Siberian carbon sink reduced by forest disturbances

Lei Fan, Jean‐Pierre Wigneron, Philippe Ciais, Jérôme Chave, Martin Brandt, Stephen Sitch, Chao Yue, Ana Bastos, Xin Li, Yuanwei Qin, Wenping Yuan, Dmitry Schepaschenko, Liudmila Mukhortova, Xiaojun Li, Xiangzhuo Liu, Mengjia Wang, Frédéric Frappart, Xiangming Xiao, Jingming Chen, Mingguo Ma, Jianguang Wen, Xiuzhi Chen, Hui Yang, Dave van Wees, Rasmus FensholtNature Geoscience 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Siberian forests, long thought to be a significant carbon sink, are showing a near-neutral carbon balance due to increased forest disturbances like fires and droughts. While greening trends are observed, they don't fully reflect carbon uptake, suggesting a decoupling between vegetation productivity and actual carbon storage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Siberia's vast boreal forests play a crucial role in the global carbon cycle, and for decades, they have been considered a substantial carbon sink. However, recent decades have seen rapid warming and an increase in extreme weather events, including severe droughts and widespread wildfires. These disturbances raise questions about the continued capacity of Siberian forests to absorb atmospheric CO2. Existing estimates of the Siberian forest carbon balance vary, and there's a lack of detailed, spatially explicit data to understand how these disturbances are impacting carbon dynamics. This paper aims to provide a more precise, up-to-date assessment of the Siberian forest carbon balance and to investigate the complex interplay between forest disturbances, vegetation greening, and carbon sequestration.

Methods

The study utilizes a novel approach combining passive microwave remote sensing data (specifically L-band Vegetation Optical Depth or L-VOD) with established forest inventory data and satellite observations. L-VOD is particularly useful because it's sensitive to biomass (including stems, branches, and leaves) and doesn't saturate in dense forests, unlike optical indices. It's also less affected by atmospheric conditions, making it suitable for high-latitude regions.

The researchers developed annual maps of above-ground biomass carbon (AGC) from 2010 to 2019 using L-VOD data calibrated against multiple global benchmark maps of forest carbon stocks. They then analyzed changes in both live above-ground carbon (AGClive) and total above-ground carbon (AGCtot), which includes dead wood. To understand the drivers of carbon loss, they separated contributions from forest area loss (due to clearcutting and stand-replacing fires) and forest degradation (less severe disturbances like low-intensity fires, droughts, and partial mortality). They also compared AGC trends with Leaf Area Index (LAI) trends to assess the decoupling between vegetation greenness and carbon uptake.

Datasets

  • L-VOD (L-band Vegetation Optical Depth): Derived from the SMOS-IC algorithm, used to estimate AGClive.
  • MODIS Vegetation Continuous Fields (MOD44B): Used for identifying tree cover.
  • Geoscience Laser Altimeter System (GLAS) forest canopy height product: Used for canopy height data.
  • MODIS Land Cover Map: Used for land cover classification.
  • Global Forest Resources Assessment (FAO): Used for general forest area dynamics.
  • MODIS LAI product (MCD15A2H): Used to track vegetation greenness.
  • Landsat forest area loss map ('yearloss'): Used to identify areas of forest loss.
  • Stand-replacing wildfires product: Used to estimate areas affected by wildfires.
  • Global SPEI database: Used to assess drought conditions.
  • Tree species map: Used to understand regional forest composition.
  • Global benchmark maps of forest carbon stocks: (Saatchi, CCI, GlobBiomass) used for calibrating L-VOD to AGClive.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Siberia's Carbon Sink is Weakening: The long-held assumption of a strong Siberian carbon sink is challenged; the region is now near neutral, with live biomass decreasing.
  • Decoupling of Greening and Carbon Uptake: Observed "greening" trends (increasing LAI) do not necessarily translate to increased carbon sequestration. This suggests that while vegetation may be recovering or growing, it's not effectively storing that carbon.
  • Disturbances Dominate: Wildfires and droughts are the primary drivers of AGClive loss, significantly impacting the carbon balance.
  • Dead Wood Accumulation Buffers Loss: While live biomass is declining, an increase in dead wood carbon (specifically coarse woody debris) is partially offsetting these losses, contributing to the near-neutral overall carbon balance.
  • Slow Carbon Recovery: Post-fire recovery of above-ground carbon is significantly slower than the recovery of vegetation greenness (LAI), highlighting a long-term impact of disturbances.

Key Results

  • Overall Carbon Balance: The Siberian forests showed a near-neutral carbon balance from 2010-2019, with a small net sink of +0.02 ± 0.03 PgC yr⁻¹.
  • Live Biomass Loss: AGClive experienced a net loss of -0.08 ± 0.08 PgC yr⁻¹ during the study period.
  • Dead Wood Gain: Carbon storage in dead wood increased by +0.10 ± 0.09 PgC yr⁻¹.
  • Drivers of Loss: Approximately 43% of AGClive loss was attributed to forest area loss, and 57% to degradation. Stand-replacing wildfires accounted for 62% of the gross AGClive loss from forest area loss.
  • LAI vs. AGC: In fire-affected areas, LAI recovered to pre-fire levels within six years, while AGClive remained about 11% below its pre-fire level seven years after the event.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Resolution: The ~25 km spatial resolution of the L-VOD data makes it difficult to precisely separate the contributions of climate (drought, heatwave) and fire to AGClive/LAI changes, as well as to distinguish fine-scale carbon gains and losses from various disturbances.
  • Data Availability: Limitations in MODIS LAI data availability (due to cloud cover) can introduce temporal scale-dependent effects and complicate the interpretation of greening/browning trends.
  • Other Carbon Pools: The study focused on above-ground carbon (live biomass and dead wood) and did not assess changes in soil organic matter or litter, which are also important components of the carbon cycle.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research is needed to disentangle the complex interactions between climate, disturbances, and carbon dynamics. They emphasize the importance of preventing disturbances and enhancing forest resilience to maintain the boreal region as a carbon sink. Future work could also benefit from integrating more in-situ data to corroborate remote sensing findings and improve the accuracy of carbon flux estimates.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{fan2022siberian,
  author = {Lei Fan and Jean‐Pierre Wigneron and Philippe Ciais and Jérôme Chave and Martin Brandt and Stephen Sitch and Chao Yue and Ana Bastos and Xin Li and Yuanwei Qin and Wenping Yuan and Dmitry Schepaschenko and Liudmila Mukhortova and Xiaojun Li and Xiangzhuo Liu and Mengjia Wang and Frédéric Frappart and Xiangming Xiao and Jingming Chen and Mingguo Ma and Jianguang Wen and Xiuzhi Chen and Hui Yang and Dave van Wees and Rasmus Fensholt},
  title = {{Siberian carbon sink reduced by forest disturbances}},
  booktitle = {Nature Geoscience},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41561-022-01087-x},
}
Figure