Shrinkage Model Selection for Portfolio Optimization on Vietnam Stock Market

Nhat Minh Nguyen, Nguyễn Đức Trung, Tuan Tran, An MaiJournal of Asian Finance Economics and Business 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This paper provides the practical application of a linear shrinkage framework on the Vietnam stock market. The cumulative data points observed in this analysis are 468 weeks from January 2011 to December 2019. All companies listed on the Ho Chi Minh City Stock Exchange (HOSE), excluding those within a two-year period from their Initial Public Offering (IPO), are considered, totaling 350 companies. The VNINDEX is used as a reference index for shrinking to a single-index model. Empirical results demonstrate that the shrinkage of the covariance matrix for portfolio optimization yields promising results for investors, producing optimal portfolios with higher profits and lower risk compared to traditional Sample Covariance Matrix (SCM) methods. Furthermore, the shrinkage method maintains low portfolio turnover, saving transaction costs and reducing liquidity risks. The profit-making ability of the shrinkage method is further confirmed by a high positive Alpha coefficient.

Introduction: The Challenge of Covariance Estimation

Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) is the cornerstone of quantitative finance, aiming to determine the optimal weight for each asset to maximize returns for a given level of risk. However, MPT relies heavily on the accurate estimation of the covariance matrix—a representation of how assets move in relation to one another.

In a market like Vietnam’s, with hundreds of listed companies, the number of parameters to estimate grows quadratically. When the number of stocks is large relative to available historical data, the traditional Sample Covariance Matrix (SCM) often becomes "ill-conditioned" or non-invertible. This leads to significant estimation errors, causing portfolio weights to fluctuate wildly, which results in poor real-world performance and high transaction costs.

Methodology

To mitigate these issues, the researchers applied Linear Shrinkage. This technique creates a weighted average between the noisy, unstable SCM ($S$) and a structured, stable target matrix ($F$):

$$\Sigma_{Shrinkage} = (1 - \sigma)S + \sigma F$$

where $\sigma$ represents the "shrinkage intensity." The study evaluated three distinct targets:

  1. Single-Index Model (SIM): Assumes stocks are primarily driven by the market index (VNINDEX).
  2. Constant Correlation Model (CCM): Assumes every pair of stocks shares the same average correlation.
  3. Identity Matrix (STIM): A neutral target assuming zero correlation between stocks.

The study utilized a rolling-window back-testing procedure on 350 stocks from the HOSE. The model "learned" from a 104-week window to predict optimal weights for the subsequent week, repeating this across the nearly decade-long dataset.

Rolling window back-testing procedure used for model evaluation.

Key Results and Discussion

The back-testing results (2013–2019) showed a clear victory for shrinkage across all metrics compared to the traditional SCM baseline.

Metric Traditional (SCM) Shrinkage (SCCM/STIM)
Average Annual Return 10.28% 16.5% – 18.82%
Average Volatility 8.97% 6.5% – 7.49%
Sharpe Ratio 0.68 1.71 – 1.72
Daily Turnover 7.04% 2.26% – 2.64%
Max Drawdown -23.68% -8.2% – -8.44%
Jensen's Alpha 4.19% 9.59% – 11.36%
Annual returns for the SSIM shrinkage model (2013-2019) showing consistent positive performance compared to the baseline.

One of the most significant findings was the stability of the shrinkage portfolios. While SCM-based portfolios required changing 7.04% of the portfolio daily, shrinkage models reduced this "churn" to approximately 2.2-2.6%. In emerging markets, this reduction in turnover is vital for saving brokerage fees and managing liquidity. Interestingly, the simplest target—the Identity Matrix (STIM)—performed remarkably well, suggesting that in noisy emerging markets, assuming zero correlation is often more effective than attempting to estimate complex relationships from unstable data.

Conclusion

Linear shrinkage provides a robust framework for portfolio optimization in the Vietnam stock market. By balancing empirical data with structured targets, investors can achieve higher risk-adjusted returns and significantly lower transaction costs. Future research may explore non-linear shrinkage or multi-factor models to further enhance these results.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper provides the practical application of a linear shrinkage framework on Vietnam stock market. The cumulative data points observed in this analysis are 468 weeks from January 2011 to December 2019. All the companies listed on Ho Chi Minh City Stock Exchange (HOSE), except the companies under two years period from Initial Public Offering (IPO), are considered. The cumulative number of stocks picked is therefore 350 companies. The VNINDEX, which is the Vietnam Stock Index, is used as a reference index for shrinking to a single-index model. The empirical results show that the shrinkage of covariance matrix for portfolio optimization gives the promising results for the investors on Vietnam stock market. The shrinkage method helps the investors to produce the optimal portfolio in the sense of having higher profit with lower levels of risk compared to the portfolio of the traditional SCM method. Moreover, the portfolio turnover of shrinkage method is always kept at low magnitudes, and this makes the shrinkage portfolios save much transaction costs and reduce the liquidity risks in the trading process. In addition, the ability of shrinkage method in making profit is once again confirmed by the Alpha coefficient that achieves a high positive value.
BibTeX
@article{nguyen2020shrinkage,
  author = {Nhat Minh Nguyen and Nguyễn Đức Trung and Tuan Tran and An Mai},
  title = {{Shrinkage Model Selection for Portfolio Optimization on Vietnam Stock Market}},
  journal = {Journal of Asian Finance Economics and Business},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.13106/jafeb.2020.vol7.no9.135},
}
Figure