Shrinkage in Tokyo’s Central Business District: Large-Scale Redevelopment in the Spatially Shrinking Office Market

Kohei Kawai, Masatomo Suzuki, Chihiro ShimizuSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that Tokyo's office market is spatially shrinking from its fringes, driven by large-scale redevelopment in the central business district (CBD) following the 1990s asset bubble. This shrinkage leads to increased vacancies and lower rent premiums for older, suburban office properties, demonstrating that the "shrinking city" concept applies even to service sector workplaces in major metropolises.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While global metropolises are often associated with growth, they can also face "shrinkage," a phenomenon typically understood as declining populations and economic activity. This paper investigates a less-explored aspect of shrinkage: the spatial contraction of the office market within a major global city, Tokyo. Specifically, it addresses how the office market's geographical footprint has changed over time, particularly in the context of Japan's shrinking labor force since 1995 and Tokyo's significant urban regeneration efforts. The study aims to understand if and how the "shrinking city" concept, usually applied to residential populations and declining industries, manifests in the spatial distribution and performance of service sector workplaces.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Spatial Analysis of Office Supply: The researchers quantify the geographical distribution of office supply over a 30-year period (pre-bubble, during bubble, and post-bubble) using GIS data. This involves mapping office buildings based on their vintage, size, and distance from the CBD.
  • Hedonic Regression Analysis: To assess the economic consequences of shrinkage, hedonic regression models are used to analyze office rents. These models control for various property characteristics (vintage, size, distance from CBD, time to nearest station) and time-specific factors (year fixed effects) to isolate the rent premium associated with each attribute. The analysis specifically examines how these premiums change over time, particularly around the 2007 economic upturn.
  • Vacancy Rate Analysis: Time-series data on vacancy rates for office properties are analyzed, categorized by vintage, size, and distance from the CBD, to identify trends and consequences of market shrinkage.

Datasets

  • Xymax Corporation Data: A property-level panel dataset covering over half of Tokyo's office building stock since 2001. This data includes building characteristics (year built, floor area, geocodes), newly contracted rents, and occupancy/vacancy status.
  • Tokyo Metropolitan Government (TMG) Data: Building-use GIS data for Tokyo's 23 special wards for selected years (1991, 1996, 2001, 2006, 2011). This dataset provides a comprehensive snapshot of building stock and is used to quantify net new office supply.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Shrinkage is Real for Offices: Contrary to the assumption of continuous urban expansion, Tokyo's office market is demonstrably shrinking spatially, with new supply concentrating closer to the CBD over time.
  • CBD Redevelopment as a Driver: Large-scale redevelopment in Tokyo's CBD, particularly after the 1990s asset bubble, has played a crucial role in this spatial contraction, drawing new development inward.
  • Suburban Office Properties Suffer: Older, smaller office buildings in the fringe areas are experiencing increased vacancies and lower rent premiums, even during periods of general economic recovery. This highlights a spatial disparity in market performance.
  • "Shrinking City" Concept Extends to Workplaces: The study provides strong evidence that the "shrinking city" phenomenon is not limited to residential populations or declining industries but also applies to the spatial dynamics of service sector workplaces in a central metropolis.
  • Opportunity for Compact Urban Form: The paper suggests that allowing strategic redevelopment in central areas, even amidst shrinking demand, can lead to a more compact and potentially sustainable urban form.

Key Results

  • Office Supply Area Shrinking: The geographical area of new office supply has contracted from the fringes towards the CBD over the past 30 years, particularly after the bubble period.
  • Vacancy Rates Higher in Suburbs: Older office properties in suburban and fringe areas (beyond 10 km from the CBD) show higher vacancy rates, especially after the 2007 economic upturn, indicating a decline in demand for these locations.
  • Rent Premiums Decline for Older Properties: Hedonic regression analysis shows that the rent premium for older properties has decreased over time, suggesting lower demand for them compared to newer buildings.
  • CBD Properties Maintain Premiums: Large, new properties in the central area continue to command higher rent premiums.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations on Replacements: The study acknowledges that buildings that were replaced (demolished and rebuilt) during the bubble period are not fully captured by the dataset. These replacements could have improved office quality or converted to other uses (e.g., residential), which would impact the overall shrinkage narrative.
  • Future Research on Adaptation Processes: The authors suggest that future research should formally clarify the adaptation processes occurring in shrinking metropolises, such as the conversion of office space to other uses. This would provide a more complete understanding of how shrinkage is managed and whether it is a "hopeless phenomenon."
  • Broader Implications for Shrinking Cities: While the study focuses on Tokyo, it implies that these findings could be relevant for other large metropolises, particularly in East Asia and Europe, facing similar demographic and economic shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although metropolises continue to grow worldwide, they face the risk of shrinkage. This study seeks to capture and contextualize the “shrinkage” of the office market in Tokyo, a city that is one of the largest in the world but whose labor force has been shrinking since 1995. Employing unique property-level data on office building performance and use, this study quantifies the geographical distribution of office supply over time and shows that the geographical area of office supply is shrinking from the fringes, in line with the large-scale redevelopment of the central area since the collapse of the asset bubble in the early 1990s. As a result, analyses of changes in the vacancy rate and rent premium (from hedonic regressions) suggest that old office properties in the suburbs have recently faced more vacancies and lower rent premiums, even during the upturn peak of around 2007. This evidence suggests that (i) the concept of shrinking cities is also applicable in a spatial context, even for service sector workplaces in a nation’s central metropolis, and that (ii) allowing large-scale redevelopment in the central area while the economy remains powerful can transform the metropolis into a more compact form, which may be desirable in the long run.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kawai2019shrinkage,
  author = {Kohei Kawai and Masatomo Suzuki and Chihiro Shimizu},
  title = {{Shrinkage in Tokyo’s Central Business District: Large-Scale Redevelopment in the Spatially Shrinking Office Market}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11102742},
}
Figure