Sibling Relationships in Families of Autistic and Typical Children: Similarities and Differences in the Perspectives of Siblings and Mothers

Yonat Rum, Ditza A. Zachor, Yael Armony, Ella Daniel, Esther DromiJournal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2024 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates mothers' and siblings' perspectives regarding similarities and differences in siblingships with and without autism. Twenty-nine typical children whose younger siblings have a diagnosis of autism and their mothers constituted the 'autism group.' Forty-six typical children with younger typical siblings and their mothers constituted the 'typical group'. Children and mothers completed the Sibling Relationship Questionnaires and were interviewed. Children's reports illustrated similarities in sibling relationships across groups, with no between-group differences in overall warmth, conflict, rivalry, or relative power. Mothers of autistic children reported their children to have less warmth and closeness and less conflict with their siblings than mothers of typical children. More disagreement was found between mothers and children in the autism group than in the typical group. Mothers and children reported less intimacy and less quarreling between the siblings in the autism group than in the typical group. The findings highlight a typical-like experience for siblings of autistic children, while mothers' perspectives emphasize differences and challenges, reporting a pattern of decreased involvement.

Introduction

Sibling relationships are among the most enduring and influential bonds in a person's life. When one sibling is autistic, the dynamics of this relationship often come under scrutiny. However, research has frequently focused on psychological outcomes like stress rather than the quality of the bond itself. This study, published in the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, explores these nuances by comparing the perspectives of both mothers and typical siblings across families with and without autism.

The researchers identified a significant "perspective gap": while typical siblings of autistic children often describe their relationships as largely "normal"—characterized by both affection and conflict—mothers tend to perceive a pattern of decreased involvement and greater distance compared to typical families.

Methodology

The study employed a mixed-methods convergent design to capture a holistic view of sibling dynamics:

  • Quantitative Analysis: Participants completed the Sibling Relationship Questionnaire (SRQ), measuring four primary factors: Warmth/Closeness, Conflict, Rivalry, and Relative Status Power.
  • Qualitative Analysis: Participants engaged in uninterrupted five-minute interviews ("Tell me about your relationship..."), which were analyzed using inductive content analysis to identify recurring themes.
  • Statistical Comparison: MANOVAs were used to find group differences, and Pearson correlations measured the level of agreement between mothers and children.

Study Population and Datasets

The research involved 75 Israeli Hebrew-speaking families. The "Autism Group" consisted of 29 families with a typical older sibling and a younger sibling diagnosed with autism. The "Typical Group" consisted of 46 families with two typical siblings. The groups were matched on key demographic variables such as maternal education, age, and family income to ensure comparability.

Demographic characteristics of participating mothers and children across the Typical and Autism groups.

Key Findings: The Perspective Gap

The study's most striking finding is the divergence between how children and mothers view the sibling bond.

Sibling Perspectives

Typical siblings in the autism group reported levels of overall warmth, conflict, and rivalry similar to those in the typical group. For these children, the relationship is "typical-like." However, they did report significantly lower levels of intimacy (sharing secrets and emotions) and quarreling. This suggests a pattern of "decreased involvement"—the relationship is stable but perhaps less intense in its emotional peaks and valleys.

Mother Perspectives

In contrast, mothers of autistic children reported significantly less warmth/closeness ($p=.02$) and less conflict ($p=.012$) than mothers in the typical group. While mothers and children in typical families generally agreed on the quality of the relationship, those in the autism group only agreed on the level of conflict, showing a marked divergence in their perception of positive bonding.

Qualitative Insights

The interviews revealed deeper layers of the lived experience:

  • The "Unsaid Word": Participants in the autism group rarely used the formal term "autism." Instead, they spoke of "specificities" or "differences," suggesting the diagnosis is integrated into the family's daily reality as a "plain fact" rather than a clinical label.
  • Universal Ambivalence: Both groups expressed themes of being "inseparable," where affection and fighting are intertwined. This reinforces that a healthy sibling relationship is defined by the coexistence of these elements, not the absence of friction.

Conclusion and Clinical Implications

The findings suggest that while siblings experience a "typical-like" bond, mothers may be more sensitive to the developmental differences and challenges inherent in an autism-affected siblingship. Clinicians should value both perspectives: the sibling's view provides a foundation of strength and normalcy, while the mother's view may highlight areas where families need support to foster deeper emotional connection. Future research should aim to include the voices of autistic siblings themselves and track these relationships longitudinally to see how they evolve into adulthood.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates mothers' and siblings' perspectives regarding similarities and differences in siblingships with and without autism. Twenty-nine typical children (M<sub>age</sub> = 8.78 years, SD = 2.05) whose younger siblings have a diagnosis of autism and their mothers constituted the 'autism group.' Forty-six typical children (M<sub>age</sub> = 9.12 years, SD = 2.06) with younger typical siblings and their mothers constituted the 'typical group'. Children and mothers completed the Sibling Relationship Questionnaires and were interviewed. Children's reports illustrated similarities in sibling relationships across groups, with no between-group differences in overall warmth, conflict, rivalry, or relative power in the sibling relationship. Mothers of autistic children reported their children to have less warmth and closeness (F<sub>(1,72)</sub> = 5.63, p = .02, η<sup>2</sup> = .073) and less conflict (F<sub>(1,72)</sub> = 6.66, p = .012, η<sup>2</sup> = .085) with their siblings than mothers of typical children. More disagreement was found between mothers and children in the autism group than in the typical group. Mothers and children reported less intimacy and less quarreling between the siblings in the autism group than in the typical group. The qualitative analysis suggests that siblings focused on the present experience, while mothers also referred to processes in the sibling relationship. Interviewees in the autism group referred to various specificities in the siblingships without explicitly using the term "autism". The findings highlight a typical-like experience for siblings of autistic children. At the same time, mothers' perspectives emphasize differences and challenges in siblingships, reporting a pattern of decreased involvement. It is important to consider both perspectives in research and clinical work with families of autistic children.
BibTeX
@article{rum2024sibling,
  author = {Yonat Rum and Ditza A. Zachor and Yael Armony and Ella Daniel and Esther Dromi},
  title = {{Sibling Relationships in Families of Autistic and Typical Children: Similarities and Differences in the Perspectives of Siblings and Mothers}},
  journal = {Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s10803-023-06222-0},
}
Figure