Showcasing Interdisciplinary Capabilities: Employers’ Perceptions on Reflective ePortfolios

Chi‐Ning Chang, Clinton A. Patterson, Courtney Lavadia, Debra Fowler, Raymundo Arróyave2020 · DOI

Introduction

In an era where global challenges are increasingly complex, single-discipline solutions are often insufficient. In the field of Materials Science and Engineering, the White House’s 2011 Materials Genome Initiative (MGI) highlighted the need for an interdisciplinary approach, integrating informatics and design into traditional engineering frameworks. As the job market evolves to favor these hybrid skill sets, a critical question arises: how can the next generation of engineers effectively demonstrate their interdisciplinary fluency to potential employers?

While traditional CVs are effective at listing publications and degrees, they often fail to capture "reflective ability"—the capacity to synthesize knowledge across domains and learn from research setbacks. This study investigates the value of reflective ePortfolios as a tool for PhD students to bridge this communication gap and enhance their competitiveness in industry, academia, and national laboratories.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a qualitative study centered on seven doctoral students enrolled in a specialized interdisciplinary program at the intersection of materials science, engineering design, and informatics. Over a two-year period, these students developed digital ePortfolios using Google Sites. These portfolios consisted of two primary sections: a Personal Profile (biography, CV, and core skills) and a Learning Portfolio (course outcomes and reflective posts).

Timeline of the interdisciplinary program and ePortfolio development stages.

To evaluate the impact of these tools, the researchers recruited ten high-level hiring influencers—including CEOs, professors, and national lab directors—to review the portfolios and provide feedback via surveys. The data was analyzed using deductive content analysis to identify key themes regarding employer expectations and portfolio effectiveness.

Key Insights: What Employers Value

The "Connective Tissue" of Research

Employers noted that while a CV lists achievements, the ePortfolio provides the "data" of a candidate’s professional thought process. One industry CEO described the portfolio as an asset that reveals the researcher's working style and personality, helping to determine organizational fit far better than a static document.

The Power of Reflection and Honesty

Surprisingly, employers highly valued "honesty and frankness" regarding research struggles. Reflection posts that detailed failed experiments or how a student navigated the "messiness" of multidisciplinary collaboration were seen as indicators of professional maturity and self-motivation. This transparency allows employers to gauge how a candidate handles the unpredictable nature of high-level research.

Visual Communication and Navigation

The study highlighted a strong preference for visual data over text-heavy descriptions. Employers favored "graphical representations of scientific work," which allowed them to assess impact quickly. However, they also warned of "unfriendly navigation"; portfolios with excessive subpages or broken links were cited as major deterrents for busy hiring managers.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The findings suggest a unanimous approval of ePortfolios among employers across all sectors. For students, the most successful portfolios are those that allow a reviewer to assess "fit" almost entirely from the homepage summary while using graphics to tell a compelling story of their interdisciplinary journey.

Future research will look toward integrating these reflective practices into mainstream professional platforms like LinkedIn and conducting larger-scale studies to correlate ePortfolio use with long-term job placement rates for PhD graduates. By moving beyond the CV, students can provide a more holistic, data-driven view of their capabilities to the modern workforce.

Summary updated

Abstract

Disciplines in isolation cannot furnish solutions to the world's complex problems. Trends within the materials science and engineering fields revealed materials development was slow to offer solutions for the practical needs of advancing technology. The Materials Genome Initiative (MGI), announced by the White House in 2011, recommended an interdisciplinary approach utilizing an informatics framework in materials discovery and development. With more employment opportunities brought about by the MGI, it is important to teach the next generation of engineers and scientists how to show employers their interdisciplinary capabilities. Creating an ePortfolio is a common, useful solution in engineering education. Students not only can display their learning experiences and research projects, but also can enhance their reflection ability, a critical skill for interdisciplinary education and research. However, few ePortfolio studies have indicated the perceived value employers have on a student's reflective ability. To fill the literature gap and provide suggestions on developing ePortfolios, our study investigated how a reflective ePortfolio enhances student's competitiveness for future positions from the perspective of employers. We recruited seven doctoral students from an interdisciplinary program designed at the intersection of materials science, engineering design, and informatics as a response to MGI's call. With the completion of two-year training, these students have finished their ePortfolio including personal profiles, learning experience, and reflection posts. We invited employers from the academia, industry, and national lab to review their ePortfolio and complete a survey. Based on the results, we presented comprehensive suggestions for developing an impactful ePortfolio.
BibTeX
@misc{chang2020showcasing,
  author = {Chi‐Ning Chang and Clinton A. Patterson and Courtney Lavadia and Debra Fowler and Raymundo Arróyave},
  title = {{Showcasing Interdisciplinary Capabilities: Employers’ Perceptions on Reflective ePortfolios}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.18260/1-2--33264},
}
Figure