) kernel: Builds a neighborhood graph based on distances in a chosen representation (e.g., a subset of genes or a latent space).
  • Distance kernel: Directly uses distances between cells in a chosen representation.
  • Pre-computed kernel: Users can supply their own kernel if they have specific prior knowledge.
  • Projection and Filtering: The kernel is used to project the gene expression matrix onto the signal to be filtered. This projection is then subtracted from the original expression matrix, resulting in a "filtered" expression matrix.
  • Correction at Gene Expression Level: Crucially, SiFT performs this correction directly on the gene expression level, not in a latent space. This preserves the interpretability of individual genes and allows downstream analysis tools to be applied directly to the corrected data.

Datasets

SiFT was evaluated on several publicly available datasets:

  • Drosophila wing disc development: Used to demonstrate removal of cell cycle and sex signals.
  • Virtual tumor dataset (mESC): A synthetic dataset to test cell cycle removal and subclone separation.
  • Mammalian liver dataset: Used to enhance circadian clock signals by filtering spatial zonation.
  • Liver regeneration dataset: Spatial transcriptomics data to expose global subpopulations by filtering local spatial signals.
  • COVID-19 dataset (PBMCs): Used to identify disease-specific signatures by filtering healthy control signals.

The paper also mentions using the Heart Cell Atlas dataset for scalability benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Uncovering the "hidden": The core idea is that by explicitly removing a known, dominant signal, we can reveal other, subtler biological signals that were previously obscured. This is like removing background noise to hear a faint melody.
  • Flexibility in defining "nuisance" signals: SiFT isn't limited to specific types of signals. By allowing different kernel constructions (mapping, knn, distance) and accepting various forms of prior knowledge (labels, marker genes, spatial coordinates, pseudotime), it can filter a wide range of unwanted variations.
  • Gene-level correction: Performing filtering directly on gene expression, rather than a latent space, is a significant advantage for interpretability and compatibility with existing downstream analysis tools.
  • Robustness to kernel choice: The method shows good performance across different kernel types and hyperparameter choices, suggesting it's not overly sensitive to specific implementation details.

Key Results

  • Effective signal removal: SiFT successfully removed cell cycle and sex signals from Drosophila data, outperforming existing methods like regress_out and scVI in preserving biological variation.
  • Enhanced biological discovery:
    • In liver data, SiFT successfully filtered spatial zonation to reveal the temporal circadian clock signal.
  • In liver regeneration data, filtering spatial signals exposed previously hidden migratory hepatocyte subpopulations.
  • In COVID-19 data, filtering healthy signals identified disease-informative cell types and pathways.
  • Scalability: SiFT can scale to large datasets (hundreds of thousands of cells) using GPU acceleration, comparable to scVI.
  • Robustness to partial markers: SiFT showed minimal performance degradation even when provided with an incomplete or slightly perturbed set of marker genes, unlike scVI.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reliance on prior knowledge: SiFT's performance is inherently dependent on the quality and accuracy of the input mapping or prior knowledge used to construct the kernel. Inaccurate or coarse mappings can lead to signal loss.
  • Interpretation of corrected data: While SiFT corrects at the gene expression level, the output can contain negative values, and the data may no longer be strictly log-transformed. This might require adjustments for certain downstream analysis tools.
  • Statistical implications: The authors suggest further work to explore the statistical implications of applying common analysis tools to the corrected gene expression data.
  • Future directions: The authors envision SiFT as a foundational tool for uncovering complex biological structures in single-cell data, especially with the rise of multimodal assays. They also highlight the potential for further exploration of its statistical properties and applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cellular populations simultaneously encode multiple biological attributes, including spatial configuration, temporal trajectories, and cell-cell interactions. Some of these signals may be overshadowed by others and harder to recover, despite the great progress made to computationally reconstruct biological processes from single-cell data. To address this, we present SiFT, a kernel-based projection method for filtering biological signals in single-cell data, thus uncovering underlying biological processes. SiFT applies to a wide range of tasks, from the removal of unwanted variation in the data to revealing hidden biological structures. We demonstrate how SiFT enhances the liver circadian signal by filtering spatial zonation, recovers regenerative cell subpopulations in spatially-resolved liver data, and exposes COVID-19 disease-related cells, pathways, and dynamics by filtering healthy reference signals. SiFT performs the correction at the gene expression level, can scale to large datasets, and compares favorably to state-of-the-art methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{piran2024sift,
  author = {Zoe Piran and Mor Nitzan},
  title = {{SiFT: uncovering hidden biological processes by probabilistic filtering of single-cell data}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-44757-7},
}

Loading related content...

Figure